MP Lalkametoo_Flat

/$/.$ 0(722


-HVWHÐP\ 2ĆFMDOQ\P '\VWU\EXWRUHP RU\JLQDOQ\FK ODOHN 0HWRR

















































::: /$/.$0(722 3/




:LHU]ELFND D _ 5DGRP 7HO _ H PDLO KHOOR#ODONDPHWRR SO

/DOND 0HWRR WR VNOHS LQWHUQHWRZ\ Z NWµU\P ]QDMG]LHV] ÐSLÃFH ODONL ] XV]NDPL L SLÇNQH
R]GRE\ GR G]LHFLÇF\FK SRNRLNµZ 3R]QDM QDV]H QLHWX]LQNRZH SURGXNW\ L RGZLHGÕ QDV
QD ZZZ ODONDPHWRR SO

-HVWHÐP\ 2ĆFMDOQ\P '\VWU\EXWRUHP RU\JLQDOQ\FK ODOHN 0HWRR



35202&-$




.2$/$ &0 3/86 /$/.$ = 86=.$0, : %,$É(- 68.,(1&(


3URPRF\MQ\ SDNLHW /DOND NRDOD FP ] LPLHQLHP SOXV QDV] EHVWVHOOHU ODOND ] XV]NDPL Z ELDÊHM

VXNLHQFH ] LPLHQLHP

1D ODONDFK ] LPLHQLHP QD ×\F]HQLH XPLHV]F]DP\ GRZROQ\ QDSLV : W\P FHOX Z RNLHQNX QDOH×\ ZSLVDÅ LPLÇ RUD]
Z\EUDÅ NRORU F]FLRQNL L LQIRUPDFMÇ QD MDNLHM ODOFH NWµUH LPLÇ PDP\ XPLHÐFLÅ 1S .RDOD =RVLD 8V]DWND 0DU\VLD
&]DV RF]HNLZDQLD QD ODONÇ ] LPLHQLHP WR RN GQL URERF]H ]DPµZLHÌ Z\V\ÊDP\ MX× QD GUXJL G]LHÌ

/DOHF]NL ĆUP\ 0HWRR VÃ RU\JLQDOQH L SRVLDGDMÃ V\PERO &( FR R]QDF]D ×H SURGXNW MHVW ]JRGQ\ ] SRGVWDZRZ\PL
Z\PDJDQLDPL ]GURZLD EH]SLHF]HÌVWZD L ÐURGRZLVND \PDJDQLDPL ]GURZLD EH]SLHF]HÌVWZD L ÐURGRZLVND
Z

3/1






























::: /$/.$0(722 3/




8OLFD :LHU]ELFND D _ 5DGRP :RMHZµG]WZR PD]RZLHFNLH 7HOHIRQ _ H PDLO KHOOR#ODONDPHWRR SO

/DOND 0HWRR WR VNOHS LQWHUQHWRZ\ Z NWµU\P ]QDMG]LHV] ÐSLÃFH ODONL ] XV]NDPL L SLÇNQH
R]GRE\ GR G]LHFLÇF\FK SRNRLNµZ 3R]QDM QDV]H QLHWX]LQNRZH SURGXNW\ L RGZLHGÕ QDV
QD ZZZ ODONDPHWRR SO

-HVWHÐP\ 2ĆFMDOQ\P '\VWU\EXWRUHP RU\JLQDOQ\FK ODOHN 0HWRR



35202&-$




.2$/$ &0 3/86 /$/.$ = 86=.$0, : %,$É(- 68.,(1&(


3URPRF\MQ\ SDNLHW /DOND NRDOD FP ] LPLHQLHP SOXV QDV] EHVWVHOOHU ODOND ] XV]NDPL Z ELDÊHM

VXNLHQFH ] LPLHQLHP

1D ODONDFK ] LPLHQLHP QD ×\F]HQLH XPLHV]F]DP\ GRZROQ\ QDSLV : W\P FHOX Z RNLHQNX QDOH×\ ZSLVDÅ LPLÇ RUD]
Z\EUDÅ NRORU F]FLRQNL L LQIRUPDFMÇ QD MDNLHM ODOFH NWµUH LPLÇ PDP\ XPLHÐFLÅ 1S .RDOD =RVLD 8V]DWND 0DU\VLD
&]DV RF]HNLZDQLD QD ODONÇ ] LPLHQLHP WR RN GQL URERF]H ]DPµZLHÌ Z\V\ÊDP\ MX× QD GUXJL G]LHÌ

/DOHF]NL ĆUP\ 0HWRR VÃ RU\JLQDOQH L SRVLDGDMÃ V\PERO &( FR R]QDF]D ×H SURGXNW MHVW ]JRGQ\ ] SRGVWDZRZ\PL
Z\PDJDQLDPL ]GURZLD EH]SLHF]HÌVWZD L ÐURGRZLVND \PDJDQLDPL ]GURZLD EH]SLHF]HÌVWZD L ÐURGRZLVND
Z

