2021 MFP Report

v

Report on the CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest under
the Mining Forest Program

I. Introduction

The Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) launched the
“Adopt-A-Tree, Adopt-A-Mining Forest Movement” under DENR Administrative
Order (DAO) No. 22, Series of 1989, calling for the establishment of mining forests
within specified area by qualified applicants. The National Executive Committee
(NEC), created under DENR Special Order No. 293, Series of 1989, and reconstituted
through DENR Special Order No. 184, Series of 2004, manages the movement, sets
the pertinent rules and regulations, formulates the criteria for the selection of the
winners of the “Best Mining Forest Contest” and determines the winners thereof based
on such criteria.

On October 26, 2005, NEC Resolution No. 2005-02 changed the name of the
movement into “Mining Forest Program (MFP).” During its meetings on November
28, 2007 and July 25, 2008, the NEC made significant revisions of the criteria and
rating system for the selection of winners in reference to the contest, and further
categorized it into metallic, non-metallic, exploration and mineral processing plant.

Given the unprecedented COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, an offsite validation and
selection was conducted for the CY 2020 and 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest to
continue the implementation of the DAO No. 22, Series of 1989.

Through a Memorandum dated June 22, 2021, the Mines and Geosciences Bureau
(MGB) Central Office (CO), as head of the NEC, issued the call for the CY 2021 Best
Mining Forest Contest nominees to all Mining Contractors, Permittees and Permit
Holders involved in active exploration, surface or underground mining operation,
quarry operation and mineral processing.

II. Objectives

The Best Mining Forest Contest generally aims to recognize Mining Contractors/
Permit Holders/Permittees’ exemplary performance in the implementation of its MFP
as one of the strategies in achieving effective progressive rehabilitation. Likewise, the
Best Mining Forest Contest is a component in the selection of the Presidential Mineral
Industry Environmental Award (PMIEA) under environmental management criteria.

The following are the specific objectives of the Best Mining Forest Contest under the
MFP:

(1) incorporate rehabilitation strategies in mined-out and other areas through
reforestation;

(2) conserve the forests as a natural habitat for fauna and flora;
(3) preserve existing soil and water conditions;
(4) increase and protect the value of vegetation and biological diversity;

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 1

(5) promote community participation in the reforestation activities;
(6) intensify IEC on reforestation activities; and
(7) contribute to climate change mitigation.

The offsite validation and selection of the winners for the CY 2021 Best Mining Forest
Contest aims to provide alternative mode of evaluation of the accomplishment of the
MFP of companies, while taking into priority the safety and well-being of the NEC,
personnel of MGB CO and Regional Offices (ROs), and the organization of the
nominated mining/quarry/mineral processing/exploration companies during the
COVID-19 pandemic.

III. Scope

The offsite validation of the CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest covered the
performance and accomplishments of the Mining Contractors/Permit
Holders/Permittees for the implementation of their respective Mining Forest Program
for the coverage period, which is July 2020 to June 2021.

The offsite validation of the CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest included the following
activities:

1. Call for Nominations;
2. Pre-evaluation and Endorsement of MGB Regional Offices;
3. Initial Review and Evaluation;
4. Initial Deliberation of NEC;
5. Virtual Presentation;
6. Offsite Validation; and
7. Final Deliberation and Review of NEC.

IV. Requirements for the Best Mining Forest Contest
Applications

a. Eligibility Rules and Restrictions

The contest is open to all companies involved in mining/quarry/mineral
processing/exploration operations in the Philippines. There shall be four (4)
categories: Metallic, Nonmetallic, Exploration, and Mineral Processing. In
each category, four (4) awardees will be chosen: Winner, 1st Runner-Up, 2nd
Runner–Up, and 3rd Runner-Up according to respective criteria and rating
system (NEC Circular Nos. 2008-01 and 2008-02).

b. Minimum Requirements for Qualification

1. With approved Environmental Protection and Enhancement Program
(EPEP) and has submitted Final Mine Rehabilitation/Decommissioning
Plan (FMR/DP) (for operating mine/plant), Environmental Work Program
(EWP) (for exploration), Care and Maintenance Program (CMP) (for

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 2

company that temporarily stopped operation due to force majeure,
economic, security reasons and the like) pursuant to MGB Memorandum
Order 2020-001;

2. Has not been suspended due to violations of mining and environmental
laws, rules and regulations;

3. Has submitted its Semi-annual MFP Accomplishment Reports (July-
December of the previous year and January–June of the current year),
which are in conformance with MFP Form No. 2008-01 and duly endorsed
by the MGB Regional Office (RO) concerned to the MGB Central Office
(CO).

4. Has submitted MFP Accomplishments by 15th of July of the current year.
Companies with different permits (e.g. MPSA, MPP), but with common
reforestation areas shall be required to submit separate reports indicating
therein their distinct accomplishments.

5. With a rating of at least seventy-five percent (75%) to qualify as
contender/s, based on the pre-evaluation of all submitted reports to the
MGB Central Office, which shall be validated by the MFP-NEC for the
selection of awardees.

c. Entry Specifications

The CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest entry of each Mining
Contractor/Permit Holder/Permittee shall be composed of the following:

• Mining Forest Program Write-up

The narrative entry must include highlights of MFP performance and
accomplishment of the Mining Contractor/Permit Holder/Permittee for
the coverage period. The write-up shall follow the format/specifications
below:

o Paper size: A4 (8.2” x 11.69”)
o Maximum number of pages: 10
o Font Size: 12
o Line Spacing: 1.5

• Validated MFP Capturing Sheet

Electronic copy of the documents listed in Annex A shall be submitted
as annex of the MFP write-up.

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 3

• Audio-visual presentation

An audio-visual presentation (AVP) shall be prepared together with the
narrative entry of submission. It must provide highlight of the nature of
the mining/quarry/mineral processing/mineral exploration project and
the MFP accomplishment for the coverage period. The Mining
Contractor/Permit Holder/Permittee may showcase its best practices
through the presentation of photographs, videos, testimonies, etc. List
of areas/facilities and activities to be highlighted in the AVP is provided
in Annex B.

Mining Contractors/Permit Holder/Permittees are encouraged to
engage in in-house production for the preparation of the AVP.
Moreover, it is suggested to use photos and videos with time stamps.
The date indicated in the documentation shall not be earlier than July
2020.

The said audio-visual presentation shall be limited to ten (10) minutes.

V. Methodology

The application review for the Best Mining Forest Contest consists of seven (7)
stages, as follows:

a. Call for Nominations and Endorsement of the MGB Regional Offices

The NEC, through the Head of the Technical Secretariat, shall call for
nominees for the Best Mining Forest Contest. MGB CO shall provide MGB
Ros the required specifications of the MFP entry and the list of the MFP
minimum requirements.

b. Pre-evaluation and endorsement of the MGB Regional Office; and
submission of entries/nomination to MGB CO

The MGB RO concerned shall review the entry of each Contractor/Permit
Holder/Permittee to determine the compliance with the minimum
requirements stipulated in the whole Section VI hereof.

Pre-evaluation of the MGB Ros shall include the following activities:

• Review of the submitted MFP entry;
• Conduct of onsite validation or virtual meeting with the

Contractor/Permit Holder/Permittee;
• Preparation of narrative justification as to why the

Contractors/Permit Holder/Permittee is being nominated.

The endorsement of the MGB RO shall include the following:
accomplished MFP checklist on the minimum requirements; MGB RO
Validated MFP Capturing Sheet; and narrative justification.

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 4

The endorsement of the MGB RO shall be included in the MFP entry to
be submitted to MGB CO. All entries shall be endorsed/forwarded via
electronic mail ([email protected]) to MGB CO not later than
August 20, 2021.

c. Initial Review and Evaluation

The Head of the Secretariat, through the TS/MSESDD, shall conduct initial
review and evaluation of the application reports duly endorsed by the
Regional Offices. List of the shortlisted/qualified applicants shall be
endorsed by the TS/MSESDD to the MFP-NEC.

The initial evaluation shall be based on the Best Mining Forest Contest
minimum requirements. Arising issues and concerns shall also be
reviewed prior to the presentation to MFP-NEC.

