City of Sarasota Locally Historically Designated Properties

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
Ordinance Number
Sarasota Times Building Mediterranean 85-HD-08
Warren Building 1216 1st Street 86-2948 Vacant Revival 94-HD-13
I.R. Burns & 93-HD-16
H.H. Bell Commercial Bldg 1269 1st Street 96-3902 Commercial Mediterranean 96-HD-02
Russell Building Revival 09-HD-05
Sarasota City Hall 1296 1st Street 93-3725 Commercial 84-HD-04
Palms Apartments Mediterranean
Second Street District (2) 1490 1st Street 96-3944 Commercial Revival
Second Street District (3)
Second Street District (4) 1565 1st Street 09-4871 Public Use Mediterranean
Second Street District (5) Revival
Belle Haven Apartments
St. Martha’s Daycare Sarasota School of
Hood Building Architecture
Spiegel Apartments
Sarasota Garden Club 1227 2nd Street 84-2799
C.M. & Ruth Howard Residence
1249 2nd Street 97-3976 Private Residence 94-HDD-02

1251 2nd Street 97-3976 Private Residence 94-HDD-02

1259 2nd Street 97-3976 Private Residence 94-HDD-02

1267 2nd Street 97-3976 Private Residence 94-HDD-02
1133 4th Street 84-2726
1658 4th Street 89-3333 Office Mediterranean 84-HD-01
1385 5th Street 99-4133 Revival
1882 5th Street 94-3778
1131 6th Street 09-4866 Daycare Craftsman Bungalow 89-HD-09
1620 6th Street 95-3905
Office Mediterranean 99-HD-05
Public Use Revival 94-HD-08
09-HD-02
Mediterranean
Revival

Sarasota School of
Architecture

Private Residence 95-HD-10

Updated as of July 2009

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
Ordinance Number
H.O. Cheney House
1643 6th Street 99-4138 Private Residence 99-HD-07
Robert & Emma Kennedy House
1677 6th Street 87-4028 Private Residence 01-HD-01
Leonard Reid Family House
1435 7th Street 99-4172 Private Residence 99-HD-15
Brazil / Clark House
1660 7th Street 01-4321 Private Residence Craftsman Bungalow 01-HD-06
William T. Finch House
1622 9th Street 94-3774 Private Residence 94-HD-04
Whitaker Cemetery
Grover and Pearl Koons House & 1232 12th Street 04-4559 Cemetery Cemetery 03-HD-05
Studio
Norma Ziegler Freeman House & 1360 13th Street 86-9279 Private Residence Mission 00-HD-10
Garage
Sparkman Property - Home of 1243 16th Street 87-4393 Private Residence Bungalow 01-HD-02
Sarasota Succulent Society 1310 38th Street 04-4578 04-HD-04
Olroyd House, The Acacia Drive 87-5489 Not-For-Profit Frame Vernacular 01-HD-03
455 Adams Lane 00-4225 Garden 00-HD-01
Perry / Little House & Garage 1920 Adams Lane 01-4297 Mediterranean 01-HD-05
1958 Adelia Avenue 99-4132 Private Residence Revival 99-HD-04
Appleby Family Home
518 House/Studio
J.E. and Lottie Moore House
Residence
McCall House Art Studio

Dr. William J. Shields House Private Residence
Rigby’s La Plaza
Historic District (8) 2445 Alameda Avenue 93-3711 Private Residence Craftsman 93-HD-11