3/1






























::: /$/.$0(722 3/




8OLFD :LHU]ELFND D _ 5DGRP :RMHZµG]WZR PD]RZLHFNLH 7HOHIRQ _ H PDLO KHOOR#ODONDPHWRR SO

‘ œ & M v , , ƽ‰ , & ® , .¼
.VLÃ×NL NWµUH RIHUXMHP\ WR SURGXNW\ QDMZ\×V]HM MDNRÐFL SU]HSLÇNQLH
Z\GDQH ] FXGRZQ\PL LOXVWUDFMDPL L ]GMÇFLDPL 3U]HGH ZV]\VWNLP VÃ
GRVWRVRZDQH GR SR]LRPX UR]ZRMX G]LHFND D WUHÐFL Z QLFK ]DZDUWH
RSUDFRZDQH Và SU]\ SRPRF\ VSHFMDOLVWµZ L Z RSDUFLX R V]F]HJµÊRZÃ
ZLHG]Ç WHPDW\F]QÃ $VRUW\PHQW ]QDMGXMÃF\ VLÇ Z VNOHSLH ]RVWDÊ
GREUDQ\ SRG NÃWHP DGHNZDWQRÐFL GR ZLHNX L ]DLQWHUHVRZDÌ G]LHFL
:\EµU NVLÃ×NL QD SRGVWDZLH ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLD G]LHFND XÊDWZL
ZSURZDG]HQLHSURZDG]HQLH Z ÐZLDW MÇ]\ND DQJLHOVNLHJR SRGQRV]ÃF MHGQRF]HÐQLH
Z
ZLHG]Ç G]LHFL ] LFK XOXELRQHM WHPDW\NL
']LÇNL RIHURZDQ\P SU]H] QDV NVLÃ×NRP ]DSHZQLV] VZRMHPX G]LHFNX Z
VSRVµE VSRQWDQLF]Q\ L QLH]Z\NOH VNXWHF]Q\ IDQWDVW\F]QÃ SU]\JRGÇ
] MÇ]\NLHP DQJLHOVNLP UR]ZLMDMÃF Z QLP OXE ZUÇF] Z]EXG]DMÃF ZLHOH
QRZ\FK ]DLQWHUHVRZDÌ

1DV]H G]LHFL SRNRFKDÊ\ MX× PDJLF]Q\
ÐZLDW RSRZLHÐFL ]DEDZ\ L QDXNL ]
NVLÃ×NDPL Z\GDZQLFWZ 8VERUQH
3XEOLVKLQJ 1RV\ &URZ 6FKRODVWLF L
%ORRPVEXU\ WHUD] FKFHP\ ]DSURVLÅ GR
QLH]Z\NÊHM SU]\JRG\ NROHMQH ']LHFL L
LFK 5RG]LFµZ å ]QDMGÕFLH Z :DV]\P
Ð
ÐZLHFLH PLHMVFH GOD QDV]ZLHFLH PLHMVFH GOD QDV]\FK NVLÃ×HN
6HUGHF]QLH ]DSUDV]DP\ MHVWHÐP\ GR
3DÌVWZD G\VSR]\FML 'R ND×GHJR
.OLHQWD SRGFKRG]LP\ LQG\ZLGXDOQLH
]DSHZQLDMÃF SRPRF Z GRERU]H
ZÊDÐFLZHM NVLÃ×NL *RUÃFR ]DFKÇFDP\
GR ]DNXSµZ Z %RRNLGV












:VSµÊSUDFXMHP\ ] SODFµZNDPL HGXNDF\MQ\PL GOD NWµU\FK PDP\ SU]\JRWRZDQà VSHFMDOQà RIHUWÇ FHQRZÃ






ZZZ ERRNLGV SO %RRNLGV 7HO WHO

ELXUR#ERRNLGV SO XO =ZROHÌVND & ORN :DUV]DZD

’ $  
.RORURZD NVLÃ×ND SHÊQD REUD]NµZ GR SRPDORZDQLD SU]\ X×\FLX
RGFLVNµZ SDOXV]NµZ ZUD] ] GRÊÃF]RQ\P SDQHOHP ] NRORURZ\PL
WXV]DPL 3HÊQD ]DEDZQ\FK PRW\ZµZ GR Z\SHÊQLHQLD RGFLVNDPL WM
ZLHZLµUNL MH× SWDNL SLMÃFH ZRGÇ ] IRQWDQQ\ L ZLHOH LQQ\FK 3DQHO
WXV]HP SR]ZDOD G]LHFLRP V]\ENR L ÊDWZR WZRU]\Å REUD]\ SU]\
X×\FLX RGFLVNµZ SDOFµZ JG]LHNROZLHN VÃ EH] SRWU]HE\ X×\ZDQLD
SÇG]OL L SRMHPQLNµZ ] IDUEDPL