The formation of the MFP-NEC Validation Team shall commence once
the list of shortlisted companies is finalized. The composition of the teams
shall be finalized prior to presentation to the MFP-NEC.

d. Initial Deliberation of the NEC

The MFP-NEC shall deliberate on the results of the initial review and
evaluation conducted by the TS/MSESDD and agree on the findings and
qualified applicants’ scores. The matters to be discussed during the initial
deliberation shall be based on the scope of the initial evaluation.

A consensus shall be then discussed to determine eligibility of the
qualified applicants for the virtual presentation and offsite validation. The
NEC, upon recommendation of the Secretariat and TS, shall confirm
eligibility of nominees based on the requirements provided above.

The list of the shortlisted companies and the corresponding validation
teams shall be provided to the MFP-NEC. The members of the committee
shall indicate which team will they be joining.

Shortlisted Contractors/Permit Holders/Permittees shall be notified on the
schedule of virtual presentation to the MFP-NEC. Disqualified companies
shall be notified through the provision of Letter of Regret.

e. Virtual Presentation of Contractors/Permit Holders/Permittees

Each shortlisted MFP nominee shall be required to present the highlight
of the nature of the mining/mineral processing/mineral exploration project
and the MFP accomplishment for the coverage period through an AVP.

Twenty (20) minutes shall be allotted for question-and-answer (Q and A)
with the representatives of the Contractors/Permit Holders/Permittees.

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 5

The MFP-NEC may request for additional supporting documents, as
deemed necessary, during Q and A.

f. Offsite Validation

Offsite validation shall be conducted by the NEC Validation Team based
on the submitted entry document and presentation.

The offsite validation shall include the following activities:

o Review of the MFP write-up and supporting documents

All MFP entries will be made available to the MFP-NEC Validation
Team after the set deadline for submission. The validation teams
shall conduct table review on the submitted write-up, supporting
documents and AVP.

o Virtual meeting with company representatives

Virtual technical conference with the Contractors/Permit
Holders/Permittees can be conducted, if determined as necessary
by the validation team. Interview with the key personnel of the
company can be performed during the virtual meeting.

Also, presentation of the current situation in the mine site, through
live video tour, is encouraged if the internet connection in the mine
site allows.

o Scoring of the MFP-NEC Validation Team

The TS shall provide initial rating based on the evaluation
conducted. The rating shall be discussed with the MFP-NEC
member/s within the team for approval.

o Submission of Scoresheets to the TS

The result of the validation shall be embodied in the Best Mining
Forest Contest scoresheets. Each team shall submit the
accomplished scoresheets to MSESDD – Mine Rehabilitation
Section for tabulation of the rating.

g. Final Deliberation and Review of the NEC

The NEC shall review the submission, validation report and scoresheet
summary. It shall determine and declare the recipients of the award.

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 6

VI. Results and Discussions

The following are the highlights of the selection process undertaken for the CY
2021 Best Mining Forest Contest:

a. Initial Deliberation with NEC

During the NEC initial deliberation meeting on September 8, 2021, out of the
thirty (30) companies endorsed by MGB ROs, twenty-eight (28) companies
complied with the minimum requirements, and achieved a minimum score of
75%, were approved by the NEC as the official list of contenders for the CY 2021
Best Mining Forest Contest:

Metallic Category

Agata Mining Ventures, Inc. – Agata Nickel Marcventures Mining & Development Corp. –
Laterite Direct Shipping Ore (DSO) Project MMDC Nickel Mining Project

Apex Mining Co., Inc. – Maco Gold Project Philex Mining Corporation – Sto. Tomas II Padcal
Berong Nickel Corp. – Berong Nickel Project Mine
Philsaga Mining Corporation – Co-o Gold Project

Platinum Group Metals Corp. – Cagdianao Nickel
Cagdianao Mining Corporation – Valencia Nickel Expansion Project (as operator of MPSA No. 007-
Project 92-X of Surigao Integrated Resources
Corporation)

FCF Minerals Corp. – Runruno Gold- Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation – Nickel
Molybdenum Project Laterite Project

Hinatuan Mining Corporation – Taganaan-Nickel Taganito Mining Corporation – Taganito Nickel
Project Project

Lepanto Consolidated Mining Co. – 2,500 MTD Zambales Diversified Metals Corporation – Sta
Gold and Copper Mining Project Cruz-Candelaria Mining Project

Non-metallic Category

Eagle Cement Corporation – Eagle Cement Republic Cement & Building Materials, Inc. –
Expansion Project Batangas – 2.5 MMTPY Cement Manufacturing
Complex, Quarrying, Power Plant, Wharf and
Other Facilities Project

Holcim Mining and Development Corp. – Republic Cement & Building Materials, Inc. –
Bulacan – Doric Claim Quarry 3 Limestone Bulacan –Quarry and Cement Manufacturing with
Quarry Additional 1.5 MMTPY Finish Mill Project

Holcim Mining and Development Corp. – Davao Republic Cement Mindanao, Inc. (Consolidation
– Limestone Quarry Project of Quarry Projects)

Holcim Resources and Development Corp. – Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation – Gotok
Limestone and Shale Quarry Expansion Project Limestone Quarry Project

Lafarge Holcim Aggregates, Inc. (as operator of MPSA Nos. 032-95-IV and 055-96-IV of Concrete
Aggregates Corporation) – Aggregate Mining and Processing Expansion Project

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 7

Mineral Processing Plant Category

Coral Bay Nickel Corporation – CBNC Mindanao Mineral Processing and Refining Corp.
Expansion Project – Co-o Gold Project

Graymont Philippines, Inc. – Lime Milk Plant Taganito HPAL Nickel Corp. – Taganito
Project Hydrometallurgical Processing Plant Project

Exploration Category

Philex Mining Corporation

Republic Cement & Building Materials, Inc.- Teresa was disqualified due to
failure to meet the minimum rating of seventy-five percent (75%) while Philippine
Mining Services Corp. - Bohol was disqualified due to non-submission of
minimum requirements, based on the pre-evaluation of all submitted reports to
the MGB CO.

The following attended the NEC Initial Deliberation:

Name Agency Position
Engr. Roland De Jesus, CESO V DENR-Mines and Asst. Director
Geosciences Bureau
For. Roberto Oliveros NEC Member
(MGB)
Mr. Rommel Baybayon NEC Member
DENR Office of the
For. Jesus Javier Undersecretary for NEC Member
Mining and Muslim
For. Dona Riza Gopez NEC Member
For. Randelle Ralph Canicosa Affairs NEC Member
Engr. Therese Gonzales NEC Member
DENR Office of the
For. Mark Anthony Tuliao Undersecretary for Field NEC Member
Ms. Raquel Ortega NEC Member
Mr. Jayson Pujeda Operations and NEC Member
Environment
Mr. Kelvin Balaquit NEC Member
Mr. Jeffrey Jaymes Mesias DENR- Forest NEC Member
Engr. Marcial H. Mateo Management Bureau Head, NEC
Technical
(FMB) Secretariat (TS)

DENR-FMB

DENR-FMB

DENR- Environmental
Management Bureau

(BMB)

DENR-EMB

DENR-EMB

DENR- Biodiversity
Management Bureau

(BMB)

DENR- BMB
DENR- BMB

DENR-MGB

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 8

For. Teodorico L. Marquez, Jr. DENR-MGB NEC TS
For. Blessed Joy P. Gibe DENR-MGB Members
Engr. Christine Battung-Baladad DENR-MGB
Engr. Aerold Louise Firmeza DENR-MGB
Engr. Danny P. Berches DENR-MGB
Mr. Gilbert Aquino DENR-MGB
Engr. Robert Glicer M. Domingo DENR-MGB
For. Christian Kevin A. Latiza DENR-MGB
Engr. Christian Philip Umerez DENR-MGB
Engr. Celeste Aquino DENR-MGB
Engr. Corazon Ferrer DENR-MGB
Engr. Ivy Kimberly Batecan DENR-MGB
Mr. Gerold Allen Argonoso DENR-MGB
Engr. Jade Mark Santos DENR-MGB
Engr. Genesis Madera DENR-MGB
Ms. Shenalie Taloza DENR-MGB

