ASSESSMENT IN EDUCATION EDUP 3153 ALVYIAN SONIA ANAK JUDO PISMP TESL D JUNE 2021 /2026 T A S K 2
Humanizing Alternative Assessments Promote Holistic Development Among Pupils 1.0 Introduction In the constantly changing field of education, conventional assessment techniques are coming under more and more scrutiny. The need for alternative assessment has become more pressing as educators work to promote authentic learning experiences and holistic development. This is supported by an article by Brown (2022), which highlighted that the use of standardized tests for educational evaluation has led to concerns about the limited scope of assessment and the need for more comprehensive evaluation methods. Alternative assessment departs from the traditional paradigms of standardized testing and is sometimes called authentic or performance-based assessment. It uses a wide range of approaches, such as projects, portfolios, presentations, and performance evaluations, to get a more comprehensive picture of students' knowledge, skills, and capacities. Instead of focusing on rote memory and recall as is typically the case with standard tests, alternative assessments aim to evaluate an applicant's ability to think critically, solve problems, and apply information in real-world situations. In her remark, Dr. T Vanitha, highlights the significance of humanizing assessment by emphasizing the values and attitudes that classroom-based assessment may foster .(News Straits Times, 2023). To do this, teachers use various assessment techniques in Malaysian primary schools. Therefore, this essay will discuss how humanizing alternative assessments which include peer assessment, project-based assessment, performance tasks, and authentic assessment promote holistic development among pupils. 2.0 Peer Assessment Firstly, peer assessment is one of the alternative assessment methods that promotes holistic development among pupils. Pupils who participate in peer assessment gain the ability to give constructive criticism, show empathy for the work of their peers, and cultivate mutual regard for one another through the evaluation process (Cornell University, 2023). Peer assessment is consistent with the notion of fostering positive attitudes since it will also
encourage cooperation and a sense of mutual regard for each other during the process of evaluation. For example, in the Malaysian primary school context, pupils may give feedback to their peers for a presentation on national celebrations by giving constructive criticism, pointing out areas where their peers' work excels and where it could be improved, and making suggestions for improvement during peer evaluation exercises while being guided by the teacher or certain criteria. This method not only fosters a supportive learning atmosphere where pupils may benefit from each other's viewpoints and ideas but also helps pupils build critical thinking abilities (Sathasivam, 2021). Peer assessment helps to develop pupils holistically since they will be able to develop their analytical skills, decision-making abilities, and intellectual growth by assessing the work of their classmates. Hence, one alternate assessment strategy that encourages students' holistic development is peer assessment. 3.0 Project-Based Assessment Next, humanizing alternative assessment which is the project-based assessment can also promote holistic development among pupils. This is because, in addition to evaluating students' academic abilities, project-based assessment helps primary school pupils develop virtues like creativity, critical thinking, and teamwork. Project-based assessment is one of the methods where good virtues and attitudes can be instilled easily since it requires the pupils to work with each other, communicate, and respect each other ideas in carrying out the project specifications. This is supported by Chakraborty, (2023) who highlights that project-based assessment frequently requires collaboration, which fosters social skills and cooperative education. Pupils are to improve their social development and get ready for future collaborative work contexts by working together, communicating clearly, and interacting with one another. Furthermore, project-based assessment mirrors real-world challenges, which give learning significance and relevance. Because of its authenticity, project-based assessment encourages pupils to participate in practical situations that improve their critical thinking, creativity, and problem-solving skills (Sindakis, 2023). In the Malaysian primary school context, project-based assessment can be carried out by making a history project that combines
research, writing, and presentation skills to explore a prominent Malaysian historical event or figure. Thus, project-based assessment can promote holistic development among pupils. 4.0 Performance Tasks Not only that, performance tasks are one of the alternative assessments that can be humanized to encourage holistic development among pupils. Performance task comes in a variety of forms, and they vary from role-plays, public speaking, drama, or storytelling. These kinds of performance tasks develop pupils holistically in a way where it allows students to showcase their skills and attitudes, promoting values like confidence and communication. Performance task assessment also demands a comprehensive evaluation from the teachers. This is because performance task assessments take into account a variety of performance factors, such as a pupils' social, emotional, cognitive, and physical growth. Teachers can better understand several facets of their pupils’ development and success by conducting holistic evaluations, which promotes a well-rounded educational experience (McTighe, 2018). For instance, in the Malaysian context, these primary school pupils could perform a skit about a story of their liking and be evaluated based on a proper criterion by the teacher which may include virtues like confidence in delivery, teamwork, and so on. Besides, performance task assessments frequently incorporate reflection and self-evaluation, giving pupils the tools they need to plan goals, measure their development, and participate in active learning. Pupils will benefit from this type of alternative assessment in terms of developing their metacognitive abilities, self-directed learning, and ongoing progress (Chakraborty, 2023). Therefore, humanizing performance task assessment can encourage holistic development among primary school pupils in Malaysia. 5.0 Authentic Assessment Lastly, to promote holistic development among pupils, humanizing alternative assessments such as authentic assessment can also be implemented. Authentic assessment inculcates real-world issues, situations, or circumstances. Its main objective is to assess