&HQD ]Ê







¸ $& $ 
8URF]D NVLÃ×HF]ND ] HOHPHQWDPL ' SU]HGVWDZLDMÃFD VFHQ\ ]H
VÊRQHF]QHJR RJURGX SHÊQHJR URÐOLQ L ]ZLHU]ÃW ']LHFL SRNRFKDMÃ
RGNU\ZDQLH NROHMQ\FK VWURQ ] UXFKRP\PL L WUµMZ\PLDURZ\PL
HOHPHQWDPL WM SV]F]RÊ\ EU]ÇF]ÃFH ZRNµÊ NZLHWQLND SHÊQHJR
NRORURZ\FK NZLDWµZ NUµOLND XNU\ZDMÃFHJR VLÇ Z JU]ÃGNDFK
ZDU]\ZQ\FK F]\ ]ÊRWÃ U\ENÇ Z RF]NX ZRGQ\P

&HQD ]Ê










— ·
0DOXWND NVLÃ×HF]ND GOD QDMPÊRGV]\FK G]LHFL
SU]HGVWDZLDMÃFD LFK XOXELRQH ]ZLHU]ÇWD L RWDF]DMÃFÃ SU]\URGÇ
3U]\ ND×G\P ] QLFK ]QDMGXMH VLÇ SU]\FLVN XUXFKDPLDMÃF\
RGJÊRV\ Z\GDMÃFH SU]H] GDQH ]ZLHU]ÃWNR OXE GÕZLÇNL QDWXU\


&HQD ]Ê











® ( 
,QWHUDNW\ZQD NVLÃ×HF]ND ]DSURMHNWRZDQD VSHFMDOQLH GOD
QDMPÊRGV]\FK SHÊQD ×\Z\FK NRORUµZ SU]HVXZDQ\FK
F]ÇÐFL L SU]\MD]Q\FK ]ZLHU]ÃWHN Z ]RR ']LHFL XZLHOELDMÃ
SU]HVXZDÅ F]ÇÐFL L WZRU]\Å QRZH VFHQ\ L REUD]NL ÏZLHWQD GOD
UR]ZRMX ]GROQRÐFL PRWRU\F]Q\FK L NRRUG\QDFML Z]URNX


&HQD ]Ê

— $ 
$NW\ZL]XMÃFD NVLÃ×HF]ND QDNOHMNRZD ZSURZDG]L G]LHFNR Z
ZDNDF\MQ\ QDVWUµM ]DELHUDMÃF MH QD SLDV]F]\VWà SOD×Ç HNVF\WXMÃFHJR
SDUNX F]\ QD EDVHQ .D×G\ REUD] MHVW SHÊHQ U]HF]\ GR Z\NU\FLD L
RSLVDQLD 'RGDWNRZR ]DZLHUD ]DJDGNL JU\ L F]WHU\ VWURQ\ QDNOHMHN
2GSRZLHG]L ]DPLHV]F]RQH Và QD NRÌFX NVLÃ×NL 'RVNRQDÊH ÅZLF]HQLH
NRRUG\QDFML Z]URNRZR UXFKRZHM RUD] VSRVWU]HJDZF]RÐFL X G]LHFND
,GHDOQLH VSUDZG]L VLÇ SRGF]DV ZDNDF\MQ\FK Z\MD]GµZ


&HQD ]Ê







 ˜ ¡  , ‘
1DXND SRSU]H] SUDFÇ WZµUF]à ']LÇNL WHM NVLÃ×HF]FH G]LHFL QDXF]à VLÇ MDN
U\VRZDÅ L WZRU]\Å SLHUZV]H ]ZLHU]ÇWD L ZLHOH LQQ\FK SOXV GHNRURZDÅ
SUDFÇ ZLHORPD QDNOHMNDPL L GRÊÃF]RQ\P GR NVLÃ×HF]NL ćDPDVWUHP
:V]\VWNLH ]HV]\W\ ] P\V]NÃ $UW\ GR ZF]HVQHM QDXNL SRPDJDMÃ UR]ZLMDÅ
NRRUG\QDFMÇ UÇND RNR SRV]HU]DMÃ ZLHG]Ç G]LHFL ] SLHUZV]\FK
NOXF]RZ\FK SRMÇÅ RUD] LFK UR]XPLHQLH SRSU]H] SUDFÇ WZµUF]Ã

&HQD ]Ê









¸ $ 
ï : VÊRQHF]Q\P RJURG]LH MHVW SHÊQR Uµ×Q\FK RGJÊRVµZ VSUµEXM
RGQDOHÕÅ VNÃG SRFKRG]Ã
ï 3LÇNQLH LOXVWURZDQD NVLÃ×HF]ND GOD QDMPÊRGV]\FK ] RWZLHUDQ\PL
RNLHQNDPL L RWZRUDPL GR SRGJOÃGDQLD
ï &]DWXMÃF\ ZVWÇS GR QDXNL R RWDF]DMÃF\P QDV ÐZLHFLH