3540 Almeria Avenue 94-3852 Private Residence Mission 94-HD-20

1774 Alta Vista Street 92-3587 Private Residence Mission 92-HDD-01

Updated as of July 2009

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
Rigby’s La Plaza Ordinance Number
Historic District (7) 92-HDD-01
Pearsall House 1776 Alta Vista Street 92-3587 Private Residence Mission
El Patio Apartments 05-HD-02
Dolph / Laura Albritton 1905 Alta Vista Street 05-4653 Private Residence Mediterranean
Olive Brink House Revival 90-HD-08
Scarborough House
Charles Picket Home 500 N Audubon Place 90-3449 Multiple Family
Orren and Allie M Wells House
Ashton House 1707 Bahia Vista Street 94-3772 Private Residence Bungalow 94-HD-02
Etowah Hagan / Jackson House
Earle House, The 1735 Bahia Vista Street 94-3777 Private Residence Bungalow 94-HD-07
Thomas Home
F & M Binz Residence 2929 Bahia Vista Street 97-3977 Private Residence 96-HD-07
Cocoon House
Gulf Beach Motel 1731 Bay Street 89-3356 Private Residence Mission 89-HD-13
Van Wezel Estate (2)
1743 Bay Street 03-4506 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 03-HD-03

3035 Bay Shore Road 93-3726 Private Residence 93-HD-15
4511 Bay Shore Road 00-4229 00-HD-05
4521 Bay Shore Road 92-3629 Private Residence Mediterranean 92-HD-14
Revival

Private Residence Greek Revival

5030 Bay Shore Road 93-3712 Private Residence 93-HD-12
5050 Bay Shore Road 93-3713 93-HD-13
3575 Bayou Louise Lane 86-2947 Private Residence Mediterranean 85-HD-07
Revival

Private Residence

930 Ben Franklin Drive 03-4467 Condominiums 03-HD-02

535 Blvd of Presidents 99-4410 Private Residence 98-HDD-01

Updated as of July 2009

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
Ordinance Number
Bachelor-Brewer Water Works Mediterranean 08-HD-01
1124 Brewer Place 08-4774 Private Residence Revival
Bryson / Crane House Mediterranean 02-HD-02
5050 Brywill Circle 02-4397 Private Residence Revival
Owen Burns House 85-HD-06
Alva J. Fisher House & Garage 431 Burns Court 88-3161 Private Residence
(Rosemary Court)
Burket House 830 Central Avenue 87-3054 Office 86-HD-05
Mason House (relocated to 830 Central Avenue 87-3056 Offices
Rosemary Ct. in 1986) 830 Central Avenue 87-3055 Offices MOVED TO 86-HD-07
Rosemary Cemetery ROSEMARY CT - 1986

Tamiami Inn 86-HD-06

Riegel Cottage 890 Central Avenue 03-4466 Cemetery Cemetery 03-HD-04

Kennedy / Barth House & Garage 2747 Central Avenue 84-2826 DEMOLISHED 84-HD-08

Van Arsdale House 935 Citrus Avenue 94-3773 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 94-HD-03

Dr. Halton Residence 1826 Clematis Street 00-4227 Private Residence Mission 00-HD-03
Byrd & Katherine Kicklighter
House 1864 Clematis Street 93-3657 Private Residence Mission 93-HD-01
Mabel Nabona Woodhull House
308 Cocoanut Avenue 89-3276 Office 89-HD-01
McAlpin Home
1205 Cocoanut Avenue 99-4156 Private Residence Bungalow 99-HD-11
Anna Cosden Berry House 1325 Cocoanut Avenue 01-4322
1526 Cross Street 85-2842 Private Residence Mediterranean 01-HD-04
1910 Datura Street 93-3742 Revival

Private Residence 85-HD-01

Private Residence Mediterranean 93-HD-18
Revival

Updated as of July 2009

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
Ordinance Number
Westmore Tenant House Mediterranean
Morrison House 1913 Datura Street 95-3890 Private Residence Revival 95-HD-03
Sprague House
Kash House 115 Edmondson Avenue 94-3775 Private Residence 94-HD-05
Richardson/Atwater House
Bidwell-Wood House 129 Edmondson Avenue 96-3947 Private Residence 96-HD-05
Crocker Church
Granada Fountain/Marker 3838 Flores Avenue 92-3545 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 92-HD-01
J.B. Turner Home
J.E. Battle Home 3850 Flores Avenue 99-4137 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 99-HD-06
S.T. Humber Home 849 Avenue 85-2875 85-HD-02
Sarasota City Garage 881 Florida Avenue 84-2853 Non-Profit MOVED TO 12TH ST. 84-HD-09
Wiley C. and Edith Steakley
House & Garage 1225 Florida Road Church MOVED TO 12TH ST.
Revere Quality House Fortuna
Levinson House Camino Real 94-3779 Object 94-HD-09
Edward H. Knight House Fruitville
86-2973 Office 86-HD-01

