กลยุทธในการแก้ปัญหาความยากจน

nagvtg

I6 t t a f i ' t ? u n uof u u' ' l

ur

n?'rtJEJ'lnqrr.f,

lrnjrcrudlilcr-

lmr, rodrzq g tf,g l{:$t l.lg

n0.:11:T0t1fRt?a o:1r tt @a leaiv, t

aov

YA

o:i7l 1 f l{tlo 2518

'rutonrrirllnq'ro.runnrrl,iu.rr],du,irun'rlrrolu"onor:do,n'rol:uro

rla{' tJ* nnlwiul ani dtu $ nsrj:cr,rlrrifrl;1n"ul:rrtrrr"l{uriu

{!

n I3 lll?llnt 2516

{t

1. ft?]utlj0{9t

d /Jrrn u,:trllflooull€ru't

fi'rluglnn ruudnl nl:flll? tul

rqnlduJ:crnaolfti uioc'lf!i'nr:rr{[([.r,r"s]uldg:un'n

,&r{l

tlnvd.tflljlllgr'lIgr]2J504 lloll6luv{wlt'lld:s$n0llavd.1Fr!

q{ s{1r1{.01.:fl { ry, llagnl: 9]l lnrno0d'l?t-
:t$ltJ:]u [q15Js1910

dl .'

ft:llJlulJdlnEU t9lu{0ita n?l uflnnlifllnolugl c

d4 t .l

lflruJnnllo.lrj:tsmunalllJIlnr tlasuqulol.|tfl9]01n

fl?lljd1nn {0.llJ?OUUiJU1tlf,2oU1n:?n[:'] MR:JiJ'IOUJ

< | tb.r ,{ |
:u15.:tt0llluillflllflnlu0u't'loDl]:tnnolflultar fi)1r

e, I l' | . ,{ d d brb,
{Olltl.1:cU?].i{tjtl.lu0 U1}J1q{flilUflU0tl1.1rialnflU{ UJlO

I .l{,' fl '] :J

n]:fin:J]Ln11tfl?]u!lniutur-l:3[ne0flt

{X,A

!Q1r1 U511|fls1.rU83U ll:ln1:nHlq:fl0r UlU]lJ1r',tfll9loj1

nrirrio /:vnrrrn o:l:rflunrrunrnirnrr:ru/mrrnr?7

#o0.,::r:lR:u5filrn.r:cunnfl"our"ifnlunrlnnr:rir,:ru

odr.r'utro;nn'lnrurirruirouurfri4urlrgrarnrrlurniDnu'hi

*nttis ts.t:J:cryrfln-"eoJauot'!:ocr6on1{nnunrlunr:

u } J u1i0LJtue 1, : .l un t T l tal ] l r u ll lf t 2 1l JU 1 n 1u

?{f ln

3

2. l fl 5 s gf t 1 d d- t fr u r : ' ] l f l: l/v{ l i u f ltJn ? l u u l n o u

0t nl

lu :vrmqo"oul{'ruur

trt:uSnrnori'jrn"rmanutd::trne (Devetopment
Economicrfslu)nr$rigrinffr:h'$Jurodrr:rnrirnraun-ln.r-

n:rrlnnn:o.1fin!ofiroJn1n:itnflor linrdlrrutrnlfi

:"!nr:rlnorJriorcornlfi:frirrr.:nr:rior.r.:::crri:;rnr1fl,16irfi
n"ur firirpurerrrn-oanhLuriarn"u{lulal"norrlur.r uf.ijr
rorugnrneri'jrn"ranr::vylrhnrourr:16:.:lnadr.r:rorcrri i':

ruurffnun:rqrnu:frfgor*niiffiol'rn"rfiluo"urrn \jrfiur

js

[slF ?.Jf'jt yl tl'hl't t: ]tf:'.B nJ l q:.tF0fiR tl,^iy"U n^:.{ lu

:r rveo"orr"rlLut-"ryr-itirrrr,orfir .rnr:iqJufr: erFofl

a1.ldRTr,rq09i0:luBn3tff1i tffit:rJtsuoltrlutnfl.l[fln(lt!qtnn

lurixrvrno"arilr-mlur6ndn.:"nrar:touonqrn+rf:i "flJur!TfiUt
fiqr.r'nq:rirTof!iin\fri:finurnnrlrrn::.t'ql1out r isrflflfl"ou-

lt"ful rusing:cryrnorir.ifiruriuer"?utrn:r"dxorur,tlr6ifiir

nqurflr:n"nLulr::nr5"rfr.rni'uq":lui .::Iarri1ofrrirmimi

lurJ::rrfio"o-falJurn'issniuldirlusyfiriqr,rmmJUmnu

ttn::.r'qrarRrrle"alr"nurgor:lr;ntr'oflrn'tlluruqinrJ:! fl

nnld nlT.tn3f,l[1,1flytIrnnql^",lJflnrurnlTy{qJu-[f1llJ5-

4

nnn nn3t$uo:lr:fr10u1,1tn01iuT1l$lJ01l14u.l2mnlJllaltun3fi
ilsjlruu1nl]lfnlul0,Jll:llnfioau fljl.l nmJ1amflll lJou

n"urarln

4.! u1n$ ( atttfll :t111J191:-

t n1fltfnlJll!t!flln11

flT .t n'r:ll ,c o r { <t{ l0 1 1 t :{1n tol n 1 : 0|u 1' {. l u . l 8 ? o o t j

fl1Jtull10.inallu:Jf

fla'lg 5ifl1: no

JenJMfl l r1 TJoa! Jl {anJlut!l1. 1

unltfin$rr!J1,11n!

&,s
vrqgg'ror1,,tnr1n:n!qlu- n1,1tfl:bsnx uxxu11'lJfl'l:ltJ0riqlu

lt-Jfi.:n ?mfl1.[nB]JUiJU?11UUn1JeUf fl',lU nlln0rv{i1Tl1l'l

I, Y'!e

rfll.ir:u nsLrlT RYll,lLn!:itnltlflr lq flJu'llJ^lTtfinl [']fl'

nolJl dlnlJ L t1n Uuflfl11'{[1fln0fl1llfllbsnq nTl:Jol

'tql f:: qrTfltlfit I n' 'lu r J, filll! l, L i:J'lnnu oluu

lrn3ouI l

'r]:fiTH r! '5r11r.U-rqU t| n: , 1lu l . 1' qr i l r y?]

lUnlln0t!.[

RlllJ!1nq n- U. taua u n . i LJ . q,I uu Y l l 3md n0l.:l'allfl:1u1,1lonfl

n11Mt

a4 !v,

tuul:uu n?unlf^l4q11$1nliiullJlll.l [. ?'ulclYlflI

lnnialr-r q crl! na lis ! .l ! t slllfllfr 0u fiqJ u' l uroLnu ![c11lT&

r ]ljiu

! ytf!lu I l Ada Nf1, 1 1el [[R ;ol n 1: t t 1,1 , ]n1 1 f l 0 u 1 ,, l flnJuu'lnltlqTlnn f i

n un

$nu!uli'tn?1!'l nquq.lqlo,lolfl8nnflfl5'lSnlTtln3:J1tfnl lT

I

911.t.rl flnfl1Jn fl ?U nlTun!q5t'ln,t1u00flt\flJumnd:JqI5

r.lnIn lf'lts3d1 1:n0lf18!rf flill.t]urgE?nfiLtfi otflrTtln3

ntIugllD.rit;t!f,]1,1!tffllfl-tn.tu u0tJEl0lo1!fnl lTtufl?u'tylLt nnn1.1

;,w

]UAUtf 01'r:|lF:J-t7fl10ln]- ndths uly.tfltfl fll" f

uo lcta.:o]fluxtrnl:[ a |_ fl- v eY

n:nntIf11[{l1 t€1'Nn uu f].tu n'n?-

[nl"r3x4!q rf]?1:.r0fruyi9t 1 nJllqlE.Jl,,t1'l:0t11'tiltlnil0.1
'-i::tyt6'flrithfi,1lI"lfl nt]J::tfl f'] t : r [:J0,ir1 Lf,Tt]yDl! Lsl

,1dy mJ nA0I nt:fl nBtl-lt-ti1,.1t'1tlfJl Srnnujia.:J3!11fl

fl 011',lSJL ln']('ltLl..tl lV.1lLLfLl n:l{ ].lXfl1l:1: Il0?t?t

10rn11},rooIyr$rl.t1rufl?rfin10.:n?t:Jfl08ltlillnx1ll1f1nt:ltl,1

filld1rT3fi1',t.J8?tn?r d?nrf?lrorft'l.tlJft0!1\fl i$n t t:1u0

I 0111,1111'4li[UnUml] 9]ArV,tmJlfUl l

,{ htfllT tulJ0[fl1,10||,U:1]|'U,tU.t1{UI nlT
l|tvflnna7

lnuruu]fl ?ltnofl 9lur flolfiuo u:f]innl?ncfl o.l|u los:!

q !{'

11nn]X?[flT]; d?lirtl k7.inl-tJfl8t1',1iJ1,lt1U'l ttl HI6l?T[S

ltn1)?!fl:lJvtfllu Missi.ngfaclor A,broach llF'zlllJlt

Single-la.tot Apptaach11n171tEt:7l,l"lllU Missing facror

.l aa

ApproachlU 2tnl:U$tlun1guUnnrlm:Sr'lv{n]f:llJ "'ln

6

oriturl:grnfffrl,,ru"fllrn"xnf-rfitul::rvrrtsl"e"quur urnvr:ri'r

:JLli t 0g l: 11^iYl:(JlUtulll : rnfiYlvifll'ltlfl 'l l|fl H! r ]nI? llJ0!

1u:J:ttrnel""ozauurfir,!arurrq-:fi'r*u: ll-uuflinrra[Jrr,reiliu
r:r"r'tr.llurl:cfl!"roflsl"1ruurttn"rrofri'uirrl:srnn0""foluarqg

Hltflfl ?,[Lr1.t1]:JLltif:lrYurln ) tf tu' ,]?rf 1 ,311U1'tLll"Ylt1l

v I Ad d) lq 3 f l0 t n 0 , ;& r A
l l 1 u Y un ! 3 lnfi n:].tnJtl:9tflfl l,lui tlTS-
oi n' uq t:l :

[ T f .q t L u t . l J L Y . t 1 1 l r uq ] l t:lolufl rllnn0fiytjd.]Jln'

llf

r:rdo!r#u'161,,rnr:r:,t$-crnr'-tronuo![r":t1]u.lial Bfiorn"U

nr:t ifl:r g1!,u1r ,44 _ rsua r l l -H riq r :r*?urtrflin tu:rn"r

tu?u[ Lula

ulnt:'tflFtnmfn1:'ttn:'tSnvinf '11.{ni,ylln!t:lnmlnT! ?u

t')}1qJur:Jtt "1fl uJr,iYtlu!:irfl fi t0 L: :Tn']frlflulnuurin

6o r::nifio-ur.ir*".rnrtr.lri::J:curuy:rrngdueruifrl irnuvi.:

a re , Xaa

n]: 0J1,t1$flt:mn:rfiu lft2r ?5n't:1lo:'t31r9l.tn0t?uu0- 1t5-

?{0Roll:3l11f1floUl.1'Wtl{rUl .llrl llT:[1]f,floU1',lflJUllUU0uI1n

Un.lUefi,l')'1 , lglLS:-,url,Jf^l;t"5d , d ;-

U :Jl11fl1D l tI L1l :ytY]fl?t1,{fI1,l1

1,1t^r11t0!,d n]: a,lumqlslun5t:J!n:3tnfllln;B rl* : dt ! l t n]J

J$l 1lf

qflfl1unT:LJfr.)?rlutu1o.Ug JT3[1rf111l11t?rnif'l?]fxi .tlv lnty')

ii Flhl't;0.rou1,1:0uno'I 1,1??,18'tn:f:::Jslgt[n3f1n1$]
'r1: sr,J,l tuffJnlgre0E-r"xudt {n .!nu lf,:J[uuf,iflll

oo'rdrrur'ntfiuio'tri riruiinr:irn:'rvliuusuinste-factor

Apgoach [ll1,{?tnlT?ln:']g.A11l'1lna,:n'l'l:Jmf, ql r Q- ! fl A

loiUn ,l

.e I Aaa |
unqfllq ltlttl,t ?tttur? ?f,n1:1tRt131tinflnIulJfl ltt^ nn0u' n

ro:vSnrnle"rui ru'trirfoel irluiu'jrnqu$rhlurrR:u3ir

rlue : J n l u Y l d 1 : : u1 9 5 0 s r ' r " u u f l , 1uL-1y l 1 o A i . J u ; A u r l l