&HQD ]Ê










—   
&LHNDZ\ LQWHUDNW\ZQ\ VSRVµE QD QDXNÇ SRQDG FRG]LHQQ\FK VʵZ
Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQ\FK Z V]NROH 6ʵZND QDJUDQH SU]H] QDWLYH VSHDNHU D
']LHFNR VSRÐUµG GZXVWURQQ\FK NDUW Z\ELHUD NDUWÇ ]H VÊRZDPL GR VÊXFKDQLD
VÃ SRXNÊDGDQH WHPDW\F]QLH QS OLWHU\ F\IU\ NRORU\ SU]HGPLRW\ Z V]NROH
ÏZLHWQ\ VSRVµE GOD SU]HGV]NRODNµZ QD QDXNÇ MÇ]\ND DQJLHOVNLHJR


&HQD ]Ê

  . ° ‘ ‘
.VLÃ×HF]ND ] VHULL 6LQJ $ORQJ WZDUG\FK WHNWXURZ\FK NVLÃ×HF]HN
] WHNVWDPL QDMSRSXODUQLHMV]\FK SLRVHQHN GOD QDMPÊRGV]\FK ÏZLHWQH
LOXVWUDFMH UXFKRPH HOHPHQW\ :\VWDUF]\ ]HVNDQRZDÅ NRG 45
E\ Z\VÊXFKDÅ ZHUVML LQVWUXPHQWDOQHM OXE SLRVHQNL ] WHNVWHP
ÏZLHWQD GR QDXNL DQJLHOVNLHJR RUD] URG]LQQHJR ÐSLHZDQLD


&HQD ]Ê










® (  
.VLÃ×HF]ND ] WZDUG\PL VWURQDPL GOD QDMPÊRGV]\FK ]DZLHUD
UXFKRPH F]ÇÐFL SRG NWµU\PL NU\MÃ VLÇ LOXVWUDFMHGX×\FK L PDÊ\FK
GLQR]DXUµZ ÏZLHWQD GR UR]ZRMX XPLHMÇWQRÐFL PRWRU\F]Q\FK
L NRRUG\QDFML Z]URNX SHÊQD NRORURZ\FK LOXVWUDFML


&HQD ]Ê










˜   » ¼
=HVWDZ FLX PLÇNNLFK NVLÃ×HF]HN ] ZLHORNURWQLH QDJUDG]DQHM VHULL
8VERUQH )LUVW 5HDGLQJ VWDQRZLÃF\ ]QDNRPLWÃ LQVSLUDFMÇ GR QDXNL
VDPRG]LHOQHJR F]\WDQLD GOD G]LHFL 3LHUZV]H LH NVLÃ×NL ] SDNLHWX
9HU\ )LUVW 5HDGLQJ WR W\WXÊ\ NWµUH SR]ZROÃ G]LHFNX ] SRPRFÃ
GRURVÊHJR SRGMÃÅ SLHUZV]H NURNL Z F]\WDQLX


&HQD ]Ê








— ( 
.D×G\ URG]LF ZLH FR WR DEVROXWQD IDVF\QDFMD G]LHFND EXWDPL ']LHFL XZLHOELDMÃ
]DNÊDGDÅ L ]GHMPRZDÅ EXW\ EDZLÅ VLÇ V]QXURZDGÊDPL U]HSDPL L NODPUDPL
7D NVLÃ×HF]ND WR RGSRZLHGÕ QD PRGOLWZ\ URG]LFµZ NWµU\FK G]LHFL SU]HG Z\MÐFLHP
] GRPX JRG]LQDPL SU]HELHUDMÃ Z RGQDOH]LHQLX WHM ZÊDÐFLZHM SDU\ %XW\ /XOX WR
NVLÃ×ND LGHDOQD GR SRGDQLD G]LHFNX Z GRPX QD VSDFHU]H Z Zµ]NX LWS ]DSHZQL
]DEDZÇ QD GÊXJR GDMÃF PR×OLZRÐÅ PDÊ\P UÃF]NRP RGSLQDÅ U]HS\ UR]ZLÃ]\ZDÅ
V]QXURZDGÊD GRW\NDÅ PLÇFLXWNLFK VWUXNWXU Uµ×QRURGQ\FK SDU EXFLNµZ Z NVLÃ×FH