NEC Initial Deliberation Meeting on September 8, 2021

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 9

b. Virtual Presentation

The two-day virtual presentation of the 30 contenders was held on September
20-21, 2021 via Microsoft Team and was attended by the following:

Name Agency Position
Engr. Roland De Jesus, CESO DENR-Mines and Asst. Director
V Geosciences Bureau
NEC Member
For. Roberto Oliveros (MGB)
DENR Office of the NEC Member
Mr. Rommel Baybayon Undersecretary for Mining
and Muslim Affairs NEC Member
For. Dona Riza Gopez DENR Office of the
Undersecretary for Field NEC Member
For. Randelle Ralph Canicosa NEC Member
Engr. Therese Gonzales Operations and
Environment NEC Member
For. Mark Anthony Tuliao DENR-Forest NEC Member
Engr. Jose Paolo Aragoncillo NEC Member
Ms. Juvy Ladisla Management Bureau
(FMB) NEC Member
Ms. Argean Guiya NEC Member
Mr. Kelvin Balaquit DENR-FMB NEC Member
Mr. Jeffrey Jaymes Mesias DENR- Environmental NEC Member
Ms. Ernestina Jose Management Bureau Head, NEC
Engr. Marcial H. Mateo Technical
(BMB) Secretariat (TS)
For. Teodorico L. Marquez, Jr. DENR-EMB
For. Blessed Joy P. Gibe DENR-EMB NEC TS
Engr. Christine Battung- DENR- Biodiversity Members
Baladad Management Bureau
Engr. Aerold Louise Firmeza
Engr. Danny P. Berches (BMB)
Mr. Gilbert Aquino DENR- BMB
Engr. Robert Glicer M. DENR- BMB
Domingo DENR- BMB
For. Christian Kevin A. Latiza DENR-SCIS
Engr. Christian Philip Umerez DENR-MGB

DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB

DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB

DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 10

Engr. Celeste Aquino DENR-MGB

Engr. Corazon Ferrer DENR-MGB

Engr. Ivy Kimberly Batecan DENR-MGB

Mr. Gerold Allen Argonoso DENR-MGB

Mr. Calvin Perez DENR-MGB

Engr. Jade Mark Santos DENR-MGB

Engr. Genesis Madera DENR-MGB

Engr. Apolinario Katipunan DENR-MGB

Engr. David Villanueva DENR-MGB

Ms. Shenalie Taloza DENR-MGB

Ms. Susan Isaac DENR-MGB

RD Glenn Noble MGB MIMAROPA Region Regional Director
SSRS
Engr. Christie Apale MGB RO No. XIII

Other members of the Technical Working Group

Other Representatives from the MGB Regional Offices

Accordingly, the following are highlights of two-day virtual presentation of 30
contenders:

The meeting was called to order at 8:30 AM, and was presided on behalf of
Engr. Marcial H. Mateo, Head of NEC Technical Secretariat, by For. Teodorico
L. Marquez, Jr., Chief of the Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB) Mine
Rehabilitation Section (MRS) and Member of the National Executive Committee
(NEC) Technical Secretariat (TS).

The meeting started with MGB Asst. Dir. Roland De Jesus, delivering a
welcome message to the members of the NEC, the TS, and the representatives
from the MGB Regional Offices (RO).

This was followed by the introduction of the NEC members and MGB RO
representatives by the TS. The TS also explained the following mechanics for
the CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Virtual Presentation:

1. Each company is scheduled for 20 minutes.
2. The NEC TS shall present the company’s basic information.
3. The NEC TS shall introduce the company representatives.
4. The submitted Audio Visual Presentation (AVP) for the Best Mining Forest

Contest shall be presented to the NEC.
5. There will be a 10-minute Question and Answer portion after the AVP.

The NEC then proceeded to the main part of the program which is the virtual
presentation for the CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest under the Mining
Forest Program (MFP), where each shortlisted company will showcase their
respective accomplishments under the MFP. Participating companies for Day
1 of the activity, with their respective representatives, are detailed on the next
page.

For each session, members of the NEC asked the representatives of the
company for clarifications and a more comprehensive discussion on their

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 11

presentation. The companies elaborated on their presentations, answering
each member’s query and carefully explaining their accomplishments under
the MFP. In cases where the company cannot provide the data or information
needed by the NEC, it was agreed upon that the company will make these
available to the validators during the offsite validation to be held on October 4-
27, 2021.
The meeting was adjourned at 4:20 PM.

Virtual Presentation with NEC on September 20, 2021 (DAY 1)

Virtual Presentation with NEC on September 21, 2021 (DAY 2)

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 12

c. Offsite Validation

The offsite validation of 30 contenders vying for the CY 2021 Best Mining
Forest Contest was undertaken by the NEC and its Technical Secretariat on
October 4-27, 2021.

The composition of the offsite validation teams is shown below:

COMPANY Location Date & No. Team Members
of Days

1 Lafarge Holcim Aggrefgates, Inc. Angono, Rizal Oct 4-6 (3 NEC
days) Representative,
2 Republic Cement & Building Norzagaray, Celeste S. Aquino
Materials, Inc. – Bulacan Bulacan Oct 12-14
(3 days) NEC
3 Eagle Cement Corporation San Ildefonso, Representative,
Bulacan Oct 25-27 Celeste S. Aquino
(3 days) OUFO-DENR
4 Holcim Mining and Development Davao City
Corp. – Davao Oct 15, 18- (Rommel
19 (3 days) Baybayon),
5 Apex Mining Co., Inc. Maco,
6 Coral Bay Nickel Corporation Compostela Oct 12-14 EMB
Valley (3days) (Jose Paolo
Aragoncillo),
Bataraza, Oct 15, 18- Jade Mark L. Santos
Palawan 19 (3 days)
NEC
7 Berong Nickel Corporation Quezon, Oct 20-22 Representative,
Palawan (3 days) Aerold Louise M.
Oct 7-8, 11
8 Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation Bataraza, (3 days) Firmeza and
– Nickel Palawan Teodorico L.
Marquez, Jr.

NEC
Representative,
Aerold Louise M.

Firmeza
SCIS-DENR
(Ernestina Jose),
Christian Philip E.

Umerez
SCIS-DENR
(Ernestina Jose),
Christian Philip E.

Umerez

BMB

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 13

9 Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation Bataraza, Oct. 12-14 (Juvy Ladisla and
– Gotok Palawan (3 days) Kelvin Anthony

10 Cagdianao Mining Corporation Cagdianao, Oct 4-6 (3 Balaquit),
Dinagat Islands days) Christine B. Baladad
11 Taganito Mining Corporation
Claver, Surigao Oct 12-14 OUFO-DENR
12 Philsaga Mining Corporation del Norte (3 days) (Rommel
Baybayon),
13 Mindanao Mineral Processing and Bunawan and Oct 25-26
Refining Corp. Rosario, Agusan (2 days) Christine B. Baladad
del Sur NEC
14 Agata Mining Ventures, Inc. Oct 20-22
Rosario, Agusan (3 days) Representative,
15 Hinatuan Mining Corporation del Sur Christian Philip E.
Oct 4-6 (3
16 Holcim Mining and Development Tubay, etc., days) Umerez.
Corp. – Bulacan Agusan del OUFO-DENR
Norte Oct 7-8, 11
17 Zambales Diversified Metals (5 days) (Rommel
Corporation Tagana-an, Baybayon),
Dinagat Islands Oct 12-14 Teodorico L.
18 Graymont (Philippines) Inc. (3 days) Marquez Jr.
Norzagaray, Oct 15, 18-
Bulacan 19 (3 days) NEC
Sta. Cruz and Representative,
Candelaria, Oct 4-6 (3
Zambales days) Teodorico L.
Marquez, Jr.
Bataraza,
Palawan FMB
(Donna Riza
Casequin),
Teodorico L.
Marquez Jr.

FMB
(Donna Riza
Casequin),
Teodorico L.
Marquez, Jr.

EMB
(Therese Gonzales),
Christian Philip E.