. l r

don:s:lrunr:ll"flurl::rnfilunflxriu tsoonquffllhur

tfl:BsnAnn llUufillXJdlfirugort,.ltutlU,( HurnanCaqi.tal)

u:flnTflnut [|n:i tu1rflltu 1970!. r n n- ; {u! - nlfl :lnt :nn ]'l

u

da .l

1r?Qroglrrmlt!ufi ll1rsrfl0in11u]nqu nf]fl uQlil!::f1nT

nnntfl't4 nnt/?t9yr/rtr1-il] !t911:ln[uIunllfn Lr10.t:luu1

A [-n r; n,Unl n{ w

frlltlUlnQUUfin- t-, tou n?1Yl1U:3lfUlllt Unnu

J .} Y

uuluniu-q ln MaJLnnEtrnrLi2n' luu

dn,'r

3. dalufll:tufl?lltulno lUlJigllldlrlfl

n"rmr qr"ainr:fl:lu'idrrurunuqulul::rnn'lna

rJ:J1nU0L[1i ,t'f,llt lT]i lflUl]o Jl[U]lJ:30- lll: vr-ia 0 l' UlnnU

u tflfln

rfiLnau qtr! 6:BJ[n) ltncul.J]sllun 'r

tuttfl.Jltlr)LtlJt'

r-iru-^f1fi' r1r.6'rilaufl::nfl"l'nJfl'rnnnun*u rlnunrru;Inn

lrli nroqrri,ao:r'uourt'qi? "nr:rh:ln"unrrl0rnolrr1l:cr{a'l u"
ntarnrunrflnf (iolral-n"utrttu2stt)

8

u,.l .r /

fi'rur'r1 r:3f.L:11lft14i,'!8.1.\flr.[1n5nqr]rflll.rnl:irt lfln x.l

t c, e lJ:l r!; lyll $ t J o { l?( Bre a k - Evenlo c o me/ !

llU TJfl Ulf lro.l$m tl

q,r n,.i . x a e,

1T3fl:lr'tflftltvtat$tu,:||nnl'l{i1! lun]:{0f,unl:l:ctflY)

011,11T lfUfl l qln EngelCoefficienl ?100ql: fl'lU

xra'jr.rirlir-rsn"ruorur:n'r:ra'(trfiooas"p"ndirurIen-co.me

{!- 5 !

Ratio, llfi1rT1U16lYl1^10J",fhl1t l'l$lfln]T.r'001l4lfF- linn' l'lu

0A oldur uj3-ftufr?llJnUuIlu9111ai:odon!uuIuu.t q u T ']rUr! F] s .3?10

n

t3Yt.tt?fltln u (Subs i s t e o cIen c o \rAd ! u ? f u [t1ff1 lTn

me) Lfl

w v,n

u1:9fl1l:19lft?t!1nnud::1.1$srngYta.lnutln3ttfls8nRrfl

tfl A

,.in trnfl l1-|srl:1.tyIt

Fa I
,=
7G
l+
iEe 9
s;
G6

-6 > rq .6t

'!Hqq 9rdrn bcc
ct: ts

10

.l \o

e

,F q"-q E"'E

3)e}q FF

.x4a ?

E)EiE -.=,F

ll

qrr:r.rufirirrrarxliuiufir uounnxurmt(P-oty

Band,i floJlTyflslt l ur] N nl I lr.l C" $n:

Fn vt{lulflslt lun

u0ntls[1']flun ju a t .in fll1 ulnqu ll]Jl0nj

Tlulnl f]110

:co"u:r:r1firafi"Blflourinrtrlry^."riinod'ronlyi'nrir'o:uu

Tlll\ lrf u 1[filfl ' ]liJU"rnq11lu n ,l :cflu :'t ! I! .n nl\o [118.:

l11u6t10, u

a'l

lnnrll{al|llun'r:u:lnfl 00 1.J:llJnr:18n1U0luo'1141:

Ae EEr luvlrr,\vlT l e 8-frlxuTr n 'n1|llns tuli n nl

lln30u"'lfrxll YtJutf jft'r

nlln'tn (ntlluft!vr]nI luu 2512o.t,J?'!ta/ nmfl'tT1r1,t14ur

l: lnflltJlTouln11|xun:o]lflT2numnnu oi :1n,l nlTlJ

)
11f,flr

lz i

*

c.ro\6\036

r\o.r+o

o\{ro.+6

d@.+o\cl\o
rdohoF

I .\oi€ooro

,7 !a "s a

"ZEFE* E ' 6

E:F =

-

rl(F llir r-
2
t: = s t! rE h

.c"FFF-h- tr

..:.irid6\d

13

q 'lnfl ] Tl . iA1.do .l l :lq;l d ret ;

ll1l lfll1 HJoy^ ,MTtllln.lnlU'lU

l',l ua.ln:oRT?nulnlutts': R'tnaElu8antogjtl,tur a

n:o flT?nu1n1u:ilnmd1ft,n4.1t 5,61R7tountx tlt0un

; J\,

n11lluft:aun:lngtnlun?lJl!,$t1 2,162,291 fltouRtl$fl ')

[n]nU 51.22 T0tntl!lflttn ,tlnt 1to [|n:n]RLflslnl 'tFr
01u1n q'E '}q l t13tji91t1tlfnl nt, ll}t SuLT []u0]lul

:t1$11:Jfl:OUfl:'1fl1flqmu 'ytnqt :oinl t! tf]|[n n]Rt 1lo
$nlnln tnfl'ltJn'rnufl21.11.{0ntflf'[11f1u1]q1]n ? nTo!fl:?

Ylulni ruttnnfifl tujtlflfl;llloEntqu{luuo :fltnIl lnttn

I',rotuuoufl3tlfl lflnl nTt! ou.l tlju?ru'1fi.nfl?1 ft't1,l:Ll

nmfl;' :uo0 nt0u AU /u8u u Lu 0111 r :t' t$onl 1ul nfl u1n

,:t1

A.

xJntsufltltlnnuiJmnlln ntno lft |lsln']uL tlntflflu1s

fnu nl 'tufl:o fltlYlulnq uorlllf,fr

I

L4

G dI .: --.:

5 d ..i

,i!

q

-q

.i

d;^i:

IC IE :i
vF 6 |

.E

)h E _rF !)?
4 a i;_ ,4,

iq.-E Fd

E E F ,;

.6
F F,G!=

er1TlJYrl fi t[d9r.rll,lluuniofl ?lf, ? ?31,11']J11U',]l.l

R:O1. ea rfJlnnunL!r'ntu:0?!n: ?- YIl ill: itYrfl [:m3[uulf]

lfi:lY

I aa4 eYX
?'t 9]l:Jfinflu25II 2512 Ll;8lltfl lltlllJnlUlun:o fl:?m.Ku

or ;

5,908,473 nTXt:01,r t1J1.1f1:0U- fl:tY'qrOf[lnl a]l,118',lnqu

dl

2,762,29| fil 1lXOU fifi[.]U:OUn4: 6.8ilonl[UnUrUntoil

flT?tutlJf][11fl].rnrlnvuso[nnrffilurn :JT1Ilfl?[1lr1rl1fl1f]u'ln

a @6i 3
nT0un;'t11'q0lu8rno{,ltutnnut?lutToflIf1l3.2 fi't1l oflllfl

c vJ

tYlflulntJfr:0R:?11u'ln1iu:oflun3 51.9 nltTlnluuq0u1J

l,lur.r,i1 o1ru1lilxflilunorrmnrfulunnrnsr-orr.f:i(urtun

s e c t o r , u n g u o f[ l m t Y ] f M n [ L u n 1 n : 1 u 1(]R1u1r a lS e c t o r .l t/l

1$14Utft',t',t 01u?irn:0un:?vrulnnlutlnfu ll:J$fl$?u

i ; vy^ YA
fi,in'l1lun'tnsl'l[rJ0.i lYnl]tTl[flv{q']Tfl.t1tJ11r.ili}JFlllr

1,,1n'l:ll1'llfll'!1311'tl'llujffl':l1T1fl10Ul ln fl 91fql U rnl:'lno.l

nltfl:'lU{ lU?UlJTglfnT fll'liU [:inl UJllflU,i11.1']Ufliun

01lflnrel?]nT'toufl $n:lnlu'lun:oLnt'11,]u'tflq tultclflt

r:Jn1fr fl.i!t rnl I n tTl,lllfffl0lrll{

16 {rtq.E e

6F+OO !F'tr
qi:
\E

sf6o\osf

E]F;E:E\o\ooo9

. F E'E

:5E

'e E{;

rg

"fF n:

'=rc

; : ; ; c : ;oho,\oN j . E= iq =

,fi =

: ri; I o\o.r4rf

n{E -

F=l

{cF 1{-

'!: t !: .- t-

= > =.= =

.,=

1,7

qtnflt:'ljl]fi ,t!

tT'tny['],111t0:t1ltu:nqtul1.lfl n tu

lilfllYrf, ']n [].\uJ484,15l nu nr 21lfli.tQuudiil1rfllY]f,u1n

n.l15,450,I2n0u :xuolulununrl1JT.Jtn|5fl,934,27|

n r,:! J a r r u-j. l n r d r ul :' 3: $ r n : | 1 , | 2 5 1 2 J n]:

o 1 . r : l : 3r

Y r,

l1lfiJt? 35.109n u6ru i;.lrLh ll fllufliuU Llul6t nu

qlj Y WA A J ej "r , r rA- f t iLfrli"ornl45.1flol Tr-

n6i-r:TJ .tquL .:

z, r i . y r n r i n :n r u : l u i , r i utunulr.n"lr]t .
fn)fl'd::[1 st

gln:Yllu:ltvt'lt|f]lJ.:llEn)rn-,i&n. t:u ttu 2517 i ru?u
rjtgsrn:fl.irl:J[l]rtqr'tiJ.v1.l5rf3ltrt:T dl 41.023nt nu rtnu

tflunuqurtf8ir.ozn4'runu n;luizl stsq'ruru!:g{rnr

Y. n:lullfl q !flU 19.194ntunu

n$filLnf, 42.2'77nluflu

4. dltfin{onuqiylnn?rurntulu rvlflflI u

I n]:o u]fltfla1]?'t 0Jt:[:]i.rst[y,{r[[1iln?TJUlnqu
L[1t:J13!lYYft,! t)]iln J lfiIufla._nllldun!)l.t1]na

\n, fiI flntu!u|Titrrl
(fl,r fl'rtlrflnlfluonrl:3tl1fl

n.r drtmprnrs:lcurna

nllrnn:fl:ltfi t3fr x411l o: t:nad1tl,191tnl,tls:.t:3[fl

18

;a 4' AdT n0 r4Jr / lUnXlnrqu lTlnola' rxr rtfli X l.lslut tnx

lrNJt1 rll

ElJnltul0ltltult'inl r LtnrLll4j1l.,i'lnInJ non rll'tllli-

1'ru0lurnm1{n1:;rtir,.lrJ[0nr.i:[1nd 1u n- !5:n15vil11.t1lni Slnoq']n

A2

nlin:Jx1ti0'rlltnrNrfl:D3nqrl l11T1l!:Jn0n!ttn1:1lul

A {e

o'r1{rqnNflr:rr]0ng0iJlLlu l,i'llnu01.t11lJ'l]trIn1l!uJf'1.1

10JURfnl :3!811ll1:llnn:OJ?l0lUtnylNn1:!lJ0Jflllltnsull.l

., r lr j f l L f lr r , 1 1n 1 l t L l n ! 1 t { t 1 1 q " n : :ql t L s l ' l l l n

tr!nn:cflhr n

o i sltf, $ I t4d ." r v {A A ;!,

unsljut:.t: tlnu I.t !uo.:srnn' nf ?l:J0'u]nll'l.l

A Yd)

n'tT|r.J0J fro'.JoL!1.r{.rurnq3!0o"rr1fll1i1l'l.Jnl:l}J0.iu1{[u

; a{ dl J ai ;
ln:8.rr,JotunrTfi:firIJnn11i1.1f[ls:fillllf]T0ll.l0!un'Tnfllf il

:ftiJ?n{u I T3 : ro : ] , flto r fe.lt nn| rl2u! $1 rVuflir., r!n n:o .18S l JtJ

|1:!n

oorui q 1; q. v9 rl:n0uLi" a%" 1 11llul nt:r, fl1l: 5lg{u : g 1ix1 .l

rur?r0oto01

tLl Cd v {r5 f l L 6 l l f l . f l l t 1 {l l t h 0 . 1 ! ' r 1 ' n , ] f rl. rl'fl81su

ltuL Lrllfl

Vr l runtun flrLLlqlerlulnLu.t:ln116r:lti)."