&HQD ]Ê

[[[ OERKYVOS[S TP

.IHIR ^ RENPITMIN ^ESTEXV^SR]GL WOPIT¶[
^ GLYWXEQM HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM



']LHFL XZLHOELDMĈ E\þ QRV]RQH





'=,(&, 126=21( : &+867$&+
'2 126=(1,$ '=,(&,

ï 0QLHM SáDF]ą PQLHM Z FLąJX GQLD L
PQLHM ZLHF]RUHP
ï 6ą ]GURZV]H V]\EFLHM SU]\ELHUDMą QD ZDG]H
PDMą OHSLHM UR]ZLQLĊWą NRRUG\QDFMĊ PLĊĞQLH
L
L SRF]XFLH UyZQRZDJL SRF]XFLH UyZQRZDJL
ï 3R]QDMą ĞZLDW ] SR]LRPX GRURVáHJR F]áRZLHND
6]\EFLHM VWDMą VLĊ QLH]DOHĪQH Vą SHZQLHMV]H
VLHELH L EDUG]LHM VDPRG]LHOQH

ï ĝSLą OHSLHM ]DV\SLDMą V]\EFLHM L ĞSLą GáXĪHM
ï 8F]ą VLĊ ZLĊFHM Vą VSRNRMQLHMV]H L XZDĪQLHM
REVHUZXMą RWDF]DMąF\ ĞZLDW
ï 6ą SR SURVWX V]F]ĊĞOLZV]H
ï









































.DQJXUNRZR SO
)+8 &216758&7 7RPDV] &LFK\
NV 6WDELND
6LHPLDQRZLFH ĝOąVNLH
WHO
H PDLO VNOHS#NDQJXUNRZR SO

'LYWXE XOERE HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM
&EF]PSRME 896/-7, ()0-+,8


'LYWX] HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM &EF]PSRME WÈ XOERI WTPSXIQ
WOSęRS OV^]ĺS[]Q GS ^ETI[RME MHIEPRI TSHXV^]Q][ERMI
H^MIGOE NYĺ SH GL[MPM REVSH^MR 1SĺRE [ RMGL RSWMÊ H^MIGM
[ [MIPY V¶ĺR]GL TS^]GNEGL



402







'LYWXE XOERE HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM
&EF]PSRME +6))2 4)%7

'LYWX] HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM &EF]PSRME WÈ XOERI WTPSXIQ
WOSęRS OV^]ĺS[]Q GS ^ETI[RME MHIEPRI TSHXV^]Q][ERMI
H^MIGOE NYĺ SH GL[MPM REVSH^MR 1SĺRE [ RMGL RSWMÊ H^MIGM
[ [MIPY V¶ĺR]GL TS^]GNEGL


402








'LYWXE XOERE HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM
&EF]PSRME 4692)00%

'LYWX] HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM &EF]PSRME WÈ XOERI WTPSXIQ
WOSęRS OV^]ĺS[]Q GS ^ETI[RME MHIEPRI TSHXV^]Q][ERMI
H^MIGOE NYĺ SH GL[MPM REVSH^MR 1SĺRE [ RMGL RSWMÊ H^MIGM
[ [MIPY V¶ĺR]GL TS^]GNEGL


402







'LYWXE XOERE HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM

&EF]PSRME '966%28 6)(

'LYWX] HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM &EF]PSRME WÈ XOERI WTPSXIQ
WOSęRS OV^]ĺS[]Q GS ^ETI[RME MHIEPRI TSHXV^]Q][ERMI
H^MIGOE NYĺ SH GL[MPM REVSH^MR 1SĺRE [ RMGL RSWMÊ H^MIGM
[ [MIPY V¶ĺR]GL TS^]GNEGL

402

'LYWXE IPEWX]G^RE HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM 2EXM .%>>


'LYWX] IPEWX]G^RI ŶVQ] 2%8- MHIEPRMI WTVE[H^È WMÜ [ TV^]TEHOY
[G^IęRMEO¶[ M RS[SVSHO¶[ 2EHENÈ WMÜ HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM SH
YVSH^IRME HS OK 'LYWX] IPEWX]G^RI HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM 2%8-
WÈ GMIROMI HIPMOEXRI M FEVH^S QMÜGMYXOMI 7È RMI^[]OPI ĂEX[I
HS ^E[MÈ^ERME



402







'LYWXE IPEWX]G^RE HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM
2EXM&EF] *0%1)2'3

'LYWX] IPEWX]G^RI ŶVQ] 2%8- MHIEPRMI WTVE[H^È WMÜ [ TV^]TEHOY
[G^IęRMEO¶[ M RS[SVSHO¶[ 2EHENÈ WMÜ HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM SH
YVSH^IRME HS OK 'LYWX] IPEWX]G^RI HS RSW^IRME H^MIGM 2%8- WÈ
GMIROMI HIPMOEXRI M FEVH^S QMÜGMYXOMI 7È RMI^[]OPI ĂEX[I HS ^E[MÈ^ERME


402








4EXETYQ GLYWXE IPEWX]G^RE HS OK 196%23

LYWXE IPEWX]G^RE 4EXETYQ ;VET ^SWXEĂE ^ETVSNIOXS[ERE EF]
V¶[RSQMIVRMI VS^OĂEHEÊ GMÜĺEV H^MIGOE RE X[SMGL VEQMSREGL
M TPIGEGL .IWX []OSRERE ^ QMÜOOMIN [ĂSWOMIN FE[IĂR] M SJIVYNI
H^MIGOY MHIEPRI [EVYROM ^ETI[RMENÈG QY GMITĂS M QSĺPM[SęÊ
[WĂYGLM[ERME WMI[ FMGMI X[SNIKS WIVGE


402








4EXETYQ GLYWXE IPEWX]G^RE HS OK 1%67%0%

'LYWXE IPEWX]G^RE 4EXETYQ ;VET ^SWXEĂE ^ETVSNIOXS[ERE EF]
V¶[RSQMIVRMI VS^OĂEHEÊ GMÜĺEV H^MIGOE RE X[SMGL VEQMSREGL
M TPIGEGL .IWX []OSRERE ^ QMÜOOMIN [ĂSWOMIN FE[IĂR] M SJIVYNI
H^MIGOY MHIEPRI [EVYROM ^ETI[RMENÈG QY GMITĂS M QSĺPM[SęÊ
[WĂYGLM[ERME WMI[ FMGMI X[SNIKS WIVGE


402

2SWMHăS 7XSVGLIR[MIKI &EF]'EVVMIV +VETLMX


2SWMHĂS 7XSVGLIR[MIKI &EF]'EVVMIV +VETLMX 13()0
;]KSHRI RSWMHĂS QMÜOOMI HS RSW^IRME RMIQS[PÈX M H^MIGM
[]OSRERI ^I WOSęRSOV^]ĺS[IN XOERMR] []TVSHYOS[ERIN HPE
RMIQMIGOMIN QEVOM 7XSVGLIR[MIKIq 1SĺRE [ RMQ OSQJSVXS[S
RSWMÊ H^MIGM HS [EKM SO OK ^EV¶[RS ^ TV^SHY NEO M RE TPIGEGL


402








)QIMFEF] 9RMOEPRI RSWMHIăOS
HPE H^MIGM 8SHHPIV *YPP &EEPM +VE]

(^MÜOM YRMOEPRIQY STEXIRXS[ERIQY W]WXIQS[M VIKYPEGNM TERIPY
RSWMHĂS MHIEPRMI HSTEWYNI WMÜ HS H^MIGOE /¶ĂOE
^EQSGS[ERI RE OSĄGEGL TEW¶[ REVEQMIRR]GL YXV^]QYNÈ
GLYWXÜ [ []FVERIN TS^]GNM


402








)QIMFEF] 9RMOEPRI RSWMHIăOS HPE H^MIGM
8SHHPIV *YPP /SMŶWL

2SWMHĂS )QIM&EF] TV^I^REG^SRI NIWX HPE H^MIGM SH YVSH^IRME
HS OK (^MÜOM YRMOEPRIQY STEXIRXS[ERIQY W]WXIQS[M VIKYPEGNM
TERIPY RSWMHĂS MHIEPRMI HSTEWYNI WMÜ HS H^MIGOE /¶ĂOE ^EQSGS[ERI RE
OSĄGEGL TEW¶[ REVEQMIRR]GL YXV^]QYNÈ GLYWXÜ [ []FVERIN TS^]GNM


402









)QIMFEF] 9RMOEPRI RSWMHIăOS HPE H^MIGM 3PMZI

4MIV[W^I RE V]ROY YRMOEPRI RSWMHĂS VIKYPS[ERI NEO GLYWXE
O¶ĂOS[E .IH]RI RSWMHĂS OX¶VIKS QSĺRE FI^TMIG^RMI
Yĺ][EÊ TV^I^ GEĂ] SOVIW RSW^IRME



402





























1$6=( 35(0,(5<



,JQDÐ .LWHN DUFKLWHNW

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV

3U]H]DEDZQD L QLHSRNRUQD NVLÃ×ND

9Ü«ˆĂ¹« ôØãÊύ«Êô— ¼«ã—؁¹Ê R UHDOL]RZDQLX VZRLFK SDVML ZEUHZ
SU]HFLZQRÐFLRP



« Õ« ¹Ã«— «¼èÜãØÊôÃ— =É




5µ]LD 5HZHOND LQ×\QLHUND

1DV]H Z\GDZQLFWZR VSHFMDOL]XMH VLÇ Z VWDUDQQ\P GRERU]H RIHUW\ L SURSRQXMH $QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV
URG]LFRP L G]LHFLRP Z\VRNLHM MDNRÐFL NVLÃ×NL ]DUµZQR ZDUWRÐFLRZH OLWHUDFNR =DEDZQD L PÃGUD RSRZLHÐÅ R
MDN L SLÇNQLH LOXVWURZDQH 7R ìSLFWXUHERRNVë å NVLÃ×NL Z NWµU\FK WHNVW L REUD] UHDOL]RZDQLX SDVML L QLH]UD×DQLX

ZVSµÊJUDMà ]H VREà WZRU]ÃF XQLNDOQà MDNRÐÅ NWµUHM QLH GDÊRE\ VLÇ RVLÃJQÃÅ EH] VLÇ QLHSRZRG]HQLDPL
KDUPRQLL PLÇG]\ QLPL 6Ã WR SXEOLNDFMH GOD Z\PDJDMÃF\FK å SRXF]DMÃFD
L MHGQRF]HÐQLH HNVF\WXMÃFD OLWHUDWXUD G]LHFLÇFD =É








7HN 1RZRF]HVQ\ MDVNLQLRZLHF

3DWULFN 0F'RQQHOO


=DEDZQ\ VSRVµE PµZLHQLD R ]QDF]HQLX Z\ÊÃF]HQLD
RWDF]DMÃF\FK QDV XU]ÃG]HÌ L FLHV]HQLD VLÇ XURNDPL
SLÇNQHJR ÐZLDWD GRRNRÊD



=É


$GD %DPELQL 1DXNRZF]\QL

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV


=$32:,('Ô





#.LQGHUNXOND




:6=<67.,( .6,ÂÖ., '267Æ31( 1$ ::: .,1'(5.8/.$ 3/

1$6=( 35(0,(5<



,JQDÐ .LWHN DUFKLWHNW

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV

3U]H]DEDZQD L QLHSRNRUQD NVLÃ×ND

9Ü«ˆĂ¹« ôØãÊύ«Êô— ¼«ã—؁¹Ê R UHDOL]RZDQLX VZRLFK SDVML ZEUHZ
SU]HFLZQRÐFLRP



« Õ« ¹Ã«— «¼èÜãØÊôÃ— =É




5µ]LD 5HZHOND LQ×\QLHUND

1DV]H Z\GDZQLFWZR VSHFMDOL]XMH VLÇ Z VWDUDQQ\P GRERU]H RIHUW\ L SURSRQXMH $QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV
URG]LFRP L G]LHFLRP Z\VRNLHM MDNRÐFL NVLÃ×NL ]DUµZQR ZDUWRÐFLRZH OLWHUDFNR =DEDZQD L PÃGUD RSRZLHÐÅ R
MDN L SLÇNQLH LOXVWURZDQH 7R ìSLFWXUHERRNVë å NVLÃ×NL Z NWµU\FK WHNVW L REUD] UHDOL]RZDQLX SDVML L QLH]UD×DQLX

ZVSµÊJUDMà ]H VREà WZRU]ÃF XQLNDOQà MDNRÐÅ NWµUHM QLH GDÊRE\ VLÇ RVLÃJQÃÅ EH] VLÇ QLHSRZRG]HQLDPL
KDUPRQLL PLÇG]\ QLPL 6Ã WR SXEOLNDFMH GOD Z\PDJDMÃF\FK å SRXF]DMÃFD
L MHGQRF]HÐQLH HNVF\WXMÃFD OLWHUDWXUD G]LHFLÇFD =É








7HN 1RZRF]HVQ\ MDVNLQLRZLHF

3DWULFN 0F'RQQHOO


=DEDZQ\ VSRVµE PµZLHQLD R ]QDF]HQLX Z\ÊÃF]HQLD
RWDF]DMÃF\FK QDV XU]ÃG]HÌ L FLHV]HQLD VLÇ XURNDPL
SLÇNQHJR ÐZLDWD GRRNRÊD



=É


$GD %DPELQL 1DXNRZF]\QL

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV


=$32:,('Ô





#.LQGHUNXOND




:6=<67.,( .6,ÂÖ., '267Æ31( 1$ ::: .,1'(5.8/.$ 3/







=GURZH VWRS\ 'R SURGXNFML REXZLD 0HPR VWRVR

ZDQH VĈ QDMZ\İV]HM MDNRĤFL PDWHULDã\ :LHU
G]LHFND ]FKQLD L ZHZQčWU]QD F]čĤþ EXWD Z\NRQDQD
MHVW ] QDWXUDOQ\FK PLčNNLFK VNyU NR]LFK
LGHDOQ\FK GOD VWRS\ G]LHFND 6NyU\ WH Z
VSRVyE QDWXUDOQ\ GRVWRVRZXMĈ VLč GR
0HPR WR QDMZ\İV]HM MDNRĤFL REXZLH GOD
G]LHFL Z\NRQDQH Z NODV\F]Q\P VW\OX ] VWRS\ W\P VDP\P ]ZLčNV]DMĈ NRPIRUW Xİ\W
QDWXUDOQ\FK PDWHULDãyZ SU]\MD]Q\FK VWRSLH NRZDQLD 1LHNWyUH PRGHOH Z\SRVDİRQH
G]LHFND 8QLNDWRZĈ IXQNFMč GLDJQRVW\F]QĈ ]RVWDã\ Z VSHFMDOLVW\F]QĈ SRGV]HZNč
]DSHZQLD V\VWHP PRQLWRULQJX Z SRGHV]ZLH EH]FKURPRZĈ 1DWXUDOQH PDWHULDã\ R
0HPR :\SUDFRZDQD SU]H] ODWD NRQVWUXN ZãDĤFLZRĤFLDFK KLJURVNRSLMQ\FK VSUDZLDMĈ
FMD L WHFKQRORJLD PRQWDİX EXWyZ 0HPR İH EXW RGG\FKD D VWRSD QLH XOHJD
] ]DSRFHQLX
]\VNDãD\VNDãD X]QDQLH VSHFMDOLVWyZ MDNR
VNXWHF]QD PHWRGD SURILODNW\NL L OHF]HQLD
QDMF]čVWV]\FK ZDG SRVWDZ\









8QLNDWRZ\ V\VWHP G\QDPLF]QHM NRQWUROL
VWyS G]LHFND GDMĈF\ PRİOLZRĤþ ELHİĈFHJR
PRQLWRURZDQLD VWDQX VWyS RUD] QDW\FKPLD
VWRZHM UHDNFML 6SHFMDOQ\ RGVWDZLRQ\ NV]
WDãW SRGHV]Z\ GRGDWNRZR VWDELOL]XMH VWRSč
L ]DSHZQLD SUDZLGãRZH MHM XãRİHQLH SRG 6SHFMDOQD WHFKQRORJLD PRQWDİX
F]DV FKRGX 'LDJQRVW\F]QD SRGHV]ZD 9 WHFK SROHJDMĈFD QD SUDZLGãRZ\P XVW
0HPR 2EV]DUHP GLDJQRVW\F]Q\P REXZLD DZLHQLX FKROHZNL SRGF]DV SURFHVX PRQ
0HPR MHVW MHJR SRGHV]ZD 1D MHM SRZLHU WRZDQLD EXWD 7HFKQRORJLD WD JZDUDQWXMH
]FKQL RUD] QD REFDVLH ]RVWDãR Z\RGUčEQL ]DFKRZDQLH RVL V\PHWULL Z Z\SURGXNRZ
RQ\FK V]HĤþ SRQXPHURZDQ\FK VWUHI ] Z\ DQ\P EXFLH D W\P VDP\P ZUD] ] FKDUDNW
SXNã\PL SDVNDPL ELHİQLND VWUHID QRUP\ HU\VW\F]Q\P V]W\ZQ\P ]DSLčWNLHP L Z\VRNĈ
VWUHID U\]\ND RUD] F]WHU\ VWUHI\ GXİHM G\V FKROHZNĈ ZVSRPDJD SUDZLGãRZ\ UR]ZyM
IXQNFML 3RGF]DV Xİ\WNRZDQLD SDVNL XOHJDMĈ VWyS 2EXZLH 0HPR SR]EDZLRQH MHVW FHFK
ĤFLHUDQLX G]LčNL F]HPX VWDUWH IUDJPHQW\ NRQVWUXNF\MQ\FK PRJĈF\FK ]DNãyFLþ
XPRİOLZLDMĈ V]\ENĈ L SUHF\]\MQĈ GLDJQR]č REUD] U]HF]\ZLVWHM IL]MRORJLL L SRWU]HE VWyS Z
ZDG VWyS RUD] HZHQWXDOQH GREUDQLH RNUHVLH Z]UDVWDQLD ']LčNL WHPX REXZLH
ZNãDGHN : SU]\SDGNX EUDNX NRQLHF]QRĤFL 0HPR XMDZQLD LFK SUDZLGãRZRĤþ PRUIR
VWRVRZDQLD ZNãDGHN NRU\JXMĈF\FK EXW\ ORJLF]QRF]\QQRĤFLRZĈ OXE LVWQLHMĈFH
0HPR VSHãQLDMĈ IXQNFMč SURILODNW\F]QĈ ZDG\ EĈGĮ LFK V\PSWRP\
=HVWDZ ZNãDGHN ZFKRG]ĈF\FK Z VNãDG
V\VWHPX\VWHPX 0HPR ZUD] ] ZEXGRZDQ\P Z
V 3URGXNW X]\VNDã SR]\W\ZQĈ RSLQLč
SRGHV]ZLH REFDVHP 7KRPDV·D QDGDMH Å&HQWUXP =GURZLD ']LHFNDµ
EXWRP 0HPR FKDUDNWHU REXZLD NRUHNF\M
QHJR 2GSRZLHGQLD GOD G]LHFND ZNãDGND
PRİH E\þ GREUDQD EH]SRĤUHGQLR SU]H]
URG]LFD QD SRGVWDZLH ]DãĈF]RQHM LQVWUXNFML
Xİ\WNRZDQLD 6\VWHPX 0HPR OXE ZJ ZVND
]Dę VSHFMDOLVW\




ZZZ ]GURZHEXFLNL SO