Umerez
NEC

Representative,
Jade Mark L. Santos

EMB
(Mark Tuliao),
Celeste S. Aquino

BMB
(Kelvin Anthony

Balaquit),
EMB

(Therese Gonzales),

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 14

Christine B. Baladad

19 Holcim Resources and Development Lugait, Misamis Oct 15, 18- NEC
19 (3 days) Representative,
Corporation Occidental Genesis D. Madera

FMB

(Randelle Ralph

20 FCF Minerals Corporation Quezon, Nueva Oct 11,21 Canicosa),
BMB
Vizcaya (2 days)
(Kelvin Anthony

Balaquit),

Blessed Joy P. Gibe

21 Republic Cement & Building Taysan, Oct 12-14 NEC
Materials, Inc. – Batangas Batangas (3 days) Representative,
Genesis D. Madera

22 Republic Cement Mindanao, Inc. Iligan City, Oct 20-22 NEC
Lanao Del Norte (3 days) Representative,
Genesis D. Madera

FMB

23 Philex Mining Corporation (Metallic) Tuba, Benguet Oct. 4 and (Randelle Ralph
18 (2 days) Canicosa),

Blessed Joy P. Gibe

Philex Mining Corporation Tuba, Benguet Oct 4 and FMB
24 (Exploration) 19 (2 days) (Randelle Ralph

Canicosa),
Blessed Joy P. Gibe

FMB

25 Lepanto Consolidated Mining Mankayan, Oct. 11,21 (Randelle Ralph
Company Benguet (2 days) Canicosa),

Blessed Joy P. Gibe

FMB

26 Taganito HPAL Nickel Corporation Taganito, Oct 7-8, 11 (Donna Riza
Surigao del (3 days) Casequin),
Norte Teodorico L.

Marquez, Jr.

NEC

27 Platinum Group Metal Corporation Claver, Surigao Oct 15, 18- Representative,
del Norte 29 (3 days) Jade Mark L. Santos

and Teodorico L.

Marquez, Jr.

NEC

28 *Carrascal Nickel Corporation Carrascal, Oct 20-22 Representative,
Jade Mark L.
Surigao Del Sur (3 days)

Santos.

29 Marcventures Mining and Cantillan, Oct 25-27 EMB
Development Corporation Surigao Del Sur (3 days) (Therese Gonzales),
Christine B. Baladad

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 15

30 *Republic Cement and Building Teresa, Rizal Oct 7-8, 11 NEC
Materials, Inc – Teresa (3 days) Representative,
Aerold Louise M.
*For PMIEA only
Firmeza

The detailed offsite validation reports of the 30 contenders are presented in
Annex C.

d. Final Deliberation by the NEC

The final deliberation of the results was presided by MGB Asst. Dir. Roland De Jesus
on November 3, 2021 via Microsoft Teams. The TS presented the final score of each
contender with the corresponding breakdown, based on the conducted offsite
validation. The final review and deliberation by the NEC resulted in the following list
of winners for the CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest, which was declared through
a Resolution dated November 3, 2021:

Metallic Category Rating Award
94.90 Winner
Hinatuan Mining Corporation - Tagana-an 92.00 1st Runner-up
FCF Minerals Corporation 91.50 2nd Runner-up
Platinum Group Metals Corporation 91.50 2nd Runner-up
Philsaga Mining Corporation 90.50 3rd Runner-up
Zambales Diversified Metals Corporation
Award
Non-metallic Category Winner
1st Runner-up
Rating
2nd Runner-up
Holcim Resources and Development Corp. 92.70 3rd Runner-up

Republic Cement & Building Materials, Inc. – 92.20 Award
Winner
Bulacan 1st Runner-up

LafargeHolcim Aggregates, Incorporated 89.50 2nd Runner-up
3rd Runner-up
Holcim Mining and Development Corporation – 83.90
Award
Davao Winner

Mineral Processing Plant Category

Taganito HPAL Nickel Corporation Rating
Mindanao Mineral Processing and Refining 97.00
Corporation 93.50
Coral Bay Nickel Corporation
Graymont (Philippines), Inc. 92.50
82.50
Exploration Category
Rating
Philex Mining Corporation 77.50

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 16

The following attended the NEC Final Deliberation:

Name Agency Position
Engr. Roland De Jesus, CESO V DENR-Mines and Asst. Director
Geosciences Bureau
For. Roberto Oliveros NEC Member
(MGB)
Mr. Rommel Baybayon DENR Office of the NEC Member
Undersecretary for
For. Jesus Javier Mining and Muslim NEC Member

For. Dona Riza Gopez Affairs NEC Member
For. Randelle Ralph Canicosa DENR Office of the NEC Member
Engr. Therese Gonzales Undersecretary for Field NEC Member

For. Mark Anthony Tuliao Operations and NEC Member
Engr. Jose Paolo Aragoncillo Environment NEC Member
Ms. Juvy Ladisla DENR- Forest NEC Member

Ms. Argean Guiya Management Bureau NEC Member
Mr. Kelvin Balaquit (FMB) NEC Member
Engr. Marcial H. Mateo Head, NEC
DENR-FMB Technical
For. Teodorico L. Marquez, Jr. DENR-FMB Secretariat (TS)
For. Blessed Joy P. Gibe DENR- Environmental
Engr. Christine Battung-Baladad Management Bureau NEC TS
Engr. Aerold Louise Firmeza Members
Engr. Danny P. Berches (BMB)
Mr. Gilbert Aquino DENR-EMB
Engr. Robert Glicer M. Domingo DENR-EMB
For. Christian Kevin A. Latiza DENR- Biodiversity
Engr. Christian Philip Umerez Management Bureau
Engr. Celeste Aquino
Engr. Corazon Ferrer (BMB)
Engr. Ivy Kimberly Batecan DENR- BMB
Mr. Gerold Allen Argonoso DENR- BMB
Mr. Calvin Perez DENR-MGB
Engr. Jade Mark Santos
Engr. Genesis Madera DENR-MGB
Engr. Apolinario Katipunan DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB
DENR-MGB

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 17

Engr. David Villanueva DENR-MGB
Ms. Shenalie Taloza DENR-MGB
Ms. Susan Isaac DENR-MGB

e. Best Mining Forest Contest Awarding Ceremony

In line with the celebration of the 67th Annual National Mine Safety and
Environment Conference, the awarding ceremony of the winners and runners-up
for the CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest was held at Vertis North on November
26, 2021. Likewise, the said awarding ceremony also recognized the recipients of
the Presidential Mineral Industry Environmental Award (PMIEA), PMIEA Selection
Committee (PMIEASC) Platinum and Titanium Achievement Awards, and Safest
Mines Awards.

Ms. Marie Aurora Dolipas, ComRel and MEPEO Manager, Philex Mining Corporation while
receiving the Best Mining Forest under Exploration Category with Usec. Juan Miguel T.
Cuna, DENR Undersecretary for Field Operations and Environment and Atty. Wilfredo G.
Moncano, MGB Director

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 18

Mr. Shiro Imai, Senior Vice President, Sumitomo Metal Mining Philippines Holding Corp.
(Taganito HPAL Nickel Corp) while receiving the Best Mining Forest under Mineral
Processing Plant Category with Usec. Juan Miguel T. Cuna, DENR Undersecretary for Field
Operations and Environment and Atty. Wilfredo G. Moncano, MGB Director

Mr. Norlex Adsuara, Mining Head, Holcim Resources and Development Corporation while
receiving the Best Mining Forest under Non-metallic Category with Usec. Juan Miguel T.
Cuna, DENR Undersecretary for Field Operations and Environment and Atty. Wilfredo G.
Moncano, MGB Director

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 19

Mr. Rommel Cruz, Nickel Asia Corporation Vice President for Operations while receiving
the Best Mining Forest under Metallic Category with Usec. Juan Miguel T. Cuna, DENR
Undersecretary for Field Operations and Environment and Atty. Wilfredo G. Moncano, MGB
Director

VII. Issues and Concerns

The following are the issues and concerns identified in the conduct of the CY
2021 Best Mining Forest Contest under MFP:

1. The conduct of NEC offsite activities (deliberation, validation, and
awarding) is challenging due to the internet connection issues and
prevailing COVID-19 community quarantine measures; and

2. There is a need to revisit the existing Guidelines of the Mining Forest
Program considering that the said policy was last updated in 2008.