$Lhlnn:0.r

tj0.rf.lrfl n?rljflr.Jliu51J11?lrxuxu ilnYnl:9'Ilt:tl,li[{l'l'l"l

9-

J]'ruLsrnl:rlnfrT0rfl,rnnlrl:rJ1nfu43n0 us'ln'lJlsn:[tli.l

,David Cisselquist,Lequalit),is theBasicChatackristic
o.[ Undenlewlotment,Discussion?aper No. 35 (Facully of
Economics,TlrammasrtUniv€rsity)

10

nl]'JUrnq ln11t0l,rJ u' S r-a flns: i:Jnf iullrngBlJ-

8iJ1110un:r

Y u' n 1" dl !:Jl{luodFr f'l ao

tr::u10Jfl.tsuu!nfl:o,lluudtn4 rx.r

H4 _r1| -]leJf.!:1:i1X1Ur10,r.f:lfr'l't1i,JA0twu. t1 1l1 , {0 u'tt.ntfgr [r J']tny] Jn 1:

tFlr

rl6!ruttnrnr:nn:o.rnrn:::.rol:1Lrt.r:urr;rffni:rqd:Jlf
:g o:r":l:;gf '[flr"Lrfl z+rs uqrTolrfic*firrun:'.r::l

ro.:nr:lnn:orfin-,:nrrflunr::Jnnn:orl6:cl'!lon! 4.:

orulnYtlinl:tli0.:!.tntflnt[nsu{uh!nf]Jottllutt fn nnlv,l

r- , !-

nll nJnn?LU,llUUi:JrUtlL.jr!U ltn:qlUJR:[UUi]tf,u

,irot ! l 1.l ou l f l f I A : d t1 YBA u[ uo . t q] nrr uQ4 q]|fitJ t 5

lrn 'rn J0Jl11uYu r.r

o : : l u r u * r -" u ? v . f l2. 5 1 71 \Dat i n " L x 6 o" rri . r : l i , ' . r :n:;nu

ir : f l "

o'lr.r1l"n1Jnr;tl']oJofl'r.r1n1fln|11! t t:Jot.]11uf,11.t:l.t:5-

q !, q rdt ,i Y u,
5rT:J ruflilijltfl?ut ryt:.t1,lr.,r?Limsmtf.flnn:o.Jttn:j/1iT0

i'2nrJ:vIdqdnrr"1.rtut'urir..inn:an.:rLun0fl:lu:fin

[6]rT1n\nflflTrt1r:.ttIf"lu1{ruuu10l:J'lnt }.[Jnl':tnnat1L

,c

ond ft nnru flrr1lrflrfl0r1-!'tn11tl:.ri:,ioltJ ktn:gl'tg

llnLJ!n5ulftultftYrun ti'Tloulm.lJflu'Itxln't:llnoiolqs

rt ::rlrrn:slornrurirl'1fla1!flu:sr.rouil::g'rlfluun;

fl: rlr,11'11::l.tLL10:'!ln6 :u ru1:JlYTgL0ll!::5 f ! lslun

RYf,:' l.l:gffLnr:urnJrtrt, Llyut .

[ . i . i i ^ f l L f-i!u l 1 r t dl 1 r

.Ia Y u.

6nT nr;01[Yu1rr:]|l0 n1011]ulul] 5ufw.Jlnn:otsc8r

R,ti$01urn]1rJn1:[:Ja,l;un']:|,|61r1,1"r011u0:Jn.o:fo][,1J$1ltJfr

e)

Hq:fl0.1ifui .r'l'r:J'ln5u1n?rm!r1rdnl!9tut u0l]lt1?].l11n1u

i"

W:ff:llnr,0 fl? lLlnrul.lUlLJULlnlllrittlr6J?,lYlf v l[Y

!1rnflnr; n:,Jllr hl lnl1 unl1L'J't14rn:J?n$ufi:lllfi

fl.in?1::ft!a uY,]01l:31,1f.tttx|0'l'] ]tQ1,1':r1flrJfl'rnunl Jl,llJfl

f&iunh_l trrif; i,]s^ : i r filnn't'txJttflnljf|lrus1ulllr.rrflTbsnn

$n't

uo.fi.l T & 111n$' L {z

:sl$ulJl.t1| {u11:tn1u3:Jtft,:1tuuotJ}JItlTl{

qrlUor' l "l'.,l ll lJ4ll-l,r'l,U1l & qr' ,, al

nl n'l: [5q1!0l'l]i till[1{0Ul]€.lnnflU1l}l

AA

s1u:111jtfl:!r5nx0 fl0 ufl't1,tlt'Ltun'tn:0.tx1,1fl,:1Jft$nfln0

:lU lOntn!1\0r1r:JJrrnnl:rlT311.rX'l9t'1tR0J{1-}r.l!1l:n flq3$J

Iv,]u.]vr,rIn0| 1:fr:0rx li0 n901 lLl e !j!V q"!!;1?111't, l d 1u..'l, 1

:3frll:i! lflI ol

t , nr:l,: : 11-d.^t$10' l 8rr ! j fl.1r1[n1t,r.1if]tr]Jr'tnlutdul u , ' ] flfln 1:0 1

tn :. rlT

k

f-llJv-d,'ryr5tYl-ru1,1rfo]u'ts111in0lltl!.l lu nlTn:gq]s8fl'r.l

A YV I

flq.1]' n' ' ltit'0 1{ il ,'n.:|U8.:fl0J{l"{' Illl-f]:rllU:glYfl

lunr:unr.:r,lrnnl:slBsr.inr.rrrnio:rr+irglffiinnrrr.:uetn

I Yd S .
f 1 r . : l r . I f l : b 5 n x T g 1 ' 1 ? 1 , 1 { u ' i u : . .nj ' lrtmn r 9 q 1 8l0' l s n r j

nln:JorIrn:J?JSL10,ut yrfl|lruiJnuq.:[.]ltt.:0uLl0us'1!ut

fl1:ttn!4tlrfllrrJU'lnn0ulin0ul'lnn0ulfru

2l

:irur,lrnlrsrnnu:r'nimrrfLolAxAtrrii.o:tLr*sinrrxrvJi'l'rd-

,!

!11u:,tnluu0tulnnt:t:J! Jll0l!:;x tt1lilt'l.tl.t li'1n11?18itli1.l

u n q ] n f l l : n : 3 n , l | l o 'tt n n r . : r f l : u 5 n nlirlj [ 1 ] ' L 1 1n!ur01fr f l ' t i r

'119t'n't:iioJf.itftiJ?lirrr{loflrq9ulali:rqq iJi.l0t1151u:11'N

, v , !r k
lfl:lJ{nn90JlJ1lUiJilflns)llfl nll ltflnnlifl.Jnnl? tfLu1,l1l

s-tl.{tn'l!!ufl2't:J[fnl clt tafln]!uo!toJ:Jutd8 itr[;[fiu?nu
lfl:.td:'tJlr'rJrl:u.Jo.t td:b:nnrln3fi.tfl 0'rsLr'f)l",.*fl:iJdJl1l

n'l't [flnfl 1.tq.Nnn]?iJxJlnlu0'turqnr. fiTDSnn!0iJnr1,1l.tf)

!tv

[oi] nfl1flal nqrn1:ilnfl tufrTotn:a.r uurJ|1nIn1:i.rnfrt1{

frro!fl:a.tlJm (1:lrrq;r uflu norurr:rvrr:r.l.tud)orff

rirurqnr.lf:lu$frqiJrn ortr o'rniroyrrian"anr:nFn:J:yrnn

!q f-l J u U 6 1-6 : , it Y U-l. nr ] , , F l a 1 " t- o -L ! " " [ | ]

1 t 1 , 1 . 1 "[l U !; rl 1 1!.nl r Lf lr Y

6imurnr:qo.:s"rnurn:nnml or.l::gtnl nii'rrr1fr61un".:or

V | ;c.

!lfl1{u lllr:J{umra1uli111.:[f1?u{n11n floIo']fl!0'tutnnlJ

lfl:birn"L ldi"LX-s lun :fil tn: 11 1q" [":,lt1.li:LoU

n't T,:lftf l : !. 11 o'tqrln xn l:rlJ 0iflno f l "rnnn{: J ilu nn:Jxu

o,r

Y,:JrrJlt1lY]l fltulnnlf JAln l{01:l t4 lJ.611U:nilltnIl

nrrIdx.J111inrirr1.J]f:lrfio.rrfiorflurn3oo.:lufinr:l,loIr,lu

I[ Rf ] 1 v : .c 11i t .t3fl |la]n']'t,[J()nflri tl.tf]lu51,"tyl,t'lj

1 1.0',n1nfl0n

22

lflTtc$^ tq 11v1t,0a [1 ]a0t1r ru q4 [ ufl l 01 : Ju B at|s] 1lT :ilnrlr f l ofl?

lfltlil'1

lnt.t3: n IJn':rl"rl,[ofYl)B:nl nndoriull{"ull].11:t1l

! q'

Lo:rn:1"tlhl"0.U1Ll,lfIl t ltj.L".l6:Ttr n')l:vq L0lu rnIt{

! fl; D j FA , dr ' r ! i lirnfiqr:arqrnfr,rrinr:ninru:in"rl-ut:r

nf,r n

n s rn dr 1 i.i L 1Luri chl l rLs l Lnrtl ; l i rt: r : : . - s d u r t

YllJtfl:l:l5nnt:lui].llflll tlJtll l.lr:TlJlJlnl u

4.1.1 ln:td:l{lJ0.l:&uxtflSugn0

tflt:llt|u]r t;:rrlr1:bsnn tfl:.Jfll'llfl"xJ:lj:llltfl:li5

nnr1]1lrJ6 (Mixcd Economy' , nn''l?^flo,lr.:'u:r}.r:*:r,r-ir.t

llLl.ll UuU:l' :l!Lfi l,J 1"uu ..slt,tlJtSllfl:3UL[r)ujnI

Lyll]'"uu:31rlryruu!rtJul:1jlllF]:B5n"nImur:r:r .:lufin:::.r

finilun:hrifiudrulnonurnasilfti lunr'::;no:.Lnru:si

l f a v , r n' R a a' d nll r ;r n^Tvr' L:J [1i1113an]isn YtlJ

i:n'] 1\f, r1u1L,1{r1d: l1ltfl

n-:.lJL' lft:Jd )u 0u rln ,6:lltlt' t1,11::{lut tfiTnthlun t:

rl:r'or.,rr:rl'hirui'rf,:rr-ur urris .n"ui:r"fjiuflr:l:ro:r

2fi1finq!fi|:3[nrt0.l [sr T:x fl aq tulaiJ0Jvtn u^!r 't;istn:o . d 0

linx JlJ

lunr:n::lru:ril'6 :;grgrilfirflufi ::J sr:rn-ur'1nn-ru'u

,l a q lfl'].t1,11 1r :18flqJnlTi A r" t h'tuu'lttli 1T

tfD0.J:.JI 0n1:r l0.lsu$ u

llngdiJfl:'!j::nv{'ln 1]'l'tlo.llflU'lnX{ n'l)-'l1.itttJulfl::jsno

; a; d .-
tln:F :61:n"' llq:0 JtlL\V,01::nl! 7t lfln : 1 .[:qtr -1L]l(lYll:

rflt utn i u,tn't1fir:n:vqr!:.u lflll:itlf ls-qrl,v4 rli ?if: T q- i.i Y l

u1.

tuJ:1lrt1l!3i0f.lTB5n9lYrun3lul.lic1l1J:f1:B5nls.l|[ifl:J tlf]