1226 Fruitville Road 84-2836 Office 84-HD-11

1365 Fruitville Road 93-3724 Office 93-HD-14

1426 Fruitville Road 87-3148 Commercial 87-HD-09

2035 Fruitville Road 00-4274 Office 00-HD-09

100 Garden Lane 05-4615 Private Residence 05-HD-01

634 Gillespie Avenue 03-4361 Private Residence 02-HD-01

1828 Grove Street 92-3642 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 92-HD-16

Updated as of July 2009

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
Ordinance Number
Ryan/Garner House Mediterranean 92-HD-03
1919 Grove Street 92-3558 Private Residence Revival 95-HD-04
Westmore Tenant House Mediterranean 08-HD-02
Albert and Selma Svenheim 1936 Grove Street 95-3891 Private Residence Revival 93-HD-03
Cottage 92-HD-04
Boroom House 3864 Hawkeye Circle 08-4775 Ancillary Structure Frame Vernacular 98-HD-01

Caven House, The 1682 Hawthorne Street 93-3659 Private Residence Mediterranean
Sallie C. & Carlton Teate, Jr. Street 92-3569 Private Residence Revival
House 1701 Hawthorne
Francis Teate House Mediterranean
Revival
Hugh K. Browning Home
1736 Hawthorne Street 98-4045 Private Residence Mission
James/Ada Baker Winter Home
1750 Hawthorne Street 92-3630 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 92-HD-12
J.W. Harvey Sr. House
2088 Hawthorne Street 86-3005 Office 84-HD-05
Pike House, The
1841 Hibiscus Street 94-3795 Private Residence Mission 94-HD-16
Williams House
1872 Hibiscus Street 92-3628 Private Residence Bungalow 92-HD-15
Robertson House 1896 Hibiscus Street 92-3633 92-HD-11
3406 Higel Street 95-3906 Private Residence Mediterranean 95-HD-11
Hillview Art Colony (1) Revival
See 93-HDD-01 Hillview Art
Colony (2) Private Residence
Knapp House
1624 Hillview Street 93-3669 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 93-HD-09

1656 Hillview Street 93-3681 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 93-HD-08

1656 Hillview Street 93-3681 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 93-HD-08

963 Indian Beach Drive 95-3889 Private Residence Dutch Colonial 95-HD-02

Updated as of July 2009

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
Rigby’s La Plaza Ordinance Number
Historic District (1)
Asa Causey House 1777 Irving Street 92-3587 Private Residence Mission 92-HDD-01
Frances H. & Corrine Walpole
2319 Ixora Avenue 97-3975 Private Residence Bungalow 96-HD-09
Mediterranean Style House
A Medieval Revival Community 3529 Jacinto Court 93-3750 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 93-HD-20
Bldg.
Nash Residence 507 S Jackson Drive 97-4014 Private Residence 97-HD-01
Katie Hale House
513 Kumquat Court 95-3888 Non-Profit Offices 95-HD-05
Southwick / Harmon House
Bachelor Brewer Model Home 1920 Laurel Street 90-3448 Private Residence 90-HD-07
Richardson House
1927 Laurel Street 95-3904 Private Residence 95-HD-09
Cornish Apartments 1830 Lincoln Drive 00-4226 00-HD-02
Cornish Apartments 1903 Lincoln Drive 89-3355 Private Residence Mediterranean 89-HD-11
1631 Loma Linda Street 96-3946 Private Residence Revival 96-HD-04
Cummer Tenant House
Mediterranean
Hines House Revival
American National Bank Building
S.H. Kress Building Private Residence Bungalow