students' ability to apply what they have learned in the classroom to real-world scenarios outside of the classroom (Campbell, 2023). Authentic assessment can promote holistic development among pupils because it encourages the development of interpersonal skills, high-order thinking skills as well as observational skills. Based on an article by the University of Florida (2023), highlights that alternative assessment can encourage the development of interpersonal skills since by engaging in real-world tasks, students can enhance their communication skills which is crucial for holistic development. Moreover, authentic assessment instills high-order thinking skills as it requires pupils to use critical thinking, problem-solving, and effective communication techniques in completing tasks. In the Malaysian primary schools context, authentic assessment can be carried out by asking students to create a project showcasing a solution to a local community issue, assessing their research, problem-solving, and presentation skills. Henceforth, authentic assessment is one of the alternative assessment methods that can be humanized to nurture holistic development in pupils. 6.0 Conclusion In a nutshell, to promote students' holistic development, a variety of alternative assessment techniques are used in Malaysian primary schools, including performance tasks, project-based assessment, peer evaluation, and authentic assessment. Alternative assessment diverges from traditional norms, employing varied techniques like projects, portfolios, and presentations to assess students' critical thinking and problem-solving abilities, rather than mere memorization Peer assessment strengthens analytical and decision-making abilities by fostering mutual respect and constructive criticism among peers. Project-based learning fosters innovation, critical thinking, and collaboration while simulating real-world problems and honing transferable skills. While authentic assessment activities demand the application of classroom knowledge to real-world circumstances, they also enhance interpersonal and higher-order thinking skills. Performance tasks, such as role-plays and storytelling, help pupils become more confident and proficient communicators. All things
considered, by addressing various facets of pupils' learning and development, humanizing alternative evaluations promote holistic development.
References Brown, G. (2022). The past, present and future of educational assessment: A transdisciplinary perspective. Frontiers in Education, 7. https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2022.1060633 Campbell, A. (2023, June 13). What is authentic assessment? Bringing authentic assessment to life. Turnitin. https://www.turnitin.com/blog/what-is-authentic-assessment-bringingauthentic-assessment-to-life Chakraborty, M. (2023). Assessment in Education: Embracing holistic development beyond traditional grading. learnenglish. https://www.learningenglisheasy.com/post/assessment-in-education-and-holisticdevelopment Cornell University. (2023). Peer assessment. Center for Teaching Innovation. https://teaching.cornell.edu/teaching-resources/assessment-evaluation/peerassessment McTighe, J. (2018). How will we evaluate student performance on tasks? (Part 6). Medium. https://blog.performancetask.com/how-will-we-evaluate-student-performance-ontasks-part-6-946c82deee02 News Straits Times. (2023, September 7). Honing teachers' skills for classroom-based assessment. NST Online. https://www.nst.com.my/news/nation/2023/09/952435/honing-teachers-skillsclassroom-based-assessment Sathasivam, R. (2021). Teachers’ implementation of peer assessment strategies in Malaysian science classrooms. www.academia.edu. https://www.academia.edu/62903944/Teachers_Implementation_of_Peer_Assessme nt_Strategies_in_Malaysian_Science_Classrooms?uc-sb-sw=15441670
Sindakis, S., PhD. (2023). Holistic assessment: unleashing student potential - Academia World News. Academia World News. https://academiaworldnews.com/holisticassessment-unleashing-student-potential/ University of Florida. (2023). Building Authentic Assessments. Center for Instructional Technology and Training. https://citt.ufl.edu/resources/assessing-studentlearning/building-authentic-assessments/
Graphic Organizer’s References Ecole Globale. (2024, February 27). What are Traditional and Alternative Assessments? https://www.ecoleglobale.com/blog/traditional-assessment-vs-alternativeassessment/ University of Washington Tacoma. (2020). Authentic Assessment Digital Learning. https://www.tacoma.uw.edu/digital-learning/authentic-assessment Huck, J. (2019). Differences and similarities between authentic and standardized testing. prezi.com. https://prezi.com/p/1e1jklecjijv/differences-and-similarities-betweenauthentic-and-standardized-testing/ Lustgarten, B. (2022). Impact of traditional versus alternative assessment on student achievement. ScholarWorks@BGSU. https://scholarworks.bgsu.edu/honorsprojects/682/ National Council of State Supervisors for Languages. (2020). LF: 6.5 Performance vs Traditional Assessment. NCSSFL. https://ncssfl.org/lfmodules/module6-5/