: A t e- d nt:u3u1.1uu^g tA A

Lfll ]t1. 0' 1tl]||ft'tu lf] Ylnu tllolq'lnn'l'ttJ

ll Ix it1.1T3 1 ,1'l1 Ju:3u1:J1f u TYsr lrl l.lrf a v.a

flnsrril,!x.t ll.]ulr,.ul 1.rruu

fl l'1t:|fln'fq]?l.{ il cl.u,utxt:J]u101:Juttfl:ujnt xl tY::uu

7t1.lu!LJtu1.{nrnn:':t: filf lulrr?i8fui d't11:.Jnfln$n3td:n1?{

lurlr:!:3nn!nl: T3l]llfilnxJuI nn!r unJfr't't:Jfirl.rt::

lu6.rfllJufl3nlin:3i1u:1LlFr Lr.lT3f'lt91n{lrYnrYririJn1[t{].i11

J S U U [ f l : D i n n m f da s r : ] 1 r : ; i l r j Y r u ulftlfllJr v ' r l i : ; ! r n r :

ln

!:B 0ur11afitn:fllr r n r ? a J : L r u 8 . l " lt r J r 1 , , .A u 0

1l:f^l tJ!

rrfur nll::lrtuur1or.rrniRlurtnl rl :cno!nr:1oln-orfirr.r

ZUaTl

nxluJ lr.ruiJl{|fl 1113t[81t,]11lr111r:01i 11t1rnrr.3f1l0:u'r3un'rq

uIga3ritd;Jrlhl nlTu:3n0ufll:ucr n1ii.r11rJ111tl,6t:i03u

0 t Lt nn rr' l i b 3a 1 I lf ,c ? r1t ll;lrtu1,1tr1!:L0rr.-x
lTruu

yllJrfl:bsnlllorllrnin nuiLJlflrrnTnl tun]:tJT:noult

tfi anrnnuonn?g fi?0 nl:llflxr1i10n6I$f ny0r5 n]l]J

aAe

n1:!u0.1111c1,1?.ri.,tn!:3[uxuYllttf0l:nud51n1q5rrn30fl51{n

2L

r'linr:tfroJuro.rrdi"rr4:al ai-. riroa-r;1arllrinnqu'hironi iyl"lundr:::-

noun'l:llofilNYlllJLfrltftrlIltn nll ofl:0f1tn3n'11x1:4

16rTrnorinrufrrranluu.:rl:ymrff'lfri iorrnl:!6r;nl

ol"- rdl q!^a*

|U1lflifllU ll-lflYl'l'-llll',ltin10.lnl1{a?lnflf Sttn:Ofln?in l.lnll

t:Jo.iFinnl?

t1,{i:jLllllf,ruSnntflLlyruuu:J n1:u1r.rlr1{n'lr:r:J.rfN

lanrrn u0:Jr:Jnl..rrnri.JBsrr:ronirarsunr:fierffl;ctrru

rusincoudfifrifidrurqro:u-oxfuf n:firinr-rnr:arinlun:o:r

nt0.t,.J1ftr0:Jl aSuruSIn:l,ft::ri,rnflci.l[1,]1.r1r1.rrflrri:lgnsn1

l!ru1'r:.10'ttqr'11tfJllJlnntni!qq:n1:ilnflul fl:eufl:oil.toll

,,tl , ]l.t t f 1 : t i^li tnAl\l,Lfl-: Y d. 4 A

llarS.ttfutnu nno|ttlf l.l11nl! lel:a.t

j qexe 1.
rjefl^rlQl11ll,]'ltfr'llX1^r40q lNftfrl t1,!Cl l0iJ':1.10'l'lqm'lJlfl:lt3

fX ffl;ll0llnnlnl'llflXJ 0-.11v111f]1.1;:c?"llYllLlO'11{lnnl.llfl:lrInn:Jln

n" - .l-]? i d! nitl nuLt:1{[fln3quflnfl"]:

Ltfll:tr::ul.l1l

[]ln!rlfl ni f]l_J'r€rrfl:U$t!1r0.J)'sr'itinJ't'1r 3t]rl.r1t-|r]u'tu
nr:v,raurl;3tl]ft ltruir"Eir-t'tr{nrfll0.JTsu]s qtn0nn

utr:rirJlriorn:tfir,l"u:Lrrun"rur:fLrurfrl::l1unr:n:gnra
:tr'lfir.l::trsr6r7iruf"iuqrffrirurrgrfionnl#nrrruonsir.r
ar"rugru:nrrre:ugfinro.r:l::trruniloansr['61s6inn- r:

26

l n,;,fuL,lunl lfl:Jfl: ]J10J:tuulr)"d3nil]11 l t0.JF1_l):n0L

FC.q Ue:JlDddlL iun r)"lnuql?,9.i

t0')glUf,.l6liUUtu flu

nnlrtfi oin r.rnnl!o-N'll t:JC$Iq't:]fiJtll1v:J'tEllltn1:

nrrqru:rfltf:i3;rxr61firflum::Lu:nlr"rrfl'.rn1;slflu

:3ili.ltfl:uqnnrellll t:3u1111u1L,]1fl

4.1.2 1rIUUlUf1l :11W1{1:[UfiSRn

qq

l r !1:J-llltlnn; UflrlUnl:?,1fl1111[f]:eUSfln?UfilnB

IriuoUtunr5fl::n1u0tl.nqtnf1::i5n1n lnv?111T'tntr3ulr

v1 a

tflibSnllrB$nx u.l'1113!'tn1n1.J10f$lfnl sllnlu n; toltns.li?

o8'l.lJ: ||9]hl!9lornqsT$lnl nlTnrl:ulfiu !flnrilfl:bsnl

dl e.r ;d .* A
t:r1lt1_1lr1u18111.n1?'tLdJ',t-n{lJoufr-u lt].t.J lt.ill olqtuu[?{:];

nrt:un.:rfoodrfio1'Jnrr:.iriirprfirlnrrlrn:ugirlu

o?'llj ulJl u;Y t'til l t q n- i u t u .r -u .l n; Sglt'.n1!0J1,1'l

!nn lllut/t:n?ntng?

o'lr:rarnquro.:r.l:*rflqfufqucooncn]r1,r:Jrrsdr6aul#1:ru

4g fllivl u tfl) l t u ?l i : , l f u &q i 1 o dut,i "

tflll:'trlflf-'l! 1L s l ll ':

nflr tnuns I n]i-1{9}lurifl:ii5nntn1llt'r'lulrJ,lJ.1111L!Yfi l.r

n1:n:ssr!:r!1:f:is-rsr61r;rflut:r:niJiu lorrdeirtu

3 Oskar LaDgcand F'redM. Taylor, on the EconotnicTheory
o/ socrdltrm(Nerv York : Mccrarv-Hill, 1956),p. 20.

26

Iul{lUn tlj f}tt 1) ll?t!'tnsronl:?,u1r9|fl:ujlnq utnnTS

4g

sr:J:18$r1lT3x11Lrslllnu:1u:?Uu.riJI1n.glfl1{11.{u.Jqlunnn

oo flor rvrnfiqr'Ldr&;:JvrLnfrur^nrisfinr:?ue:ilugrurfrn;

ooxJtJlufr:.j'tn'f'llnuqHi Lfr;u^ rn a0 lux$[l4n.]r.1r11.{lTdrfrq

nitr:-!nt:-zuurrhcrrdeoriuoorror:l::rrrt:rurn(fie'i.r

rful ftnqtnir:n:cqru:r16:l::vrl11rf6ulfri:::Lrrnffu)

sq

x8.Jnr.1[urm:qrr:Qrflt|9r1]1irL::i1nnflo].r:.nJ11n1!.t:gu!

rt:nti:Lgoln:grrunt:vt"qn}r]:ugr :ornr:"limurotnuiruri-nori

nrnrn:E:nf:l: 7i-,rRgrful uno-.rq;r'u'Ifi'ir:rlrt'nlfni t:rfri

e a lq':5n) q sl,r "l 0,r0ut,r9l1"

J :40r'r: 1{q:u rtr.l0i fll

6'tu 6r f r J u!!tJoq t f f ntrBfl:t,uItfl?,r130u'r.TJr.A:rJ1or'r?

zufl!uli

firr:u'rlosnir:u:.::un"r :vfrtulunrornuorrn::rsr"o.r:-:
nrrsnrii6{d0frlr1 rernr:iorn:-fgi unrSrnrf(ilr:c r

66 61 ^"./."41 [.r:)' n l! i .t[ ]L r [n ':flqJu r.'t.-bs])'}::J

flrl,r[r.]ri'ruriflTB$fsf[rnvd-rrifl!- frxrfii (2504'2509rf)ifl.J

t 4 . t 5 7 "f l 1 r [ . h r . l iur : ]r q; lr$0,(:zslo-zst+)rrir: zo.

*li

23%ttnrqtluruu-all.rrr al-lfintltfia.t 13,7%$o.r.r!1,{-flur

rf:lugfnf unm"rnfll-.uiqsr1iunlfni'jsrrs"lunr:rl-murrs:uq

aDan Usher,:the Ecananicsof RicePrcmium(1961)

27

A I J' fliulnlfl ostdt?nTT li:a n'tflql'l

nltl)tyt7t11-t$.r'111lltunuln:

[tuai u.ii.]nllln?'t:JLlglll9't]J[u.t:l1ft!:3llx1.t1]:3{t$l.tlunln

I ar, II A 'to.iT;u3
tr LYtntnlflfl'tuJo.1:J1n1u €ritrlnx't t ay- tl'rt

lll!lls't nl:n;tnr t 1{flJ].n{'llnlnuflr:n:1iJtll'ln n't:u 0:Jq:

ttua!stTnft0nlT edutl.lJ;[?]fl t1,'{T'l3fl211}1Jtfnl .t10.iR'tfl
v;

tnbflTn:: 1.u0.tJl.rlt6ftIrn?q3ntr1ln::l.llun'1:1lsru'If]:lj3

nqtT0itln.J
z-

nTuy*1-hqtt ]usfldlnt: driul Tt.n6lYfl8ntn f

\'t;x r 0n a 2 5 1 4 E-1at".!1L u l f i 6 1,1' t19 0 "

fl'.r"1 i: 0rn. Ltfll' dfll

Ui{UhqJL"l %LLIfidJ :-Utoln'ltflnUlo.l:311T (PerCapi

ra IncomeI, n I-r9]l{l A'l|flffl]ln E U ; . l n\B| J [ |. ] Y {11 {

"? 1t 1.

oflTlnl:$1t:qtr)ut9lYl't.T1f:lJ3fnl10,t[s]n3r!nrnnfl.1u91ffllrn

flu:J'tfloflfl?s1at 1r1'l: tqnfinfl lusll:l.tYlt1l

' itnrtrj uurrtn'u{.":itgar.t:ugir'lnrlu!'tru'vurvouranno"rn"unl
i,in,i (ul urinirl ,lr.rrryrui, uu,rn,u,n'rorlrzliru"ni,rLr{rnin

bu z:tz) r:l'r or-r+

2A

F s-+6 vi

c; oo
"?= .G
saiG
-di 1? .i

o@
;" .i

.F

<r- ^G

= r; /.\ -i

FE i- -: " 9

1 3- F - F l l

4E-6d 6

g 'F N F--.
I
- . r F= rF= " -d ^

- =^ = [c r

.ddY'rFts',- !
:FGE)EF.I.
F:--i-F=
{S.i: =
F I].i=
r-:-),o5'@EJ

29

orn8fi6tuen:"rrfi r:rosrfiu't6'ii:r:trguluain

fl3lUO0nli)u.Jtuo Ht iJnllflSSlJ:TLlon:lan0f'l1fll'IlT3s'tfu
iri l . l J"rd f l [ 1 ] L r . u - - Y r : E n : r ' : [ \ : " l l 0 . J : - u L " U ' 9n]) 1

Ard,'g

t lflrr"-'1fl'lu u n[ '] [1-t 10l"]11"81t1'.1r111\.[a'fl.]