VIII. Recommendations

The following are the corresponding recommendations:

1. Resumption of NEC onsite validation of the Mining Forest Program
accomplishment of the Contractor, Permit Holder and Permittees
depending on the travel restriction guidelines to be issued by COVID-19
Inter-Agency Task Force for the Management of Emerging Infectious
Diseases;

CY 2021 Best Mining Forest Contest Report | 20



ANNEX A

Presidential Mineral Industry Environmental Award
Supporting Safety and Health, Environment and Social Development and

Management Documents
Coverage Period: July 2020 – June 2021

I. Safety and Health Management (for Underground, Surface Mining, Quarry,
Mineral Processing and Mineral Exploration Categories)

Document Coverage period Remarks
Attach its
1. Approved Annual Safety and CY 2020-2021 corresponding
Health Program certificate of
CY 2020-2021 approval
2. Accomplishment Report of the July 2020 – June 2021
Safety and Health Program July 2020 – June 2021 Attach its
July 2020 – June 2021 corresponding
3. Monthly General Accident certificate of
Reports CY 2020-2021 approval

4. Monthly Employer’s Report of July 2020 – June 2021 if applicable
Accidents/Illness July 2020 – June 2021 if applicable
July 2020 – June 2021 if applicable
5. Central Safety and Health
Committee Minutes of Meeting CY 2020
July 2020 – June 2021
6. Approved Emergency Response July 2020 – June 2021
and Preparedness Program July 2020 – June 2021

7. Report on the Conduct of CY 2020-2021
Emergency Drills
CY 2020-2021
8. Safety Engineer’s and/or
Inspector’s Permit(s)

9. Electrical/Mechanical
Installation Permits

10. Annual Medical Report
11. Explosives Transaction Reports
12. Explosives and Accessories

Consumption Reports
13. Blasting Reports
14. Table of Organization of the

Safety and Health Office
15. Safety and Health Policy

Statement

16. Safety and Health Handbook CY 2020-2021
CY 2020-2021
17. Hazard Identification, Risk
assessment and Control
(HIRAC)

ANNEX A

18. Company Safety and Health July 2020 – June 2021
Self -Monitoring and Inspection July 2020 – June 2021
Reports July 2020 – June 2021
July 2020 – June 2021
19. Reports pertaining to the
conduct of toolbox meetings July 2020 – June 2021

20. Work Permits (Hot Work, Work July 2020 – June 2021
at Heights, Confined Space, July 2020 – June 2021
etc.) July 2020 – June 2021
July 2020 – June 2021
21. Reports and/or programs July 2020 – June 2021
pertaining to Good
Housekeeping (including dust CY 2020-2021
control, solid waste and
hazardous waste management)

22. Reports pertaining to Medical
Surveillance and/or Health
Monitoring, e.g.
a. Pre-employment exam
b. Annual physical exam
c. Relation to work medical
exam
d. Separation exam
e. Special medical exam

23. Reports and/or programs
pertaining to the prevention and
Control of HIV, TB and Hepatitis
B (as per RA 11058)

24. Reports and/or programs
pertaining to promotions on
Drug-free workplace, Mental
Health and Healthy Lifestyle (as
per RA 11058)

25. Reports and/or programs
pertaining to the provision of
safety and health incentives

26. Reports pertaining to penalties
and/or fines to be issued in case
of a safety and health violation

27. Reports pertaining to the
provision Personal Protective
Equipment (PPE), and the
company’s corresponding PPE
inventory

28. Reports pertaining to targeted
and accomplished safety and
health trainings

ANNEX A

29. Awards and citations received. July 2020 – June 2021
30. ISO Certifications acquired July 2020 – June 2021

II. Environmental Management and Rehabilitation (for Underground, Surface
Mining, Quarry and Mineral Processing Categories)

Environmental Management

1. Cover page of the approved Environmental Protection and Enhancement
Program (EPEP) & Final Mine Rehabilitation and/or Decommissioning Plan
(FMR/DP)

2. Certificate/s of Approval of the EPEP and FMR/DP
3. Annual EPEP (2020 and 2021)
4. Certificates of Approval of the 2020 and 2021 AEPEPs
5. EPEP Physical and Financial Accomplishment Reports (2020 and 1st

Semester 2021)
6. Table of Organization
7. Copy of PRC Identification Card and/or PCO Accreditation Certificate of the

Head of the MEPEO
8. Documents pertaining to the formation of MMT and MRFC (Minutes of MRFC

Meetings conducted within coverage period and/or Resolutions/Special
Order forming the MRFC)
9. Updated bank certifications/statements for RCF, MTF and FMR/DF
10. Mine Waste and Tailings Semi-Annual Reports for 2nd Semester of 2020 and
1st Semester of 2021 marked received by MGB RO/CO
11. Proof of payment for Mine Waste for the 2nd Semester of 2020
12. Environmental Compliance Certificate/s
13. Permit/s to Operate
14. Discharge Permit/s
15. Hazardous Waste Generator’s ID
16. Solid Waste Management Program
17. NWRB Water Permit/s
18. Sanitary Permit for 2020 & 2021
19. Proof of submission of SMR to EMB and MGB RO (cover page only)
a. 3rd Quarter 2020
b. 4th Quarter 2020
c. 1st Quarter 2021
d. 2nd Quarter 2021
20. ISO 14001:2015 Certification
21. Environmental Policy
22. Proof of environmental awards attained during the coverage period

ANNEX A

Mining Forest Program

1. Development plans (long-range and annual)
2. Photocopy of joint venture agreement in nursery operation (if any)
3. Reforestation map (Scale 1:25,000)
4. Photographs/Exhibits of all aspects of forestry development activities
5. Photocopy(ies) of deputation papers of forest guards (or DENROs)
6. A certified list of personnel directly involved in the Program indicating the

position and nature of employment
7. Photocopy of reforestation contracts (if any)
8. Copy of the research/study of reforestation (if any)
9. Copy of publication and other IEC papers (if any)

III. Environmental Management (for Mineral Exploration Category)

Environmental Management

1. Copy of the approved Environmental Work Program
2. Copy of the approved Exploration Permit/Exploration Period covering the

coverage period
3. Semi-annual status/accomplishment report on the implementation of EWP

(for 2nd Semester 2020 and 1st Semester 2021) marked received by MGB
CO/RO
4. Table of Organization
5. Air sampling map and air quality monitoring reports
6. Water sampling map and water quality monitoring reports
7. Permit/s to Operate
8. Discharge Permit/s
9. Hazardous Waste Generator’s ID
10. Solid Waste Management Program
11. NWRB Water Permit/s
12. Sanitary Permit for 2020 & 2021
13. ISO 14001:2015 Certification
14. Environmental Policy
15. Proof of environmental awards attained during the coverage period

Mining Forest Program

1. Development plans (long-range and annual)
2. Photocopy of joint venture agreement in nursery operation (if any)
3. Reforestation map (Scale 1:25,000)
4. Photographs/Exhibits of all aspects of forestry development activities
5. Photocopy(ies) of deputation papers of forest guards (or DENROs)
6. A certified list of personnel directly involved in the Program indicating the

position and nature of employment
7. Photocopy of reforestation contracts (if any)

ANNEX A

8. Copy of the research/study of reforestation (if any)
9. Copy of publication and other IEC papers (if any)

IV. Social Development and Management (for Underground, Surface Mining,
Quarry and Mineral Processing Categories)

A. Social Development and Management Program

1. Stamped received Initial copy of the ASDMP from the MGB RO for CY 2019
and 2020

2. Certificates of Approval of Annual SDMP (2020 and 2021)
3. Copy of the notarized duly sworn statement of operating cost stamped

received by MGB RO (2019 and 2020)
4. Organizational structure of the Community Relations Office (to indicate

support staff if there is any)
5. Curriculum Vitae of the Community Relations Officer
6. Quarterly and Annual Accomplishment Reports submitted to MGB RO (4th