1641 Loma Linda Street 92-3632 Private Residence Prairie 92-HD-13

1647 Loma Linda Street 92-3632 Private Residence Prairie 92-HD-13

1658 Loma Linda Street 95-3892 Private Residence Bungalow 95-HD-07

1858 Magnolia Street 95-3893 Private Residence Bungalow 95-HD-06

1330 Main Street 98-4092 Condominiums 98-HD-05

1440 Main Street 99-4111 Commercial 99-HD-01

Updated as of July 2009

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
Ordinance Number
Worth's Block/aka Gator Club
Crisp Building 1490 Main Street 98-4050 Commercial 97-HD-02
Lyle House
Stuckey House 1970 Main Street 99-4150 Commercial 99-HD-09
Col. Fredrick & Jessie Byerly
House 2027 McClellan Parkway 93-3744 Private Residence Mission 93-HD-17
Craig Residence
Dunnebacke House 2170 McClellan Parkway 92-3594 Private Residence Mission 92-HD-09
Lemont House
Belvedere Bungalow 344 Monroe Drive 99-4170 Private Residence 99-HD-13
Lynn L. & Mildred G. Silvertooth
Marable Home 175 Morningside Drive 00-4267 Private Residence 00-HD-07
Spanish Oaks Apartments
Jerome K. Martin House 1630 Morrill Street 96-3945 Private Residence 96-HD-03
Ella Dula Westermann Tenant
House 1944 Morrill Street 05-4549 Private Residence 04-HD-02
Dr. Walter C. Kennedy Home
Lynn A. Curtiss House 1608 Oak Street 84-2787 Office 84-HD-03

1616 Oak Street 98-4056 Private Residence 98-HD-02

1630 Oak Street 89-3368 Private Residence 89-HD-14

1637 Oak Street 86-2997 Multiple Family 86-HD-02

1675 Oak Street 98-4091 Private Residence 98-HD-04

1716 Oak Street 94-3825 Private Residence 94-HD-12

1876 Oak Street 90-3391 Private Residence 90-HD-03

1911 Oak Street 99-4122 Private Residence 99-HD-02

Updated as of July 2009

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
Ordinance Number
J Walton Taylor Family Home
Grace & Effie Bills Home 542 Ohio Place 04-4588 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 04-HD-05
John and Mary Erbs House
Federal Building 642 Ohio Place 08-4785 Private Residence Craftsman Bungalow 08-HD-03
Daisy Williams House
Stephen B. Jennings Home 651 Ohio Place 95-3903 Private Residence 95-HD-08
City Waterworks Building
H.B. Williams House 111 S Orange Avenue 09-4854 Public Use Neoclassical Revival 09-HD-01
Silva Apartments
Frederickson House 741 S Orange Avenue 94-3794 94-HD-15
Boat and Lighthouse
Frederick and Margaret Meyer 751 S Orange Avenue 88-3177 Mediterranean 88-HD-01
House 1015 N Orange Avenue 04-4550 Commercial Revival 04-HD-01
Joseph Humphries 1509 S Orange Avenue 99-4109 98-HD-06
Warner/Guptil Home
Moses L. Tomlinson House 229 S Osprey Avenue 88-3160 87-HD-02
Lily White Laundry
310 S Osprey Avenue 92-3643 Private Residence 92-HD-17

433 N Osprey Avenue 84-2827 Private Residence 84-HD-10

540 S Osprey Avenue 99-4149 Private Residence 99-HD-10

555 S Osprey Avenue 87-3132 Private Residence 87-HD-04

558 S Osprey Avenue 89-3342 Private Residence 89-HD-12

636 S Osprey Avenue 96-3943 Private Residence 96-HD-01

700 S Osprey Avenue 90-3386 90-HD-02

Updated as of July 2009

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
Rigby’s La Plaza Ordinance Number
Historic District (6)
Rigby’s La Plaza 1002 S Osprey Avenue 92-3587 Private Residence Mission 92-HDD-01
Historic District (5)
Rigby’s La Plaza 1012 S Osprey Avenue 92-3587 Private Residence Mission 92-HDD-01
Historic District (4)
Rigby’s La Plaza 1022 S Osprey Avenue 92-3587 Private Residence Mission 92-HDD-01
Historic District (3)
Rigby’s La Plaza 1030 S Osprey Avenue 92-3587 Private Residence Mission 92-HDD-01
Historic District (2)
House/Barker Boathouse 1038 S Osprey Avenue 92-3587 Private Residence Mission 92-HDD-01