:vr.rirl.f:l '[a!io.i :crvul nrnfl:iu oanrf,aru.atian-rLrlor

;,c

1.l5gxrstuuRrn0 "l u0!:JlJ1m

4.1,3U lUU',tulftl0lullo{:gula

n"rfinr:ur:ruriruro.::"gdurrrntun,tlnn"nuc*g1r'r

tdTUjl-n ( f c o n o m i c C l a s s i f i c a l i oInl f L l . , l l q i U :: l J,l l l l;Yd rl ! U 1 l

U L

t n L l o u( l r c n s f e rF x p e n d i r u rne ): t g a r t l L r b-

r - { o n u-n l l . n Y

U)n^lf l:"'l(Exhau.ri\eExpcdi:LlUunrcrr)10":3".n!::[r11
r il fi r^lt rutunl:nrl qtflTLtflr.l::tr$ 0rl11l1.r5:1:Jl;0

t ]ur'rrjYrurullJou tl-lll.:ut?tlru 2517-2518 :run-uYr

dl 1ltl l!lt0fl ng l4 , II

fiJU^HsU l0 l l 0 J t u l l t : : J l T l t t l g n ' l u Y l n ffit

q L-aL r . l ' l t h , n- g

n- l l n l l t t( l sl-. 3 I ' ' l.qnF:ldlLll ll1

;ct ur1 01{ nu:runrrYNr,lrJolr0.::s]l1:Jnl{sr51l

: l u n' - E I H r u t- . t

?tfrlllf?tn1: r?1 n'tTtt01fl1l0.l:t]n:Jf,'tunallltn*frxl:J
lU,rfr::ul n):n:?nlUllUtn!:VglTlqlln ofl,1',tlUfi iq-IUU

n [ : ] q n f l E l h ni r L t B t n l j : r n o u f l 0 i ) - l u x . u Y . . L l "t"0. %l 1 lf:lu

30

T l U nlT ri',rnQ:J O. r : lU nr ,ada m X 01 4l4i.1d15c1:

Uu:3 YlUfnlofln0u

4ln'r,nrirdi:"oudnoc- boloiluilufirflutiulou :rsnr:

fiJnnt?u1,11ldol tunt:s?un:Situttluftlllg{ rf]f1t1[4uxl
f:i t Ll,{ltil t]su t.ruo0Liulnonng111:tlnn' \l-quvu

I YAe I ;cl a

8O lnlnsU{UlltJsru8Ynltfl:b'nlfl fi' 1U:lUXl!YNjUl:u

loulusl1]$:t?8nnflxlt|fln0]Nlot 5'ru3Yn.1lf1:B5nq:?g1,1

rhrtu rru r3uor"n6nr:riru:'rnuirn3quulnrturirxt:'lr

n:: n:?l1l.l. u (UncrnploymenCt ompensation'1, 8'l I

t- fl- ruvl.r r3[u l,f? | n-:t$i-JtoJ:5!1n11-tFllJ

:.lTr-ll?r:J

sl nflR'ILr[fltflftfl'rut]uloT31,r?1.J!'NYutNqJ):.rnu9r

nn!t:11{1.txl!Y$rfif:i Lvft'tliJElnf't1.tn.1nnl']|JrJ'tnlu

0nrlf:'lLS 111llj11.11,{LilLt.n? nl:iflflT:LJTnlt

nrsr:ru:ro.r:"5urnu.r:lf:iosrnqnisiruri':!n::qru:ru'16

& v ,s

ll:!{1rt9 Lf"i :l f 1)uL t-fl 1rl tfluf't5inloL00}.J ts1.tL:l rl

nr:finurnr:nrm:udrnr;r01,1firnnlrlr usiryirfirfluod

q ts .;req r T U, u.Ilu l Jli.l t nn] Tifr 6::!: nt:d 151 : I uv l 0J

lutln]L iJY[r"

13'ln fll t rylf.[n ].lT:,r{{LluJl'flr1[0.] llnt!T:{']g

;d $l , : l ' A1 ] t ulu.{u"i l l t l uvt! fi -l l l t s!ln . qJ

?t x.l3 lnn1.ilrngNfl5ru3f TJtt{

,&
aof,:lutn't:f,'r51:0.1c[un']u flt1ltfirulft].J11tnn1Ttn!,t119

s1

; o 4r , . l

0ln: ltnBt'lflYlt:jrrrl:YnLlLflfll lynJ. l"I U t6llj00,J{J

:Jht,Lltttlft u14nn :I un ]bf1t;h, n!tl Lfln'1.trfYri ttit:iTnt:

toii-j (BenefitPrinciplcof taxation) ql-.JutR't:g9ri1-tYru

l n1:1frflTTU:nr:fittr'tTlu;910.i:six'l'.tiffl'ntrii:csrsufrrfia
nr6orn:lnuy,''l'nlll'rurxlqrilcrf:i6*1iu\fiirnr:s-od::
:.:inr:nrtr:u;lo.r:"gr-ndnrvurArI1ofr6nfnrtnfir:n:vrrr:t16

u:3iJ]fl t01rl1.tL:lOIE.tl[u1.t5:ii] t].J
r<

4.1.4 UlUlrlUnttt.lUolns

rr:i0rnlnt$Urnttflntn! lfr llTSiJri[:oun380 85H]11

.tf

nluYllJO0rJ {i !n:idTlioqlTm'lBrlr}|ln:Jd:rJIu!nor11n.3

(Tax Rcgressi\,ityd, tun'tu lFLafLTt{l ntlJtiu Inqlf ofln

n:::Jolrntulrl"lfrtgrunnn'rn't.nLlfr"ht.t:0unl5r 20

:ior:r'Ifqi rnnr:rfiu16otno:"rrarnsr"o.rnr:1{nur:5orn:

; aq

lnTo.fiJlo nlTn:8119:tutqt!:39'r{i9l1nti.tu5tllJ[n1 J]'tu

11t:flntnu1nflflJl[.iutf]ung?t:v€fl1{tlr1rfru1 :tfru'tn

LnT1fiT-{Eq:J]'U1r9lultl6ll- l .7111{ Ta\ Progressiviry,

$flrfi't11urua{fulltn 3 d;dr !vJl,o1[.819?1 : 1 ' turfrllj 11311 r

JIruYr}J

e a d tVa \''
:5U1frtTUnm1J0luuL10!1.lo8iluJ1i:nJ lfr:Jnr:Tl::Jrflrn'rftl

'NU, tCOn ;ca t.ruI'lnllnSn: flfil]t]Ju5r1t0!1.3q:.rnrnfu

n

s2

J l9lJ16l- Jl bi r' . t uDJ1'l:l^IUn'CuapiralGainsTayr
nru?rtlll]Flu11LftlJLl ft,itflu't1't'tn11nl:lfl|':Iu lfl:{61t1.JeTfl1

Jl-luoln:nuJtilx.Ltfr:1fTi 'r,r||:lunfl]un{ d.l:iltfiq311 l11n!1

t x J f l 1 , l r : 1 1n,lI: n : r s u:]glfrl):r r d r n : Jt a L !^' n1,L l ' , y

nl 1' uu

lu::ur.ln1-rri n':r:1ufi.,unrr! lnrrnr':l 'Gorn:16fii,r1fi
r ,a 6
n'll nllx1lt't10.1Efl:1n1baiJfrn.l1rinn fiftJlli [1'1lr

,{ ai

:gurn:J lfl tt'nri4oln:luutfr:0itJoluf r:n:inlu:Tr k]r.li;-

Yt61ahr t[]l1.t1i:::J

IH.lui.j11ltll "dt'l 1q:lL flfl. ,frfl3lu[.t1,[1f]jlnftn

f .T: r Jf ]i1lfI'rn1d: In )eratu: J: i ] r' J A u 1: ysl u11f4l[r I ? Y u

16't.?1 unf1l u]u

r u u n ' l : 3 t r n t l : 1 . l 1 t t I u 8 . r n ? 1] un[1. :]ul fll0u nn n n t r T!:J f ] l

a d7

ldu0n u18:l'tunr:ff:lflrfl'lrrlrulu1lt3[1f1lfxlunlfln]r

1 !a ;: l l J l l Nw 'lt uC u "q L rqi . l uo . I i tn6!du u . d , u , i u . l i.q, t 1 1 4t l-n x 3 xt L

tu {n f 1Y

5 d c; e
:r tf i.l:YI {.fl 1 r ur:T},i.J'tnlxr tl"lT"'nt:t't 1lh:[!.]ur.Jl'1l

fJsl :1 f r ! n\]luSI r. l tA rn?1 d ru 1{ 51xu1nlifr:1ltln

r11',r n'rr n3

9lOLltlluQnnltt,F0l: r)ql'1lYfl):lY"ilU r;
t0'1lJl'l:fl0:

6 J.S.Salkin and D. Chalayonwatn, Changesin Tax Incidekce
in Thaila d fron 1963to 1968(nim€oqraph, 1974)

7 Sirlriporn Kridakara (H.S.H. Prince), Sone Aspectso,f Rice
Famins in Siam(BangkokI SuksitSia . 1970)pp. 43-45.

33

l dA : JU l' l lr'r' 1fl' n[n s r ' ]dul 1']tll1tlifirr y' d aA ,a
nt:rnr?i:tlJu:JlJt1nl
ir:r

lf lrn ! "L l . n l r / ' 1 0 .:U tft h 't,i t1 0 'n 'l l U r I tt- 1"11l":U
0fl11Uunur.r:lnfrl 'nlr:Jlfrr.nJfT9Jr': lor!fl1,,1]y0!'fli

! : i" r' 5 L t n . f f l [ :JL .i Y l u {l tt? 1 8 i " i ,'n' "nL]nlt!n!

l^jt[:JU:J1L"r,:nr]XfiUn:n4t?t11ln.l1y:n;3ql:J:'tul0l:ys-lxlt1

ln?:rfln?111q?:n:"Luhn3nr uJyIn2 IU In1L11?Fl?tlJ

:11l!:.tu'tfll1l

,r.
4.l,b oD:rtunatufla:gltryu I trn:lnnn

r t:: ):, | 'L n t l,:: . .Y < A i ,::J11,.1u:

tnl LrtL14i" |'6]|;1,,{1l,f{strtt

ffqc:"nur.r,lr:n:lutxirar iur"r:rl.nlri:rLrngn:'dr.ru: rsflo:o.r

1r0'r J v rnl!J: : L r f u :l t r.- l L d r9 r,L L r :5 . sL"n..n::J

URr' lll tl6t!1.,,lqslualL1frL)1"EL!ly - i ' , e ; 6V l l d u l o ! ttillu

:1

luTllttuuE,11 t.r u:trtllx" ]nLltfi.!dt:J [rn:hJr

n?1 1T.rlnrn3fl u fi111t1,4Uf t"r-AU ::ll]lyl:?ufl ?nuutu

dfiurnn:J n: [:Jx:i.Jn']:d.Jtf,:rlxixoc|ins'ntlul itslfln]J

Tr? 'l fitiutnn: ?t a awdll * dA

t'it:lfilts:u ltfiJ?u1l1.t nrhOustl:,luTu

n1.Jn1:t1,lallJot11.t1ur.filllIfrlTn0striJt1:qrnn:fil!fltr lu

yl0fl"r1{1u11u:liJnnsu aiua .l a
ly{0i{ lU1lln; 0.J:oJ1aI u Lflulfl

fl16l:lu: . . 9 1 L n U l L t T { i ) 1 . . n ) d t L' u l l al f i' o r' fi ln

n nl lln IL

hd6-r'u.Lrui113u aulLn 1":' iifr t .iNnJnf0l ,l1l)ln.:,t0 1

; q, e Lu!i!f,'tt-r:lui:tl.tll:3nr: t l;l o tr r1 4

llt0Hr:s]]rntrjnu trNni

g e ir n f l n,raJ :l3u x u? tr i n t Y r1 A ' lnlflo 1 .llfli. l0

m u$l.t11'T Tu'rn1:1sl1l

lJ'l'11 nr:T?lJnnx1J0.fr 1.lt' nfi :J151t\|n:f 'r?1.1t1:fi]unu

i',

nInl floifint:n'l1,,lyt't$r'tTrlJ0lflo.Jil:3trrlttf'ldt:lullullJlfr-

u n i f lr11d u v ;e . a v a

.Jn i1:51:lrnnnulJl0lJ.iunun:infln'nnruo$fl!'ln u

alnn1:T?xJnolJ9l0ltr"1/,{r10Lf 7t dglA dr,\ t In di A r o1.l

n1:0l.t.Ju s 3l v t l r:lx.