Quarter of 2020, 2nd Quarter of 2021 and 2020 Annual Accomplishment
Report)
7. Soft copies of the monthly internal monitoring reports (July 2020 to June
2021)
8. Documentation of company responsiveness to community needs, issues and
concerns (such as copy of the Grievance Mechanism procedure, process
flow and forms, and IEC feedback forms created)

B. Information, Education and Communication Program

1. Copy of the Approved IEC Program and Accomplishments (2020 and 2021)
2. Copy of IEC materials such as newsletter, posters, advertisement, press

release, brochures, announcement signs on site)
3. Copy or proof of utilization of verbal communication tools such as site visits,

open days/houses, presentations, public meetings/consultations, personal
contacts, media interviews)
4. Photo documentation of the establishment of Community Information
Centers at the community and company/mine site
5. Documentation/Reports on the participation of stakeholders in the
development of the IEC program and dissemination of IEC materials
6. Documentation of distributed/disseminated corporate/site reports on SHES
performance

V. Social Development and Management (for Mineral Exploration Category)

A. Community Development Program

1. Stamped received initial copy of the CDP from the MGB RO (2020-2021)

ANNEX A

2. Certificates of Approval of CDP (covering 2020 and 2021)
3. Submission of the Annual Status Report (to cover Documentation/Report of

activities conducted for CY 2020) and documentation/report of activities
conducted for CY 2021 of the following:
a. Assistance in providing livelihood training to the community and/ or

creating special projects to foster skills training and employment amongst
local residents
b. Provision of medical assistance to the community (e.g. medical/ dental
missions; distribution of medicines, etc.)
c. Provision of educational assistance to the community (e.g. donation of
books, teaching materials, computers, etc.)
d. Assistance in community infrastructure/ road construction and/or
maintenance projects of the community/ LGUs
e. Assistance in providing water facilities and other social infrastructures to
the community
f. Other relevant implemented activities of the approved CDP
4. Documentation of inclusion/ hiring of company personnel/s that will deal with
the social aspects of the project
5. Documentation of conduct of regular community meetings
6. Copy of corporate policy/ies, procedure/s, and/or program/s to deal with
stakeholder concerns and issues
7. Documentation of community immersions for company personnel

B. Information, Education and Communication Program

1. IEC Programs/Projects/Activities from the approved CDP
2. Proof of IEC accomplishments such as:

a. Copy of IEC materials such as newsletter, posters, advertisement, press
release, brochures, announcement signs on site)

b. Copy or proof of utilization of verbal communication tools such as site
visits, open days/houses, presentations, public meetings/consultations,
personal contacts, media interviews)

c. Photo documentations of the establishment of Community Information
Centers at the community and company/minesite

d. Documentation/Reports on the participation of stakeholders in the
development of the IEC program and dissemination of IEC materials

e. Documentation of distributed/disseminated corporate/site reports on
SHES performance

f. Other relevant implemented activities of the approved CDP

ANNEX B

Presidential Mineral Industry Environmental Award

List of Areas/Facilities/Structures and Activities to be highlighted in the AVP

Coverage Period: July 2020 – June 2021

I. Safety and Health Management (for Underground, Surface Mining,
Quarry, Mineral Processing and Mineral Exploration Categories)

• List of areas to be photo and/or video documented

1. Safety and Health Office
2. Clinic and/or Hospital
3. Active mining and/or mineral processing areas
4. Tailings Storage Facility
5. Waste Dump
6. Ore Stockyard
7. Materials Recovery Facility
8. Hazardous Waste Facility
9. Sanitary Landfill
10. Pier
11. Warehouse
12. Mechanical shop or Motorpool
13. Safety Signages
14. Safety and Health Monitoring Devices
15. Fuel depot
16. Explosives magazine/s (if applicable)
17. Power plant (if applicable)
18. Coal Storage Facility

• List of activities to be photo and/or video documented

1. Conduct of toolbox meetings
2. Conduct of trainings
3. Conduct of safety and health orientation of employees and/or visitors
4. Conduct of safety and health inspection
5. Conduct of health monitoring
6. Conduct of activities on the prevention and control of HIV, TB, and

Hepatitis B
7. Conduct of activities on the promotion of drug-free workplace, mental

health, and healthy lifestyle
8. Conduct on the provision of safety and health incentives
9. Conduct of emergency drills

ANNEX B

II. Environmental Management and Rehabilitation (for Underground,
Surface Mining, Quarry and Mineral Processing Categories)

Include panoramic and close-up videos and photographs of the listed
facilities/structures.

Environmental Management

1. Mine Environmental Protection and Enhancement Office
2. Active mining area
3. Buffer zones
4. Settlings ponds, sumps or other structures intended to address

siltation/sedimentation
5. Tailings Storage Facility/ies
6. Waste dump
7. Ore stockyard
8. Topsoil/subsoil stockpile area
9. Materials Recovery Facility
10. Hazardous Waste Facility
11. Water reservoir or water storage facility
12. Sanitary Landfill
13. Pier/jetty (including seawaters)
14. Warehouse
15. Motorpool
16. Other pollution control facilities/structures
17. Location of water quality sampling stations show in map; include current

photos in the area)
18. Location of air quality sampling stations show in map; include current

photos in the area)

Mining Forest Program

1. Nursery Components
2. Nursery Operations/Management
3. Disturbed Areas declared
4. Plantation

a. Latest Plantation
b. Recent Plantation
c. Old Plantation
5. Company Forester
6. Deputized Forest Guards (DENROs)
7. Reforestation Personnel
8. Local/Community Residents Involvement
9. Research
10. IEC on Reforestation
11. Services in the Community
12. Conservation measures

ANNEX B

a. Landscaping
b. Use of vines/grass for initial rehabilitation
c. Herbal/ornamental garden
13. Flora and Fauna sighting in the MFP/NGP Area

III. Environmental Management (for Mineral Exploration Category)

Include panoramic and close-up videos and photographs of the listed
facilities/structures.

Environmental Management

1. Environmental Office
2. Active exploration area
3. Previous exploration area (test pits, trenches, drill holes)
4. Core house
5. Bunk house/s
6. Buffer zones
7. Settlings ponds, sumps or other facility to address sedimentation
8. Waste dump
9. Stockpile area
10. Topsoil/subsoil storage area
11. Materials Recovery Facility
12. Hazardous Waste Facility
13. Warehouse
14. Location of water quality sampling stations (show in map; include

current photos in the area)
15. Location of air quality sampling stations (show in map; include current

photos in the area)

Mining Forest Program

1. Nursery Components
2. Nursery Operations/Management
3. Disturbed/Exploration Areas declared
4. Plantation

a. Latest Plantation
b. Recent Plantation
c. Old Plantation
5. Company Forester
6. Deputized Forest Guards (DENROs)
7. Reforestation Personnel
8. Local/Community Residents Involvement
9. Research
10. IEC on Reforestation
11. Services in the Community

ANNEX B

12. Conservation measures
a. Landscaping
b. Use of vines/grass for initial rehabilitation
c. Herbal/ornamental garden

13. Flora and Fauna sighting in the MFP/NGP Area

IV. Social Development and Management (for Underground, Surface Mining,
Quarry and Mineral Processing Categories)

1. Community Relations Office
2. AVP of implemented Programs/Projects/Activities for the development

of host and neighboring communities
a. Access to Health Services, Health Facilities and Health Professionals
b. Access to Education and Educational Support Programs
c. Enterprise Development and Networking
d. Assistance to Infrastructure Development and Support Services
e. Protection and Respect of Socio-Cultural Values
3. AVP of implemented IEC materials and utilization of verbal
communication tools
4. Establishment of Community Information Centers

V. Social Development and Management (for Mineral Exploration Category)

1. Community Relations Office
2. AVP of implemented Programs/Projects/Activities for the development

of host and neighboring communities
a. Assistance in providing livelihood training to the community and/ or

creating special projects to foster skills training and employment
amongst local residents
b. Provision of medical assistance to the community (e.g. medical/
dental missions; distribution of medicines, etc.)
c. Provision of educational assistance to the community (e.g. donation
of books, teaching materials, computers, etc.)
d. Assistance in community infrastructure/ road construction and/or
maintenance projects of the community/ LGUs
e. Assistance in providing water facilities and other social
infrastructures to the community
5. AVP of implemented IEC materials and utilization of verbal
communication tools
6. Establishment of Community Information Centers

EXPLORATION
CATEGORY

PHILEX MINING CORPORATION

Project: South West Exploration Project
President: Mr. Eulalio B. Austin, Jr.
Address: 2nd Flr., LaunchPad, Reliance St. cor. Sheridan St.,
Mandaluyong City

Background

Philex Mining Corporation’s (PMC) exploration activity is under Mineral Production
Sharing Agreement No. 157-000-000 located at Padcal, Tuba, Benguet. Its current
disturbed area is 0.06 ha. The Mining Forest Program of the Company was established
in 2016 and is being governed by the Company’s approved Environmental Work
Program. The Company falls under the Exploration Category of the Best Mining Forest
Contest. After the field validation, PMC achieved a final rating of 77.5% and was
declared as the winner for the said contest under its category.