Selby Apartments 2429 S Osprey Avenue 92-3593 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 92-HD-08

Elizabeth Perry Residence 535 S Palm Avenue 87-3128 87-HD-10

LD Reagin Residence 624 S Palm Avenue 87-3053 Private Residence 86-HD-04

Frances Carlton Apartments 1213 N Palm Avenue 84-2817 Mixed Use 84-HD-06

Sarasota Women's Club 1221 N Palm Avenue 86-2998 Condominiums 86-HD-03
1241 N Palm Avenue 84-2818 84-HD-07
Edwards Theater Avenue 87-3125 Not for Profit 87-HD-07
61 N Pineapple Theatre Company
T. Redd/A. Wilson House
Opera House
Mazie Luzier Bungalows
908 Pomelo Avenue 94-3776 Private Residence Bungalow 94-HD-06
Mazie Luzier Bungalows
1122 Pomelo Avenue 94-3796 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 94-HDD-01
J. & F. Glennon House /Garage
1130 Pomelo Avenue 94-3796 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 94-HDD-01

2800 N Riverside Drive 99-4171 Private Residence Frame Vernacular 99-HD-14

Updated as of July 2009

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
C. E. Hitchings - Judge Fosler Ordinance Number
Residence 94-HD-17
Nagirroc Corrigan House 2846 S Riverside Drive 94-3826 Frame Vernacular
Franklin Redd House 94-HD-01
463 Sapphire Drive 94-3771 Private Residence Mediterranean
Remsen House/Garage Revival 07-HD-01

McKaig House 823 S School Avenue 07-4722 Private Residence Prairie
Blue Pagoda-Chamber of
Commerce Building 3459 Seagrape Drive 00-4275 Private Residence 00-HD-08
Chidsey Building-City Library
1744 South Drive 94-3791 Private Residence Colonial Revival 94-HD-11
Municipal Auditorium Trail 09-4867 09-HD-03
J.J. and Maude Murphy House 655 N Tamiami Trail 09-4870 Public Use Sarasota School of 09-HD-04
Bay Breeze Motel – Twin Motel Arch.

Van Wezel Estate (1) 701 N Tamiami Public Use Moderne Style
Albert Roehr Estate
801 N Tamiami Trail 90-3458 Public Use 90-HD-09
Casa Del Mar
1522 N Tamiami Trail 06-4665 Private Residence Craftsman Bungalow 06-HD-01
William J. Burns House
Schuler House 1770 N Tamiami Trail 03-4467 Office/ Commercial 03-HD-01
Charles E. Leigh Home
601 Tyler Drive 99-4410 Private Residence 98-HDD-01
847 Virginia Drive 87-3106
Drive 93-3749 Private Residence Mediterranean 87-HD-06
25 S Washington Drive 96-3965 Private Residence Revival 93-HD-19
47 S Washington Drive 94-3828 Private Residence 96-HD-06
76 S Washington Drive 90-3408 Private Residence Mediterranean 94-HD-19
139 S Washington Private Residence Revival 90-HD-04

Mediterranean
Revival

Mediterranean
Revival

Mediterranean
Revival

Updated as of July 2009

City of Sarasota
Locally Historically Designated Properties

[Sorted by Street Name]

Resource Name St # N/S Street Name St/Dr/Av Designation Current Use Arch Style Petition
Umbrella House Ordinance Number
Hall/Gillette House Wood Frame- 08-HD-05
Gillette House 1300 Westway Drive 08-4826 Private Residence Sarasota School of
George Day House Architecture 99-HD-03
92-HD-10
1620 Wewa Drive 99-4123 Private Residence Mission 94-HD-18

1845 Wisteria Street 92-3631 Private Residence Mission
451 Woodland Drive 94-3827
Private Residence Mediterranean
Revival

Updated as of July 2009