I

lll |:t lf] u0n!dirnrn?1{u1tx'',i0n.nl :0.::Jt,ln!f,;Lff{1{tiiJnutu

!a

1JUU]UllU t[fl3 ontflUqtn:lU Lgll']till0ii611't'fEnli rq3n' .l[n:]J

fi?flrlni T, AI Y nT: - XA y \l YA : Ull\:1!
10.ltu{uu']U?lalnll1ut
Yl.

t1"4'lrfl [%1utt11v,l8f]ru'lun1r1:Tu1:Jnn:Jnlrqr{ {un tirJl-

sli .ln:{ tl" nnlllots:t n3 nLlitlyf fit.F'tn'.!{L u' U

, YV A AA Y
1?1t14A]umfAl TOJ9tOJ{U{UYNalo,iUtlflnf]1J,ninUUl9U ?ll "l

Y;rXrt0|]1\u51uo1 1nnl,If1iusnxrqlfsrlin0ulrnx hnnflo

AYAYY

50Jlon'rn)lsusul.tlulru!31JfrT9tnf1::{s tf UJ:Jrnlu

8 ruuri,trr'n,inr: "nd:Lrarl::luuinrrra:rJn'rhJzarra'lmrrtr"-art
trtuotonf1ti.l ,u'"i: nrn,n"u2i 517xui 4l -78J

35

r19

4.1.6 ljlllJ]lt10{trl{rn1: 1flItrU

trl.t'tf,1l:-tfll{8flJsJfi_l[?dtllfntonsu llflfi.]6rnu J

fir.fln.rsnirrinriari".nrul.unil or'rru":o:1' ,:-,: 6o
rJ:rnr:u:n"lulr*rfiinrvffrrongrl:rrnr6ttunrrvrrir'l:

r lt- rllddfl tlllr-[1.lSt1]fl1.{lqtn: L) - ,T1l)ltjl14{r""'l [tql

tr 1 n 't: 1 , , 1.t'ftluuf1l .:l f 1 n Il: q l n ! a n : r l 6ia d | l ]'iud0nnl. 1

{u Lf llllt .:1.{

q,;qe

l1.l'l:tt3-tl.ln116!u.6lS) :!1n :fl ,l I li i .lluli ) t"fl r!U

lJ0.t:gr.luIf1:uSnnrnluuf]Jult fu1fl1:fl'r1l|{uq.J:Jrlnl:

frrfrr -un-":.rrlqlor:l:rrtrt:ugfrrlr:vnr:fiaott;i'jrinll-

fl ongurvijtiturql'unr:1r?frer r.:eirrdl(.:PorveorfDiscri-

mination, nnnr'0qYtd0n1fltd ntllny]l:fl'tTilnlfl:n lO ltflS

n:rForh " fll/ l6rt L"l r.arlxlr'!!Ls|r:t finllor"uu

r ,- l : v " a t 0il1t'ur.rrinrlrf"l l t 0 , u n n- r r n r u! [r,r11u]ntt?ilr["iJll

n

| Ad a
01u1qtin3lfll{oll.rqfl-tflntlufilut fli a frutntTl\-Ilfitu

tn0nYtl3tltnnft'lllllfru|tilt ttngtnonl]n3t [.|lnnf]'tlll.iflu

n[]L t[n: t0L1']51.|]ft1m:?{L{ l1tlin.unl t,ln!:: fltu tu
fl61fiTtn:T91',"]t.r l.r1|5 ',rfl]:1"lr XErUOiJ1o1fi1ir1r31113lS
9:ia:ri ur.rc:$-ur' "ru'rn'r:nrdtu,' id'i"qratooalo!,'hda"-on,

A1dn,l|ttA (ranl|dr 2511)

36

0 ] t ^ 1 1 lL '],) lill- ,.t .Js.0uI LLn:n: '0 xl-1 n f ll' t t nf l? u

n-:1f,roffn:.""rilvin.r"on".ffno-luort-J"tr, u'lur*n.ta^::f:f

ftll untl:3Luxu!tfr!rn0n11n4In ?.]f1rflfl{1rrur1s3flfil.,lfr:v{lT6l

ko v

1.,1'tntctfl1tlfltnoo0nttr l fln:1fl1 1,1t0L0un8fl:rnt:lelu.l

d.in!lnnt: fLl1.rx3t11ll.9t l'l1 5u1n1:1l1l1l{llft:Jfxl ufllfl lu

iunrr*:'rnrr1o,ld.lnr:4nrJreh5rsursirfqf!'fllfIl drdo:J

L ri't, . j r ,rlLl ,) - l ^'trrLn t 1 . , 1n r . t',. t u : r ^ ; 1. : Fr ' ) 'wn .'l ;t

9

r"i

dir-n f?rIn?: u6r;:rfrid nltlng :nr:u.r.l!:gtnllq3s.rfll"r

nlT SUlf]]:1',1]rUtU1.t dr U tX.tfl"r:1l11r15lU3ll',lilfJ:U5nn

llolIx, lslt 5

tlt{]1in- ,1t 1nlu

4.2 itl(1lflntuuofl:gI fl
fr!'IJflLJ1.rr1ll1lifitfl:USn^n::11?'r.:Il:ctflFlnr!1fi:cul

1.t"rufilfr:.r611t.n{q6jtx.ntlt r r [v LrUu]n! 1iJ8rna14tllll:8lnn

f l o r J v l 0 l u l ; 1 ! t t T J E rl.r1JlUUr u o J l l n o ' r s 1 r 1 . l n ' r : r l rlol n. Jg

El mml , tt f l: u 5 nqf1t 1' t1J ll :3t c ;n: 3 n lu o' u!'ili'lei Jl d lYl u x. i

l1fnJ1 lfl

n- ;.

nr:fl1.1::ti1f10I 1l"r.iu:iul[in :JC]lnl111.in]:rr.Jtl0niS

or ql'nJIfl:ulnn::u?]J!:gt?]fi[alnc]1.ornfl'lJU'ln]JltuulYui,r

deuilerlo.rnlfri :sflifl:cuir.r::lnflrfindu'lIqfir8.rrttfil:r;

rlTsryrfJxJlr'roll.til l :11:luu[.i1,1't0]x.lrs1]1{n'l::0l:.J0J

a?

iJxrdrrqmr'ltr':ugfrrnio:rq;liril-rertxirflulun'rlrs1.l111

f.in|:u LflxuT31r:1.r11:JrYfrtf'tl1?,Jfi).rlil.t5?,ll,ltfr?t9lnn:31,11"t.t

:.1:ln rvnu d:.nflu: '"uorr,:.,:vri"Jtrtnl : r:n:ru

:g',1'l-r.rd:gfl[fltrngotL;{t:rttno:gu':t :gtnri

u-nrn::1n5rnmnioi:lurir:l-rndue'ir nr:o"r:sv'jr.r

, q r , : .d li u t. ll . lotdn e. ,:.'o y,tult'1r:y"1.nft"rn'-1^ l

::.t . n n" ur

l1nfll',liln'lrXnl[t1,1.1f]l,!JUl q A

r'11lf111ryl0.lll:3['nr11lu.l

q3fl.1fl0ntinitfiifl'tltaiqLlfirl::rYrflLa,i,l0rifnriJln:e tflfl

oro-narrro"r:,L,r-uf,rnOr:ruf3rl:: u'ir.:rJr:n:n'td n1:fl""r

:sl,1i1.rfi-sis!nli'frl!lfinr"oafri vlro.lrl:rtrruluri;;rnnfffi

n i : v 11 ! A J-n 1{tt n- 3 d 1g 1!\!t}rJ-lf l , 1} A {o-filn | A i43lu

nr n, nu 1$t fln1 .[ nr'' ]11

j, d, a r ;d w Y
nfL€[ a In:.1fi'Tt.19]nlnfl$0l;gtYtfllt:.lnt?ft)ll|]n- i{
x^:nln

d.i r).fnf LL '1llif n :

[u1,tr[fl1"'frlt)uf iT,lflifl,{0r:.li.{ut l;u

n s ] : g ? t J | i 3 [ n f l 4 n f ] 0 r U l 1 r L l l L f r u f i 3uf nt ::f: l : i f i n - a 0 t l -

n:Tfllft.] t[,r1r51]n3tl1r .Lr 0?1fln'tfr.ljJ}r;trlff1uou'JtalxJ|:nl

uufit1.tlfYl tIl[),l|lI tu:fliLltr]iftI |utllu.t' v-"
n'n.lln :111" tI

llll"mflnJL'r [!a!r][fl: tL,1',l|1t1r-l:;.n401)"]1:rJ n

n?lfr:Jn'tTn.r0n11'llftr3.f:lf1r {nT00n fln!ftxulll:ptJnt[liN

at I

R]Url',l',ll.rl1{ ,11nn?]lUfl .rnlrNl,,lt!!ri.lluntSs:t.t5t o't ]n

38

rio:o.::rnvriruror.rnrrn::uiyl:orn"tolnr::rrndr::-

[Ylfl0Junfl lln:!1ll?lfli]!: Ulr.i!Ufl lll l'!l:tJ]llsn r'l.U tl11l

qi;nr:n-r'r:'ir,:r!nnrrali::riuraaf :.rn".rnnn'nlriiu

.r w d o;.q'! n3!:3t11fl

unnrrl,flurnrllfll:3iYlfll1vlfll i|tn'lu,J:')lrs

oflrJv,rfullt!Jnunt l un^:?^ tntt3?.tA:0,l A" dt v

un1l 1-]u- qllfld-.11.'{n11;

ni n:3 ',t6{51T[t1lI il::?9] fl1fifl: 18.J1.1',]3[1fol0uy]0Ju1ttfld3

rl:rrnn

1.1t:[14ffO] ll1f/]!11.11'?'-)A1n tU0flf iri:11t1,ql ltl] U0"lTll'l
"l

rinrirrrnr:rofrro.rrl:uvrorr'tidrurql-r:r::flruiinrl:d

"11-L :"r), fi rk.ti"',1J,'tttej4.'fcor-omicS.lrpius)r::'ll

i.l:g[1ffl0uum^Aftlru t1,1t3: llJtfl|lL]tTnflurrrEtl0lu$l.uj::'rqt-

ornori'ilismorurtirursn-n:!ri:r:q6sfi'll.iLrnr:rcvlsrgd

n'mfr1.lttfl,,lltLltu0Iut1.tn:J10l(l !t3[']1f]0lillr fl a.tllltIil

Lr: dl^61)Lt).: )lflrl )'-dl"tl lyln)l:,,q:[ ("d]nfld

l:;tirr:rlrri"urqq-n:r:;fifiar):l:nnoorrrirr:rflutfiur

flnrf6l un"roErdr?n::i.no.:rJ:r;drrue'irJq ttnvriiuuurir

r"fnlfrtldrr:-rrfiolu:rirx.rodn'l1ni::J lu :nnn:Jrriiturq

|! a aC
tlt'tu nl:$cTo:3rl?]J!:3lnflnJtnf]9u l]\51;?slllnalu

nrri.:ffuei'roonlur]:c|nao'o:n:rn,ln-sroruu.lr'iaIful runu

39

qt0.l:3[Ylfl:J1110',ru'l]unltq3t!"1' -t1.l1uYl1....l,l€"":-", """"---

,t.

orn: !t!r118dna)[c81r0r1]t3r11fl0liJnnq?BoLrlnr?o1

T31,1J'1l.li:t11fl1l l!t1/t111filfii.l0-111 rt',l'ttn::i\n l.t:Jt3[IflaJ]
tn^ sfLl1.r!1t5'tu,tt1lax1,tu1s,9]o:o; .J"n,'9l[t1f.l]f our.l:,r1n

lu::r:r,rnln:n:rlrnnR;ltso.: tlt:rrar,"oilr'rur

.1 !

LUUe'l:J't,utn:utdnT-{ lJntt[u0.] ffil;t:t;nui/tflJ1ll!:3[1']fl

o$1nn:.rn$lqrn1:ltflJ't{r]l:3trlnnin.J3[uIn.Jn1:1\!t1r1i8ld11lr-

flT:Ll 1l:3[11f1F0ll]1ft1-l"lQ.illl11,/rl'lt?r(nT'hJe Latc-comel./

d|, A @a A
lunltl"tflJul0it$runT::Jnt:t:rur'.1:J-1lx1n.tfllnrittl?,.uJqJ:J

a

1''AaAflttr L:J[',lo,]rfrUtlUt:lln: t|n:l1f]tI nt:n flf)url:3unn'111u1

!. * i

9''11.11"1l 1tl.,tll'J ll ltlg!:gli'li-l11lifll'"1-ll[l0u1t?0.]r,r iual:-J; li"'l

t T r . r .l,1ln 0 tfllfi ':1iJn t'./f 'll)"ln) [1\]J! " t E irf ld).1 . 1

llttui.tl3fli.Jll!flutll [tiigaln1-]:3i]aulcJ:tlrqtnr; Frfnl lt t1.l

, tY n-:l:]1.till.j-tllrlf,JlunlT gJ.luroflrTfrf T:ltn

tl::itfl fl[11 u1.1[,

tl1r0td!0g1.Jrl11.'l,31n: 'l:11:ry:0! 01liJl-l:vrYrfli1'r'f\lJ1-r'llLfln u

L Ad W
n1: - ft t09lslun:::Ju1.l t:J0[::.ifLun:3]J41n't ],1flutafti 1,,1.

n:: g"rndlgfrlnrri r',"1oens::ri:crryrsirr.Jinnn:ru

l 1ll!!::tltf1Yr r * a vr
0Jl1.{'1ts'lqult:Jlfl1fl1 0 |l,tiat ut n-:t"tF]iL1I0.l

:3tl'tflnot lutn ni:fl tnItttn:nlJl']ltfl,lfr'1tlt:3u:LtSftt:u

40

n,J-i:tn)nt1]::tY'ltv,la"J[nI r'!.tuntuq.L3 ll [1.t

l"u:;i,r'ir.tJ::tnrlrornEirin"unr'nr,::ori.srnor:stltfl\yrfifl

Lnrtfqr. t.il,li llf 1 .Ll .inLL ui Ll]n'|lrulltfrhi'ttfr"tr,l

nrr:Ltufrl rlucfer r t:r:.:"nr:nn:roxrlrir'lnr!f'hui irronnfl:rt

lurtrtfl: [|sl|:]q3rtrftlf5lau1t:rx1r:'rt tnudryrdt[ontrT
a

?1',t.itfl:b3n1l fiJoLgr:Jn1:n'tsuffiryQ"urLx,:JJ:2r 398{r

ulfi3lrn9raisa!rflLsflnflJl0'tn'd:-f01ilnnn: n'ndrurd8dntr

flr,hls-r'fi rui-rr.lunrvs'r'-i.'::-r:rf i,i"t,r1#
r:urf:l.nrdiurqr'n:?::6rrjfeliounrl:cluninrrrn:ugil

1lnilr-3t1'lflLl'lt0el"n-elnF[nlxn-l]l]T:tnilnr$rTnnrnr i.lnaflr.r

firflryt]l:J1t]nll0:i:l tfr01tl,lt.frl 0ua3u'tru14l9ltltrlll8tytflon
g'la€era1iul n1: tnd1u1nfel :01]llln'tluJ on:3lm"r.rlt)t:ltf]nr1,1uo

n'jrrorr.j:;rno:rvrdrurql"n:rl:u:n6r1::rsirgunf-ryrur

flrJl\U5lljfTlUl1 fi.11{?5nltnt{1frTflfi',]Urn nr. fl:USnq

:yu'iri :crrfol s't!':lrrFni^r,uuclu',rdlu:cusvni

f fJnT r :1nJnfr Y-l uTJlnqtyrulu31 lu:gl?tflr.rJuanBSiJ

: Jr1s0r

[[ n{n:r r0}.]fllrluur!a:ar:.rol,ttfl!:nJm"o.tdin-url:gtnfl

r,lrdrulq-{-n::a:::6Jfrio\rinfilrnrfsf :lf nll'ti u-liauyrr.r

nr:rfio.:tsxf'i:r.rl'r*lu'rynrf:lrrnrrrnerrlrglugdsrrvnryrfi-

4l

o ;v

lrU n?flnlTnllluEl.id',1[1-!wli.:1flr:J0rulStl tLn ]1tllUTUY)

u"r:.r-uso.::l::rnn:lrrdrursnr "n:nrn::"6ufir:rrl":rcno

nr:lu ::r,rfi'ln!r

u0nl1.u0q^o']r sxJ1.^ru5Yr1,Jnh!f1:u3:11I2lll t:tmq

lu: ro.rnr:ni:vr,rir:l::rnnrrn"nrrrn.Jl:rs1'1'ir:hyllrfl

de dl

nu,]|ul{tntnt fllT9rrT'lfrff'luInulrl.itf1iu5nq13t1l.4J:.1:3r11fl

6n,nisq5.rardrffr'rnr:n.:trurortmeirl:cr:nsfrlylulfllnu

n:fdi rutrlr::rvrrrlyurnr:qrnrrnnur3umunrslu:l:c

I t f' l. n{ ; tt t n u t u r u f t . l : 1 1 : t lrltrFf-t : i l Y i J l f r i J T t f r / t a tnn L :t

uu

tra n'rnulur,rl.rsr1,ii.trrx?trn:n:fl:Jyuti'rnnrulu:J:c-trfl

n'n-r

'lnuroi :l:ctJg{ro.rnr:nrnu::u:i;rrlnr'11unr:nnfiarur

nrrenqrro!Ssururnulurl:srnRdoruu"rol:rcnr.r:nd.Jri'e.r

il J 1 . l,l1T n " Y ) l E : $ 1 ' l s) r : J ? : t y n r flT qLorJsnoeh"1flrtnT

h

$1rll,1luut:J tl,vT13l0ntffYtaJnnla0alB{tuo:J?1'NlflTUSnn

E rLfrgtaY{]:o!'r.l:un.l: d ;y l

9l0JltglYlfJ[e19i0r1r]uJu:Je'lntu

utluei',:r 6nru":n-un:"'r.i.r,nrri.ur:nlr,:rn"L'si,u:;!rr":uS-

nntflu

.I Ae
u-ntflTuSfl'ldo,ltnlnluf.ll flnlo'tinult n't1lJ$rJ1.{u5

11rrlf]fi.jsni::fi )1J1.]T36T1!4ud01,:nl1tf':utlrn0n-tr€ltuSni

42

:911?1.fi1:gtl1iJf1f,l YlUn9lf?l txJtrnflfl110]1r31x.lg11'Ntf1:85-

ffq:su'ir.r:sinafri-srurun-rn-uj::rnstn-aaiyrel"iwuqfuiir.,

X

r[nx frxluf']g[11n8:5n?1,1r1:-3[y]-fv1lqlf:]JlnnxSluinJ'rnr?niln

'arsl"ru!uuus::iJttsitfioqrfnlzt unyr{nro:trf:ic1,1ir.!

1,lr:;3q t'4fl tflunfrrnt1,1lf1lqflio.tfl'l'tflut14noT3u2"r.rll:3[11c1
luaufl-t!u t:1u0 u]n q;oml4?J']]fl11J51ftl n0:91,r't1.IJ:3t1r1

q8fil 1:0919lu:l:gtnfl0091\flJurl,lnflu 1ln'ttn :[1,l.Ju?]tJ

!! ;l a

UlflqUL,iltiJoV!nr: lniolnll:gnoUlolnll X'lUll1tl0t3lr!li

1.lTgt11fi||n[:X',]q3ix4l1fi.?l ',tfl'l'tu$1!!nolSulNtlTgtltfl lu:lJ
l.l1l{7[Nn] lqUldu?' (Granr, : u dfl1'l fllu tl,ru:.nqg[llu

n1. flUtlln0 lL:llt 1LL1,1(nLoan, {JtrU'lilt:tn? fl:'liJ
;-

{:gtl1n0 :J u'td'tt.tutl1tlfltrfll] aJulltnxlun |lnl:gtltfl

qo!l,tfljut nlJ 03llfl0tJnlufl1Jc'l lflUtitl l1tou1tu.3l0lrnllu

.,t , 10f^6 1 , [tA:,1:]l :iltU::.rfrtn rf0l ll: n \Procu.emenr

t1 l f|l

Tvinel.tnlqoiJn1"LLnrL:Tl.mflul lntinllxlu] lfr:.Jntl)u

, !'

lftSlf,y,I]!lProrect lvrne, 10ilny,lul nlU!dlJl1ll1,1li- fl

A1n[1lUl]13lfl{Ufl Oll:ll?lf1flOll1,!it}li{1dU1lllll{TJttngUlrJnlU

nxlxJ{1tltnorg1:,tr.fl113tllf'nnldrn0In90.t3u! sn:1:tfl
ufl n fl tu:J

13

6. tl o t.t qfilfl'l'luulfl0u

1lra0fl[ nl:llfl

frrdru16rnuonur'rjrunrlflilrnnuflitr.J:rngnr:oi

f, Ll{U (AbsolutcPhcnomenonU, ln1]l1l]l1.lll:1nfln11ll|d-

rnr"llrudnr:fnf lrrudrvuoulautrtnvrrar:nro:rlrfif:ilqvr

fnl:JU',tnqt1r{l|u111VAl0ifin:iTalnt.t slfl0{n'r1:Jfl1flluafrlr

no.:rr1:1Jfgl uv unl:[n'q! uA

Q11']19[1lrgu.ti1n1:tlnr:.t]rJr,1't11t1!ntfilf

Iv f' "aJ l l lu\ 'tAfal9v tll , dI u? 1U Q l 4rntl r'nn YA

lYrru 1r14 filluqlfl.rfl

rfllrJro-rnrlurl::rnrntn::JqR"flnr:ucuryorno ndrrlou

5l n11 U1nnUlUl.ll^lnqlnn'lTfl:;1l'nlllYoll1ln'Dr:JaR.lsJ

011r1Xyt1:]JJ[5flnnr UJyrLfYl rUtJfl{rU3rqlrnflU fl21 n l\Uf',

YltitflT145tn::14'Ifil:;rYrflIr tfl:3:rllfl 'firr ldinirurni:r

,q L 1 , t T - U^l,lrt:li1Ul 9q

fit1Ilullt O- fl.1^[Uf ]Tllitt$rTr.itn8nlu

n1:[nllruuinl'tdfnq !{s q;a l, ,alq.rl: r d w .rI(lro,nH u

qfll1 n

(n) 1n:.rn:"r.rrinvnr:n:sqruriruors.:rrrnr:rfi

t/ \1 . / q n t T l t cu l ! : g t fl

tullrtrut

(o,, lflTlnn ]Ju0u :ssl8Jl,lu]ru[u]ltJ1n

(.r,1fl'I fl ltusYllrlfl:B3nn|.|n3n1,3n1:$J0.t:J1,1?',]t

i:rrno

44

5.1 <trOo{:{n:.l. t0vfl1:fl5gs1golul0t'l'l{n10:J0t

r..!J01vl9.l;1" dt ; , xru' l l,Tl r[ nuQ]r ' tlfr .lJrlf l lu:5)ru

1n]t!ufni sx

tE:U.]1d "Tinnl1kflE0 )i] n [ . 5 1 3 v, . l l f l T l ' nlflel'

5uhf ]

9q 2 Llt ,

9l? 1J9l"l-i:,i llns;1sl1d.-lullt- $11f l 'l:tlflllll14-14US 910'

::rulfi:uj;no;.inrirxfin-.]lrrn:iuinun:rusi.rlnc:0.:qrn

a ' l l i J 99 .q:l r ) i-: r Yb nr:

l i L n Y t f l g l uU-: f l l ] f n J l . { 1 , 1 . L U f l ' lL : : f l ' l n t

ttfirl4urnrrrrrnnufinnn:sirun:rgfrounrnJ:s.[rqrinr.r

lfl TUqnnl0Jnn!{ u ;c. 1 1?11.lni :aLJt [ n; 01u1n njrlfl : u 3-

l']ijo1u

I

flx tfi5jfi:1.lfl1in1:tlJdlan9rfl.J:Jnnlnflq:t in tllsu{x{

!fl FL:rtll,lu:JL.nt u lfi::l snt,huq .ul0.]ulnt t-dtrIiT tql

11TdHJrnftllJ:JnnInI r':ll]nuut.ijr J:51t]s l?J011l,v :Jr1,l
{,

SSUlOirJO{1aUri lflUtula.I'U [[A&n"{OU1AtrUO!].1$1,1

ri,:ln:.rnirrrrrnrnfiorfrfi:rngruodr:ll:uc:s;:rrikou

, a )e a , q'

1U"r1itll'' ,]tlt-Lurl?inntaotovn1t1:.nn1!1ruftul1l'tut11,1,1us]nI

t,a ,. ,ct-

l!"h 0:J:1tU{u1d, 11"' Ut rul: t"sl111.1;gnrT}.1"0J14!

rrrirnuvi.:nfinrro.rnq--.sn:'nio.rrr:lnsirrntu r,toi '16:-nrrrr.r

llru$olliilntJlnS :55::tJUIIJYI:lJIOUtUY{1.''lLrJnf]:8 1 l*r

[f uTsn::iJunJt[11rT1]taon'rTInu ]\llsf'nrrif 2517 dAr

fi'lfi:"!finiutouqrn:J:nqucior.rsqrncfri6o:J:s1ug;sio

46

lnf u [n rt1.!ua0]Jntnd au Jnn :0r11r'1r4r1/1 ,{ttn

ftfl.tf1i :l0rYufur,li

rJ:rlamidrueururirrfnl -q ueilu:suo!nr:lno:oruur:

r.113{1tnru! :5!]n $n1[u flo][1,1qR:3ntl1r flor1r10f1{

;
r1.r:3fn:J5llI::L ]n!:l S]t rl Lfl|1,!i"t0t1rJ"f,l! :r[r nnrtur

r]fi fn.ln 3tr a t dga .$ V r sr Yr . e x.ln1nx . l f lLxr.t1llu

1.lu so J[Y]lut5utrn

ltTL{i-r l t l h ^ v 1 F x L"I rrrr [ 6 )" t : I n 0 Y ct u a ) q ur r 0 f t 'r'l

'n l l[ nn lt u

.anentiEinUt\:-rdab-rJr:'"'tn,,ro::5r-rnl-:uol'u'trjrun:cr"'

n:ttuu A lAiiAtiiliZn r , l u'l : r dfnl ig ( M ar sin avt otec ain ) r yi'ln "l

toa

7 ) 0 1 ' ! i en ! " f l l n d 1 . n L U f i l " 1 g n , ; 1uq l el t a : tr : l (/ \larginal

qrl L fl lt

Vote LossJ 0].lulUtln1lflflriln:lnlB 0ln:[1,]:J]l1,llliol.l'tiJ'l
.0
v, _! n,JtruYr
lgl]fl01-r:JutuLl'till]nrfult? a,run;rl fl't]

:)U]n tuTJlrol lJ:yt]n U iEili.,)r[81ti:J It U?dfir ![sr.!u
<<r-<.ttt-'9

t1"t:rn.rauslltllJaIntra{fl v[|uutdfl n(ooRfl.l r1r't1ru t|91.ftl

Vd u tn n , iJ $ ;d- t r^ n tf l;t ! 1.t l. ugf.iJ tl 5 :fn t f'llu n xr

n:3x{unqlt n 1;rfiI

fl Inl:t' Ufll11tYrU l[n:Xl]-T;Un ,d fi 6l ].U'ql"

lfI,i.[nL

[LU]l:iJ ::Lsllll:95 511LFUnU:turltnyd:f tlqr- .:r!nuL

a qr{, r j

tlUAl)l1lln lnUflU9] [ rlfi til - otlltl$ [[tJ

'1'JtsUtflt

to. rl? n:o.ltto'"ru-nre:rgaran:1orR:tr:runr:rlrggrii'lnuorjri'l:"
,rrarrrrrorrorf ifi: r,iui l (rq!nln! 251?)n l', zot-zzt

46

n:3 !ltnllfrinnt't n3n l!fi1fl'rxt-ru[1\Dlfl,n] flIJ :lofl: {q3

anqr"oorird'enrixquffrgi ru:n..r:n:u5frio-uqqi,r"a'01fui ou

finu'n|6?tnfufl't:nlft:Lllt' f,flrtnon,iN ll?'ll:-q31,1lif1]0u1.J

1:'ir nnirtuiimornrrrrnuri!^xqnsrl,,rQof:r?-l-uJ'lrnfinr:

AYA-

t:.lai iln3s3 N1.lYt0.J:Jfnlions3u'tloLlstlnn:tln'lTr on ln

v\!lllur[ [['.. 6l? !4 [?Lt:{]fluT

ull.rtY r1.":35'\0 rrr

ufnsx.ll,tu:.1'tldqflrlt on lln3l{f{115?]tin'tlliJo.:0ut.ll91xJ14

r'rrnrfti:urluu.l':"rr;tiorLur'.:\i:jrlfir1:rtmumff rldr;

srftirnrirn:r:hilrnr;nlroqff;li-u:Jr*ullnr:rio.Jeiru"u

nit1lU1,11111e1i$1r.l{t1"/.\1;,11('El li!es) n3fl0.rl.lnn!; 3t"lf 1-!t1,1iJ

a 6r,:1 o . e- o".;-
nluf rltnr:L ?rn ItnglT;{raNl]:B tu{1.r0u1.l\f.r]llnfrlrnn'rr

lSfifl 5n'llnl:t:JoJttfi{qlu

n'l141nn'lTlt:in1!01uln7t1Jn't:tlJu0J$i,l1ftt1,tfnl uttu

n}T9t1l':J:UuEtUryTn',trJfltn$ r ,:n)i" ,10u nYt'-'t:
rrJ0l0u'NYttf?t l8iJn:j0:Jntl.[t.Jox{l10 qlr u Ll.tfl"rTtln!dnl

n?] lllnlu llfl $J?'tn-l:llnn:oiq:t!u:1i !l1llfl 1,,1-ttfl!

n $vtn;1 1 x' q'd n l T n T 3tn80tu l qnt . ln1 :t u0 t0u1 t1 1tfYt Bin.t

3{xl1:Jr

tntloflt1,lsrH,l 0'lu'lnn'l{n]:tiJ0.iuou}.Jn1:nTgqllri0Ju"r.l

r?r'rilg n t lt1.111l7fr1u11l?.J11.t,Jouo0r1rul L1fn'tLu'ftirntu

17

2a r, I A a r ljnfl^nl A H ] t ll I e I Yr

fix{ lnft:oi ltn310 iJd ln?J t|q]su{utJ

!nq:O"tLet0:ur0r0 11"1d^ill, f F : firuqiu)3{ r:Ju tq

,.i d

xr1{1[Y1r."r1ttffllnlt:Iu1fl ']lrJfJi lltill:0u110ifi rn]Jl11luu 11rn

yt: tujt 1,4Ll11lun :$x:l 1111 Ifu f ']fl 8?:Ott lofr')Lfl.lslfffl

Ye v;e I
lflu?rs]tl1n! 0noxu 1i1nfu11{N:lnfr:o.:ng[unlg11n.lnn])

I !r . i { l .ut 0iJ f int r fl1:J5:T{ "^: n^ :itn- :f.-lr4NJ4 ,

191m 11 ! i 3X'tnfrl

; Yt,

t",rg[11lfl0x1.lo'i81,ll t UrtnLfl: tuf,]6l fuYll'!rf:0'

! ,l

IrJXJ,'.]1|tnUQU',tnl',St:ilUllsrrlr?U:1Br: fr?1UlJOl|fl.]:|1'11rJ

't I d g V

x tuu0u11'tfl1r:J:u[:.:s1r ltJ']l{l{su-f,irl n:o.:n3n'l1.lfl

r:Jtarsroro-.':lniadr.rl:nrrrl-oufrigra'ir.J$du0st"ilu

x J.q,j, q A.

01lli1:fl1 1l1l1l d.l lfi LuolqL::R[U iJ rUvln121"ri] tq

11 {d aY w. Inft :Bt:J . itf,l1 lqrnf-rlTJ1f1l gfl1 n9 0i111lsli

,l1Jf1l 1S1l tUU

t nfl0[|nx I Yr

nt:s,ir:nfiul]J{l.txuuraigorJulr,r']flunu:Jrfl

{lts1vtl-{,]Jnf:lo.10!fi 11na[nnfliJlft

5.2 rtn u lu lu ft15 1l011. 1')gll[511d

nJlfi

u-llflV. L t\''d Ju,i.t1 i 1., , t 9J . JutIfl:]r 5n n[6i:d^.Vtfr],r' [ 1.1,1 1']

nlfl:

u 2504iuuflu:J1 fJtDfurdii|flftnn]txcurJl: rL rr,l:JrL
ntr11n:lu.JnrJy,ruflr!:Ytilf10fnl n1'tr1,il:Jt:f1rlu.lt:$rslslrv 'tn

llfifltvr'tli13:Jltfnl l[:J']'Lt uLli.tuv,t,itrlulq'1:lrtq: lfl:ti [ 1

48

li:Jt:lnt:n::1'tu:i! LflltLJrllfJ::J l'1,f]]ll srlflgit0lnnnTJul

lftFLlluun l;fllrJLt|]x{lxJ YA A

lr.3utuotl'tannrnf lunl:}|9}J111

ll::[1]nfl lnf, n Llill11\s]1r[Jl]flfl01"1 nl:t tgt LllRlTictLn :

t.4ca'+

1\fljUrfln14nInnrntnufl:n:: tu fl]nry [u']1,r:J['lrnflrnnu?]f

luf l: fl ur!;3[ fl1.):J?f,1{11111,1Q]1.r,l1At]XJUln1 lrJUUIlJ"fri

i'-tullT.tfl.tllu

,A A l 4 l,lu1utif l3 f lnu?' t l n]?

fld1]l:rll.rv' i4l:t nflo u]

v 141

vrmu'l!::rr6 nt:tv filuorj t: nt,n01]:loJ!ru't1t.rd8llluolJ

$io1A?nn[nuli]'-[r1: f]nfl X.|lf'ir 1lnr-lnl'il lllfl xumtnUln:-l

! e| n-\' l9r

l!-r11rJM0.:n1ii46Ju] lt'aoyr!:'rYt.rfinr!01tr:8ue:':

nn0 nfr .rn:J'rutoinlTlirlJulrl:3r1fl1f:J$y olYlnl:11111

d <. a< taa aaf a
lJ'lll$ t?olll$l nxu 9t'tfllrfr oo{?flt{l.l lfltlu Uli.l

* Ae aa Ada

uullmnSflolflntfiuln flat all lnnlno?1 {2flllflno

n?olntxnf ui.Jfui qlfl1 Lfl l,tfttllti:.lnu 1011t:'Ir{.tv{n'l:1nfla

nrTtlillJltt [fr]lTy{ {,sr Lr:JrnTd0[n]1,113ln!.lq t:r"r tt 1.r

13fl0.111tl'llfl?alfrtll\ tondlfl ti lsocial Wcl[a.e) tJfllSlf,O

id !! io
lfl 0l:l l,l]ntJn't:iJns]iB s]lv,lfi1ut1u.in nfl']flo.1:fl!.'t9l

fizufisrlfiuo::rn:rir'l1ilu:r!'lfirl:sm{rlu6n:dffui:ru

g

tfl1l::{rf m- 'ri:.^hr1u ftslfJl fl;Ji:Ji]tu fl d:\fl ]fl iR rh-lgit:Ju

1S

vgA ! r i^ 3 .l a v 4,

YlJl.{luo.t5l?n'f|l]|ful fltnfln'rntn! 91ttnlu tf,J[?flno:Jtuxl

fiuo"untfqi rnnr!runra: Jsferf ro.rl:iruilf!i:rn4o:1iun6fi

:'rJlflul3flxTt- n1 d n :1{Ul, fl t l: 3 t I .nro dl

1 txlflL?i:,l11 !Jt nl[UU

fiwirli:rrnruin:"s6nu66urnm1:uJdrirbu-nra:rg-

orsniiirirr,runrJurrarolnru:ru:"l::r fllouoro"usifi:rd

[f]!:3tltr|l l | n : o f l: 1 ' ] ] t 5 1 1 q t ful a d! oA

lrnl.ttfTBSniI uosu

tufl n:J0ulr0tl{rJ.Jlu1ntfTTt45fJlfl0:l,lfltu'1iJ!tsrrJu"fli.islrJ

osntuufl? [n1 ax,a .010r?T{1btSflfllfisrT

flrJiJ91Sv1,rU5rlr0f1l ,1U

fi60ruurirflue"Eriror(ur5cfoin omrricauon)dr:60rflu

s9."AnA 'jfffiuannH'nrrfirunian(natonarityro) uLuuriorifi'jr

u)'uln uTtlltoltuun'D.lo'1 t1A4.0hraitJnittJaltl4:0o::fl1.1:g-

tUiu:JlnYlfitllYllYlnlngl:fJl (Utilitv MaximizationJUfl n

lflTbsflrfifl?n o?rrJd1r:nlun']T!:uuJ n?1 $ltflflJrJl[uB

lflh ]3[[a1n?lfI10ulnfl $fl']fln (MaLerialWellare , ) te

[vlluu

u-nt:fui ontanjg-.l1,ltn1xJr31!i0i nlr!fi 1flt.rlq (M"ot"t

werrarerf)lqn-rrn:i.llfrii n".ruu""unrn:t3ornnii.rrJ::riu

nrr*rnowuuaitrnrrn:3rlnr:n:orrlinr :xmrglunr:

n:ariyrfiurliosh6uurifi6o:co":Jnr:uilaunuiaiu.!'u

[oJ nb ?ulr,rflAfUlluunrfl:uir]rf,fl:qlflolrnhifiah.irn'cr