Nursery Operations

PMC’s nursery, PMC Forest Nursery, is located in and shared with the MFP of MPSA
No. 276-2009-CAR which is under commercial operation. The nursery has an area of
3,000 m2 with 30,000 seedling capacity. For the fiscal year, the Company has a
previous stock of 1,444 seedlings, produced 18,700 seedlings. PMC has outplanted
9,800, and donated 478 seedlings under its exploration operation, resulting in a stock
balance of 9,266.

PMC’s Forest Nursery

Reforested Areas
At the end of the fiscal year, PMC has a total reforested area of 46.85 ha to which
5 ha are new plantations. Since the Company’s MFP only started in 2016, there are
no plantations that are considered old. The average survival rate of the Company’s
recent and latest plantations is 90%.

New Plantation located at Ampucao, Itogon, Benguet

In order to have a high survival rate for the plantations, PMC has one company
foresters, four company-designated forest guards, 19 reforestation personnel, and
25 local residents are involved in the reforestation activities. As maintenance and
protection activities, the Company has been performing the following:

● Establishment of firelines;
● Brushing/weeding/mulching/pruning;
● Fertilizer/lime/pesticide/chemical application;
● Water spraying;
● Control of pests and diseases;
● Patrol work; and
● Forest law enforcement.

Established fire line in Ampucao, Itogon, Benguet

Other Environmental Factors

PMC has propagated calliandra, Benguet pine, antsoan dilau, coffee, and cacao,
among others. Aside from the tree species planted, the Company has also initially
rehabilitated decommissioned drill pads using lantana, sunflower, Chinese bamboo,
and napier grass.

METALLIC
CATEGORY

Agata Mining Ventures, Inc.
Apex Mining Company, Inc.
Berong Nickel Corporation
Cagdianao Mining Corporation
FCF Minerals Corporation
Hinatuan Mining Corporation
Lepanto Consolidated Mining Company
Marcventures Mining and Development Corporation
Philex Mining Corporation
Philsaga Mining Corporation
Platinum Group Metals Corporation
Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation – Nickel
Taganito Mining Corporation
Zambales Diversified Metals Corporation

AGATA MINING VENTURES, INC. (as Operator of MPSA No. 134-99-
XIII of Agata Processing, Inc.)

Project Name: Agata Nickel Laterite Expansion Project
President: Ms. Cynthia Marie S. Delfin
Address: Jabonga, Santiago and Tubay, Agusan Del Norte

Agata Mining Ventures, Inc. (AMVI) is located in Jabonga, Santiago and Tubay,
Agusan Del Norte. It is covered by Mineral Production Sharing Agreement No. 134-
99-XIII as operator of Agata Processing, Inc. covering a contract area of 4,995 ha. Its
current disturbed area is 154.00 ha. The main mineral product is nickel. The Mining
ForestProgram of the company started in 1999. It has an approved Environmental
Protection and Enhancement Program and Final Mine Rehabilitation and/or
Decommissioning Plan. The company falls under the Metallic Category of the Best
Mining Forest Contest. Based on the guidelines and rating system, it attained an
initial rating of 82%. After the field validation, the Company achieved a final rating
of 88% in the said contest under its category.

Nursery Operations

The Company owns a nursery with a land area 19,600 m2 and a total capacity of
1,025.000 seedlings. AMVI has four (4) nurseries, namely: Agata Central Nursery;
Lawigan Satellite Nursery in partnership with LAFFA; Bae Lawanen Ornamental Plant
Nursery; and Bamboo and Pine Nursery.

The total seedling production of the Company for the fiscal year amounts to 1,057,150
seedlings and a stock balance of 772,827 seedlings from the previous fiscal year. The
total out-planted seedlings for this year is 87,151 including the seedlings replanted,
and donated a total amount of 10,050 seedlings. A total of 959,949 seedlings remain
in the nursery as stock balance for this fiscal year.

Various forest trees and fruit trees were raised within the facility such as Agoho,
African Tulip, Anabiong, Antipolo, Bagras, Bagalunga, Bitaog, Bitanghol, Ilang-ilang,
Kamansi, Lauan, Manoco, Avocado, Cacao, Caimito, Lanzones, etc.

Ornamental plants were also planted within the vicinity to enhance aesthetic. To
promote agriculture as well, herbal, ornamental and vegetable gardens were
tendered.

Nursery operation in Agata Central Nursery.

Various indigenous and fruit species raised in Agata Central Nursery.

Reforestation Areas
AMVI has established new plantation with an area of 64.57 ha for the fiscal year. In
order to maintain a high survival rate for the planted seedlings, the Company has
two (2) foresters, 10 deputized forest guards and 40 reforestation personnel that
supervise the following maintenance and protection activities to achieve higher
survival rate:

❖ Construction of firelines/firebreaks;
❖ Brushing/weeding/mulching/pruning;
❖ Fertilizer/lime/pesticide/chemical application;
❖ Water spraying especially in the new plantation;
❖ Patrol work; and
❖ Forest law enforcement.
With the above-mentioned activities, the Company has attained an average survival
rate of 89.57%. As of June 2021, the Company has a total reforestation area of
441.98 ha for Mining Forest Program supporting 379,401 surviving trees and
seedlings.

Latest plantation established in Mine Area 4 using fruit crop

Latest plantation established in Mine Area 6 using Agoho

Recent plantation in Mine Area 9 established in 2020

Old plantation in the Upper Nursery established in 2016

Other Environmental Factors

The Information, Education and Communication on reforestation being implemented
are the following:

• AGATA Nickel Project FB Page

• Quarterly Local News Publication – CENTRO
• Official Newsletter of Employees, and Communities – Budjong
• Regular radio guesting quarterly at DXSN “Katilingban ug Kinaiyahan” radio

program
• Weekly Tree Growing Activity in support to the company’s D-Day ”Defeat

Covid-19 through catching Vitamin D

On the services to the community, the company continuously donated 10,050
seedlings of fruit trees and rubber trees to the local communities and LGUs.

Within the coverage period, AMVI held and commemorates series of environmental
celebrations such as the International Day of Forest, Earth Hour, Earth Day, Arbor
Day, Month of the Ocean and International Coastal Clean-Up.

AMVI also launched Environment Month Online Symposium held on June 29-30,
2021, showcasing the Agatas Best Practices on Improving the Mining Industry’s
Response to Challenges.

AMVI established the “Mabakas Techno Demo Farm School” which focuses on the
training, research and development of community members to acquire skills in
sustainable farming technologies that will ensure food security and generate income
opportunities even after the end of the mine.

In observance of the National Arbor Day and Environment Month 2021 Celebrations,
AMVI launched a 3-day Community PanTREE inspired by the theme: “Gikan sa
Kinaiyahan, Alang sa Katawhan”, held at AllHome Butuan last June 25-27, 2021.

The company established various plantations in partnership with the IP communities
in Coro (Coro Mamanwa Tribal Sector), Capilitan and Ayrag Clan, and Mapaso
Manobo Tribal Sector.

Rehabilitated mined-out area through landscaping and revegetation
Medicinal and ornamental garden established by AMVI
Non-mist Clonal Nursery established by AMVI

APEX MINING COMPANY, INC.

Project Name: Maco Gold Project
President: Mr. Luis R. Sarmiento
Address: 3304B West Tower, PSE Centre, Exchange Road, Ortigas
Center, Pasig City

Background

Apex Mining Company, Inc.’s (AMCI) underground mine, located in Maco,
Compostela Valley, is covered by MPSA No. 225-2005-XI covering a total land area
of 679.0200 ha. The company produces gold and copper. Currently, the company’s
disturbed area is ha. The Mining Forest Program of the company started in 1995.
The Company has an approved Environmental Protection and Enhancement
Program and Final Mine Rehabilitation and/or Decommissioning Plan. AMCI’s Mining
Forest Program falls under the Metallic Category of the Best Mining Forest Contest.
Based on the guidelines and rating system, it attained an initial rating of 79.5%. After
the field validation, the Company achieved a final rating of 80.8% in the said contest
under its category.

Nursery Operations

The Company owns a nursery with an area 19,000 m2 and a total capacity of
500,000 seedlings. It also has 2 satellite nurseries (Bongabong and Bucana) both
with an area of 300 m2 and a total capacity of 20,000 seedlings. The total seedling
production of the Company for the fiscal year amounts to 75,034 seedlings and a
stock balance of 109,643 seedlings from the previous fiscal year. The total out-
planted seedlings for this year is 7,684, including the seedlings replanted, and
donated a total amount of 12,919 seedlings. A total of 66,751 seedlings remains in
the nursery as stockbalance for this fiscal year.

AMCI Central Nursery

Reforestation Areas
AMCI has established new plantations with an area of 13.63 ha for the fiscal year. In
order to maintain a high survival rate for the planted seedlings, the Company has 4
foresters, 7 deputized forest guards and 16 reforestation personnel that supervise
the following maintenance and protection activities:

• Brushing/weeding/mulching/pruning;
• Fertilizer/lime/pesticide/chemical application;
• Patrol work; and
• Forest law enforcement;
With the above-mentioned activities, AMCI has attained an average survival rate of
91.49% for old, recent and latest plantations. As of June 2021 the Company has a
total reforested area of 570.71 ha supporting 386,165 surviving trees and seedlings.

AMCI Old Plantation

AMCI Recent Plantation

AMCI Latest Plantation

Other Environmental Factors
There are over 10 species of forest and fruit-bearing trees propagated in the nursery
and planted within and outside the mining tenement. These includes Falcata,
Antipolo, Narra, White Lauan, Bagtikan, Macopa, Lanzones, Durian, Rambutan,
Pagatpat, Bakauan Lalaki and different Bamboo species.
During the fiscal year, AMCI has conducted researches and studies that includes
Carbon Footprint and Carbon Stock, AMCI Green House Gas Reduction Plan, Dam
Stability Study, Biodiversity in the AMCI MPSA and an ongoing study on the
Rehabilitation of AMCI Old Open Pit Area with Phytoremediation Plant and
Biofertilizer Application.

AMCI Wildlife Sightings

BERONG NICKEL CORPORATION

Project Name: Berong Nickel Project
President: Tulsi Das C. Reyes
Address: 3/F DMCI Homes Corporate Center, 1321 Apolinario Street, Brgy.
Bangkal, 1233 Makati City

Background

Beong Nickel Corporation’s (BNC) nickel mine, located in Quezon, Palawa, is the
Operator of Mineral Production Sharing Agreement No. 235-2007-IVB covering a total
land area of 288 hectares. The company’s current disturbed area is 107.7 ha, comprising
of the active mine area, road networks, stockyards, settling ponds and other
environmental/ancillary facilities. BNC has an approved Environmental Protection and
Enhancement Program with Certificate of Approval No. 087-2009-03 dated April 28, 2009
and Final Mine Rehabilitation and/or Decommissioning Plan with Certificate of Approval
No. 185-2021-10 dated July 7, 2021.

The Mining Forest Program of the company which started in 2007 falls under the Metallic
Category of the Best Mining Forest Contest. Based on the guidelines and rating system,
it attained an initial rating of 88%. After the offsite validation, the Company achieved a
final rating of 89.5% in the said contest under its category.

Nursery Operations

BNC operates two nurseries with a total land area 21,800 m2 and a total capacity of
525,000 seedlings. The total seedling production of the Company for the fiscal year
amounts to 90,618 seedlings and a stock balance of 63,623 seedlings from the previous
fiscal year. The total out-planted seedlings for this year is 42,789. The number of
seedlings replanted is 52,892. CMC donated a total amount of 8,736 seedlings. A total of
55,765 seedlings remains in the nursery as stock balance for this fiscal year.

Various forest trees were raised within the facility such as Indian Lanutan, various species
of agoho, narra, and rubber.

Ornamental garden, herbal garden, and vegetable garden were also established within
the contract area.

BNC’s Nursery

Reforestation Areas
BNC has established new plantation with an area of 44.5 ha for the fiscal year. In order
to maintain a high survival rate for the planted seedlings, the Company has 10 deputized
forest guards and 87 reforestation personnel that supervise the following maintenance
and protection activities:

❖ Construction of firelines/firebreaks;
❖ Brushing/weeding/mulching/pruning;
❖ Fertilizer/lime/pesticide/chemical application;
❖ Control of forest pests and diseases;
❖ Patrol work; and
❖ Forest law enforcement.
With the above-mentioned activities, BNC has attained an average survival rate of
95.62% for old, recent and latest plantations. As of June 2021, the Company has a total
reforested area of 557.84 ha supporting 1,368,346 surviving trees and seedlings.

Progressive Rehabilitation at Area 5

Progressive Rehabilitation in mined-out areas

Adopt-a-Mangrove Forest Program at Tabon

Other Environmental Factors
Other reforestation-related activities conducted during the fiscal year includes research
on the Use of Inoculants to improve plant growth and development, IEC on company’s
best practices, and provision of seedlings to local farmers and benefactors of the BNC
Agro-forestry and livelihood project.

CAGDIANAO MINING CORPORATION

Project Name: Valencia Nickel Project
President: Martin Antonio G. Zamora
Address: 29th Flr., NAC Tower, 32nd St., Bonifacio Global City, 1634 Taguig
City

Background

Cagdianao Mining Corporation’s (CMC) nickel mine, located in Brgy. Valencia,
Cagdianao, Dinagat Island, is the Operator of Mineral Production Sharing Agreement
No. 078-97-XIII (SMR) covering a total land area of 697.0481 hectares. The company’s
current disturbed area is 198.74 ha, comprising of the active mine area, road networks,
stockyards, settling ponds and other environmental/ancillary facilities. CMC has an
approved Environmental Protection and Enhancement Program and Final Mine
Rehabilitation and/or Decommissioning Plan with Certificate of Approval
No. 131-2018-10 dated April 26, 2018.

The Mining Forest Program of the company which started in 1999 falls under the Metallic
Category of the Best Mining Forest Contest. Based on the guidelines and rating system,
it attained an initial rating of 85%. After the offsite validation, the Company achieved a
final rating of 84.2% in the said contest under its category.

Nursery Operations

CMC operates three nurseries with a total land area 22,720.5 m2 and a total capacity of
1,000,000 seedlings. The total seedling production of the Company for the fiscal year
amounts to 687,870 seedlings and a stock balance of 891,539 seedlings from the
previous fiscal year. The total out-planted seedlings for this year is 635,446. The number
of seedlings replanted is 23,360. CMC donated a total amount of 39,317 seedlings. A
total of 881,287 seedlings remains in the nursery as stock balance for this fiscal year.

Various forest trees and fruit trees were raised within the facility such as agoho, narra,
talisay, lauan, mangkono, mango, langka, and avocado, to name a few.

Ornamental garden, herbal garden, vegetable garden and an orchidarium were also
established within the contract area.

Reforestation Areas

CMC has established new plantation with an area of 20.49 ha for the fiscal year. In order
to maintain a high survival rate for the planted seedlings, the Company has four foresters,
26 deputized forest guards and 194 reforestation personnel that supervise the following
maintenance and protection activities: