MP Alegoria

8ZEBXOJDUXP "MFHPSJB TQ [ P P

VM 6TZOPXTLB MPL 8BST[BXB
XZEBXOJDUXP!XZEBXOJDUXP BMFHPSJB QM
5FMFGPO

'(7(.7<: %=,.




$XWRU $QQD 3DV]NLHZLF]
LOXVWUDFMH $OHNVDQGUD -DPUR×NLHZLF]
IRUPDW [ PP
XXX XZEBXOJDUXP BMFHPSJB QM REMÇWRÐÅ VWURQ\
2SUDZD PLÇNND
,TJŞƁLJ EMB E[JFDJ J N’PE[JFƁZ ,6%1 &(1$ 2.à$'.2:$

: :\GDQLH , :DUV]DZD

1 VCMJLVKFNZ H’ØXOJF LTJnjȈLJ EMB E[JFDJ J N’PE[JFȈZ BMF P EPSPT’ZDI OJF [BQPNJOBNZ /BT[ZN DFMFN KFTU
EPTUBSD[BOJF LTJnjȈFL QJǗLOZDI NnjESZDI OJFCBOBMOZDI ;BMFȈZ OBN BCZ T’VȈZ’Z OJF UZMLP SP[SZXDF BMF
UBLȈF FEVLBDKJ [BSØXOP QPQS[F[ [BXBSUF X OJDI USFǴDJ KBL J LT[UB’U BSUZTUZD[OZ
8TQؒQSBDVKFNZ [ XJFMPNB V[OBOZNJ UXØSDBNJ MFD[ OJF TUSPOJNZ PE EFCJVUBOUØX /JF CPJNZ TJǗ USVEOZDI
XZ[XBǩ T[VLBNZ VUXPSØX LUØSF X OPXZ B XJǗD OJF OVEOZ TQPTØC QSPQBHPXBǎ CǗEnj XBSUPǴDJ
OJFQS[FNJKBKnjDF NJ’PǴǎ EPCSPǎ VD[DJXPǴǎ MPKBMOPǴǎ PEXBHǗ XJFSOPǴǎ T[MBDIFUOPǴǎ
: PDÊHM L EDUG]R PDÊR ]QDQHM ZLRVFH å .XU]DÊNDFK 'ROQ\FK å SR]RUQLH QLH G]LHMH VLÇ QLF
8JFS[ZNZ ȈF D[ZUBOJF KFTU ȇSØE’FN NZǴMFOJB TUZNVMVKF LSFBUZXOPǴǎ J VXBMOJB UXØSD[Z QPUFODKB’
8 QDG]Z\F]DMQHJR :V]\VWNR REUDFD VLÇ ZRNµÊ SHZQHM NXU]HM IHUP\ QDOH×ÃFHM GR WDPWHMV]HJR VRÊW\VD
8JFS[ZNZ ȈF X EPCJF vDZGSZ[BDKJw LTJnjȈLB XDJnjȈ QP[PTUBKF OBKXBȈOJFKT[ZN OPǴOJLJFN LVMUVSZ $ MHGQDN QDZHW WDP ]QDMG]LH VLÇ ]DMÇFLH GOD SU]HGVLÇELRUF]HJR NRJXWD NWµUHPX ]QXG]LÊR VLÇ E\FLH
Z\VWDZRZ\P FKDPSLRQHP å MH×G×HQLH ] Z\VWDZ\ QD Z\VWDZÇ QLH MHVW HNVF\WXMÃF\P ]DMÇFLHP NLHG\ PD
8ZEBXOJDUXP "MFHPSJB TQ [ P P VLÇ XP\VÊ E\VWU\ L XPLHMÇWQRÐFL GHGXNF\MQH :SUDZG]LH %]LNRZL QLH SU]\MG]LH PLHU]\Å VLÇ ] JURÕQ\PL
SU]HVWÇSFDPL DOH QDZHW QLHNRQLHF]QLH NU\PLQDOQD ]DJDGND MHVW ]DJDGNÃ NWµUÃ WU]HED XPLHÅ
VM 6TZOPXTLB MPL 8BST[BXB Z\MDÐQLÅ $ SRZLHG]HQLH ×H NXU\ VÃ JÊXSLH RND×H VLÇ PRFQR NU]\ZG]ÃFH 'OD NXU U]HF] MDVQD
XZEBXOJDUXP!XZEBXOJDUXP BMFHPSJB QM
5FMFGPO E[JB’ TQS[FEBȈZ




-$%É.2 , 0,Æ7$ : 35=('6=.2/8
.6,ÆÖ1,&=.$ '(7(.7<: *•5$

&=$512.6,ÆÖ1,.$ $66$ 7$5$66$ $XWRU .U\VW\QD ÏPLJLHOVND

LOXVWUDFMH (ZHOLQD -DÐODQ .OLVLN

7HNVW L LOXVWUDFMH 7RPDV] 0LQNLHZLF] IRUPDW [ PP
OD\RXW 6WXGLR .DUDQGDV] REMÇWRÐÅ VWURQ
IRUPDW [ PP 2SUDZD WZDUGD
REMÇWRÐÅ VWURQ\ &(1$ 2.à$'.2:$ ,6%1 &(1$ 2.à$'.2:$
: :\GDQLH , :DUV]DZD
: :\GDQLH , :DUV]DZD

2SUDZD WZDUGD

,6%1




%\ÊD VRELH UD] NVLÇ×QLF]ND NWµUD VLÇ QLJG\ QLH QXG]LÊDð &R OXELà G]LHFL" 2F]\ZLÐFLH EDZLÅ VLÇ $ FR MHV]F]H" =DMDGDÅ VPDNRÊ\NL ELHJDÅ VNDNDÅ WDSODÅ
$ GODF]HJR VLÇ QLH QXG]LÊD" %R MDNR ]DÊR×\FLHOND 6WRZDU]\V]HQLD .VLÇ×QLF]HN 'HWHNW\ZµZ VLÇ Z ZRG]LHð 1R GREU]H DOH FR WDN QDSUDZGÇ OXELà QDMEDUG]LHM" 1DMEDUG]LHM OXELà PµZLÅ
]DZV]H E\ÊD EDUG]R ]DMÇWD UR]ZLÃ]\ZDQLHP ]DJDGHN L PUR×ÃF\FK NUHZ Z ×\ÊDFK WDMHPQLF &R" 2SRZLDGDÅ L S\WDÅ 1LH LQDF]HM MHVW ] (Oà -DEÊNR GOD NWµUHM ND×G\ SRZUµW ] SU]HGV]NROD MHVW
1LH ZLHU]\FLH ×H PDOXWND NVLÇ×QLF]ND PR×H E\Å GRVNRQDÊ\P GHWHNW\ZHP QLHXVWUDV]RQ\P RND]Mà GR UR]PRZ\ ] PDPà 'R G]LHOHQLD VLÇ ] QLà VZRLPL ZUD×HQLDPL ] NROHMQHJR GQLD
SRJURPFÃ ZV]HONLHM PDÐFL ]ÊRF]\ÌFµZ ERKDWHUVNÃ REURÌF]\QLÃ VÊDE\FK L SRNU]\ZG]RQ\FK" VSÇG]RQHJR ] UµZLHÐQLNDPL ] SU]HGV]NROQHM JUXS\ $ ZÐUµG QLFK SU\P ZLHG]LH '\]LR 0LÇWD
0R×H EH] QDMPQLHMV]\FK ZÃWSOLZRÐFL QDMZLÇNV]\ SU]\MDFLHO (OL = W\FK SRJDZÇGHN Z\ÊDQLD VLÇ SLÇNQ\ G]LHFLÇF\ ÐZLDW SHÊHQ XÐPLHFKX
DOH WH× UR]WHUHN L S\WDÌ QD NWµUH PÃGUD PDPD ]DZV]H ]QDMG]LH RGSRZLHGÕ

'(7(.7<: %=,.




$XWRU $QQD 3DV]NLHZLF]
LOXVWUDFMH $OHNVDQGUD -DPUR×NLHZLF]
IRUPDW [ PP
XXX XZEBXOJDUXP BMFHPSJB QM REMÇWRÐÅ VWURQ\
2SUDZD PLÇNND
,TJŞƁLJ EMB E[JFDJ J N’PE[JFƁZ ,6%1 &(1$ 2.à$'.2:$

: :\GDQLH , :DUV]DZD

1 VCMJLVKFNZ H’ØXOJF LTJnjȈLJ EMB E[JFDJ J N’PE[JFȈZ BMF P EPSPT’ZDI OJF [BQPNJOBNZ /BT[ZN DFMFN KFTU
EPTUBSD[BOJF LTJnjȈFL QJǗLOZDI NnjESZDI OJFCBOBMOZDI ;BMFȈZ OBN BCZ T’VȈZ’Z OJF UZMLP SP[SZXDF BMF
UBLȈF FEVLBDKJ [BSØXOP QPQS[F[ [BXBSUF X OJDI USFǴDJ KBL J LT[UB’U BSUZTUZD[OZ
8TQؒQSBDVKFNZ [ XJFMPNB V[OBOZNJ UXØSDBNJ MFD[ OJF TUSPOJNZ PE EFCJVUBOUØX /JF CPJNZ TJǗ USVEOZDI
XZ[XBǩ T[VLBNZ VUXPSØX LUØSF X OPXZ B XJǗD OJF OVEOZ TQPTØC QSPQBHPXBǎ CǗEnj XBSUPǴDJ
OJFQS[FNJKBKnjDF NJ’PǴǎ EPCSPǎ VD[DJXPǴǎ MPKBMOPǴǎ PEXBHǗ XJFSOPǴǎ T[MBDIFUOPǴǎ
: PDÊHM L EDUG]R PDÊR ]QDQHM ZLRVFH å .XU]DÊNDFK 'ROQ\FK å SR]RUQLH QLH G]LHMH VLÇ QLF
8JFS[ZNZ ȈF D[ZUBOJF KFTU ȇSØE’FN NZǴMFOJB TUZNVMVKF LSFBUZXOPǴǎ J VXBMOJB UXØSD[Z QPUFODKB’
8 QDG]Z\F]DMQHJR :V]\VWNR REUDFD VLÇ ZRNµÊ SHZQHM NXU]HM IHUP\ QDOH×ÃFHM GR WDPWHMV]HJR VRÊW\VD
8JFS[ZNZ ȈF X EPCJF vDZGSZ[BDKJw LTJnjȈLB XDJnjȈ QP[PTUBKF OBKXBȈOJFKT[ZN OPǴOJLJFN LVMUVSZ $ MHGQDN QDZHW WDP ]QDMG]LH VLÇ ]DMÇFLH GOD SU]HGVLÇELRUF]HJR NRJXWD NWµUHPX ]QXG]LÊR VLÇ E\FLH
Z\VWDZRZ\P FKDPSLRQHP å MH×G×HQLH ] Z\VWDZ\ QD Z\VWDZÇ QLH MHVW HNVF\WXMÃF\P ]DMÇFLHP NLHG\ PD
8ZEBXOJDUXP "MFHPSJB TQ [ P P VLÇ XP\VÊ E\VWU\ L XPLHMÇWQRÐFL GHGXNF\MQH :SUDZG]LH %]LNRZL QLH SU]\MG]LH PLHU]\Å VLÇ ] JURÕQ\PL
SU]HVWÇSFDPL DOH QDZHW QLHNRQLHF]QLH NU\PLQDOQD ]DJDGND MHVW ]DJDGNÃ NWµUÃ WU]HED XPLHÅ
VM 6TZOPXTLB MPL 8BST[BXB Z\MDÐQLÅ $ SRZLHG]HQLH ×H NXU\ VÃ JÊXSLH RND×H VLÇ PRFQR NU]\ZG]ÃFH 'OD NXU U]HF] MDVQD
XZEBXOJDUXP!XZEBXOJDUXP BMFHPSJB QM
5FMFGPO E[JB’ TQS[FEBȈZ




-$%É.2 , 0,Æ7$ : 35=('6=.2/8
.6,ÆÖ1,&=.$ '(7(.7<: *•5$

&=$512.6,ÆÖ1,.$ $66$ 7$5$66$ $XWRU .U\VW\QD ÏPLJLHOVND

LOXVWUDFMH (ZHOLQD -DÐODQ .OLVLN

7HNVW L LOXVWUDFMH 7RPDV] 0LQNLHZLF] IRUPDW [ PP
OD\RXW 6WXGLR .DUDQGDV] REMÇWRÐÅ VWURQ
IRUPDW [ PP 2SUDZD WZDUGD
REMÇWRÐÅ VWURQ\ &(1$ 2.à$'.2:$ ,6%1 &(1$ 2.à$'.2:$
: :\GDQLH , :DUV]DZD
: :\GDQLH , :DUV]DZD

2SUDZD WZDUGD

,6%1




%\ÊD VRELH UD] NVLÇ×QLF]ND NWµUD VLÇ QLJG\ QLH QXG]LÊDð &R OXELà G]LHFL" 2F]\ZLÐFLH EDZLÅ VLÇ $ FR MHV]F]H" =DMDGDÅ VPDNRÊ\NL ELHJDÅ VNDNDÅ WDSODÅ
$ GODF]HJR VLÇ QLH QXG]LÊD" %R MDNR ]DÊR×\FLHOND 6WRZDU]\V]HQLD .VLÇ×QLF]HN 'HWHNW\ZµZ VLÇ Z ZRG]LHð 1R GREU]H DOH FR WDN QDSUDZGÇ OXELà QDMEDUG]LHM" 1DMEDUG]LHM OXELà PµZLÅ
]DZV]H E\ÊD EDUG]R ]DMÇWD UR]ZLÃ]\ZDQLHP ]DJDGHN L PUR×ÃF\FK NUHZ Z ×\ÊDFK WDMHPQLF &R" 2SRZLDGDÅ L S\WDÅ 1LH LQDF]HM MHVW ] (Oà -DEÊNR GOD NWµUHM ND×G\ SRZUµW ] SU]HGV]NROD MHVW
1LH ZLHU]\FLH ×H PDOXWND NVLÇ×QLF]ND PR×H E\Å GRVNRQDÊ\P GHWHNW\ZHP QLHXVWUDV]RQ\P RND]Mà GR UR]PRZ\ ] PDPà 'R G]LHOHQLD VLÇ ] QLà VZRLPL ZUD×HQLDPL ] NROHMQHJR GQLD
SRJURPFÃ ZV]HONLHM PDÐFL ]ÊRF]\ÌFµZ ERKDWHUVNÃ REURÌF]\QLÃ VÊDE\FK L SRNU]\ZG]RQ\FK" VSÇG]RQHJR ] UµZLHÐQLNDPL ] SU]HGV]NROQHM JUXS\ $ ZÐUµG QLFK SU\P ZLHG]LH '\]LR 0LÇWD
0R×H EH] QDMPQLHMV]\FK ZÃWSOLZRÐFL QDMZLÇNV]\ SU]\MDFLHO (OL = W\FK SRJDZÇGHN Z\ÊDQLD VLÇ SLÇNQ\ G]LHFLÇF\ ÐZLDW SHÊHQ XÐPLHFKX
DOH WH× UR]WHUHN L S\WDÌ QD NWµUH PÃGUD PDPD ]DZV]H ]QDMG]LH RGSRZLHGÕ

-HVWHP DEVROZHQWNÃ SROLWRORJLL L VWXGLµZ SRG\SORPRZ\FK QD NLHUXQNX
ì3V\FKRORJLD EL]QHVXë REHFQLH SURZDG]Ç SUDNW\NÇ MDNR .RQVXOWDQWND
GV 6QX ']LHFND FHUW\ĆNRZDQD SU]H] 7KH )DPLO\ 6OHHS ,QVWLWXWH ]
VLHG]LEÃ Z 1RZ\P -RUNX 86$ LQVW\WXFMÇ Z\]QDF]DMÃFÃ VWDQGDUG\ Z
WHM EUDQ×\ QD FDÊ\P ÐZLHFLH :LHOH ODW Z NDULHU]H ]DZRGRZHM
SU]HSUDFRZDÊDP Z G]LDÊDFK SHUVRQDOQ\FK MDNR OLGHU Z REV]DU]H
UHNUXWDFML L WUHQHU ZHZQÇWU]Q\ 3U\ZDWQLH MHVWHP PDPÃ GZXOHWQLFK
EOLÕQLÃW OLÕQLÃW NWµUH QLHZÃWSOLZLH SU]\F]\QLÊ\ VLÇ GR PRMHJR ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLD
E
VLÇ WHPDWHP VQX G]LHFND L RGNU\FLD QRZHM PLVML Z PRLP ×\FLX E\ HGXNRZDÅ L ZVSLHUDÅ URG]LQ\
NWµUH GRÐZLDGF]DMÃ SUREOHPµZ ]H VQHP X VZRLFK G]LHFL
¡¸œ·”¯Ì ˜šž£¡·• ” ¡”¯‘¤ ‘— œš‘¤”·č¡
-DNR .RQVXOWDQWND GV 6QX ']LHFND SURZDG]Ç LQG\ZLGXDOQH NRQVXOWDFMH RUD] ZDUV]WDW\ L
¸œ“™dž·£·° œš¤¡”dž¤DŽ ¸œš®—¯˜ ™Ÿ
Z\NÊDG\ GOD URG]LFµZ Z MÇ]\NX SROVNLP L DQJLHOVNLP :VSµÊSUDFXMÇ UµZQLH× ] IXQGDFMDPL
Ÿ ¡š”·° ‘¤”¯·” ×ÊRENDPL V]NRÊDPL URG]HQLD RUD] ] LQQ\PL RUJDQL]DFMDPL NWµU\FK G]LDÊDQLD QDNLHURZDQH Và QD
]ZLÇNV]DQLH NRPSHWHQFML URG]LFµZ WDN DE\ HIHNW\ZQLH ZVSLHUDOL VZRMH G]LHFNR Z SURFHVLH
=UµEP\ WR FR Z\GDMH VLÇ QLHPR×OLZH QDXF]P\ 7ZRMH G]LHFNR SLÇNQLH VSDÅ UR]ZRMX Z\FKRZDQLD L HGXNDFML :LHU]Ç ×H ND×GH G]LHFNR PR×H SLÇNQLH SU]HV\SLDÅ QRFH FR
'OD URG]LFµZ EOLÕQLÃW VSHFMDOQD RIHUWD Z PRLP GRPX WH× SRGZµMQH V]F]ÇÐFLH SU]HNÊDGD VLÇ QD OHSV]H IXQNFMRQRZDQLH FDÊHM MHJR URG]LQ\ =GURZ\ VHQ WR SRGVWDZD




·¯™™”–
0RQLND +XQWMHQV
3/$1< :63•É35$&< &HUW\ĆNRZDQD .RQVXOWDQWND GV 6QX ']LHFND
&HUWLĆHG &KLOG 6OHHS &RQVXOWDQW

'1,2:< '1,2:<

=É =É




ï $QDOL]D .ZHVWLRQDULXV]D GOD 5RG]LFµZ ï $QDOL]D .ZHVWLRQDULXV]D GOD 5RG]LFµZ
ï PLQXWRZD NRQVXOWDFMD ï PLQXWRZD NRQVXOWDFMD
SU]H]WHOHIRQ 6N\SH =RRP QD SRF]ÃWNX SU]H]WHOHIRQ 6N\SH =RRP QD SRF]ÃWNX
QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\ QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\
ï 2SUDFRZDQH LQG\ZLGXDOQLH QD :DV]H ï 2SUDFRZDQH LQG\ZLGXDOQLH QD :DV]H
SRWU]HE\ ì3ODQX 'REUHJR 6QXë SRWU]HE\ ì3ODQX 'REUHJR 6QXë

ï %LH×ÃFH ZVSDUFLH SU]H] RNUHV GZµFK W\JRGQL %LH×ÃFH ZVSDUFLH SU]H] RNUHV GZµFK W\JRGQL ï %LH×ÃFH ZVSDUFLH SU]H] RNUHV GZµFK W\JRGQL ï %LH×ÃFH ZVSDUFLH SU]H] RNUHV GZµFK W\JRGQL
ï
MHGQD NRQVXOWDFMD WHOHIRQLF]QD G]LHQQLH SU]H] MHGQD NRQVXOWDFMD WHOHIRQLF]QD G]LHQQLH SU]H]
GQL PDNV PLQXW GQL GR Z\NRU]\VWDQLD GQL PDNV PLQXW GQL GR Z\NRU]\VWDQLD
QD NRQVXOWDFMH WHOHIRQLF]QH PRJÃ QDVWÇSRZDÅ QD NRQVXOWDFMH WHOHIRQLF]QH PRJÃ QDVWÇSRZDÅ
MHGHQ SR GUXJLP OXE UR]ÊR]\Å VLÇ GRZROQLH QD MHGHQ SR GUXJLP OXE UR]ÊR]\Å VLÇ GRZROQLH QD
RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\ RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\
ï 1LHOLPLWRZDQH VPV\ ZLDGRPRÐFL WHNVWRZH ï 1LHOLPLWRZDQH VPV\ ZLDGRPRÐFL WHNVWRZH
L
L HPDLOH SU]H] FDÊ\ RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊS HPDLOH SU]H] FDÊ\ RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\
L L HPDLOH SU]H] FDÊ\ RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊS HPDLOH SU]H] FDÊ\ RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\



&HQ\ SR]RVWDMÃ EH] ]PLDQ
Z SU]\SDGNX EOLÕQLÃW L WURMDF]NµZ



XXX GBDFCPPL DPN TQJKNBMVT[LV

-HVWHP DEVROZHQWNÃ SROLWRORJLL L VWXGLµZ SRG\SORPRZ\FK QD NLHUXQNX
ì3V\FKRORJLD EL]QHVXë REHFQLH SURZDG]Ç SUDNW\NÇ MDNR .RQVXOWDQWND
GV 6QX ']LHFND FHUW\ĆNRZDQD SU]H] 7KH )DPLO\ 6OHHS ,QVWLWXWH ]
VLHG]LEÃ Z 1RZ\P -RUNX 86$ LQVW\WXFMÇ Z\]QDF]DMÃFÃ VWDQGDUG\ Z
WHM EUDQ×\ QD FDÊ\P ÐZLHFLH :LHOH ODW Z NDULHU]H ]DZRGRZHM
SU]HSUDFRZDÊDP Z G]LDÊDFK SHUVRQDOQ\FK MDNR OLGHU Z REV]DU]H
UHNUXWDFML L WUHQHU ZHZQÇWU]Q\ 3U\ZDWQLH MHVWHP PDPÃ GZXOHWQLFK
EOLÕQLÃW OLÕQLÃW NWµUH QLHZÃWSOLZLH SU]\F]\QLÊ\ VLÇ GR PRMHJR ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLD
E
VLÇ WHPDWHP VQX G]LHFND L RGNU\FLD QRZHM PLVML Z PRLP ×\FLX E\ HGXNRZDÅ L ZVSLHUDÅ URG]LQ\
NWµUH GRÐZLDGF]DMÃ SUREOHPµZ ]H VQHP X VZRLFK G]LHFL
¡¸œ·”¯Ì ˜šž£¡·• ” ¡”¯‘¤ ‘— œš‘¤”·č¡
-DNR .RQVXOWDQWND GV 6QX ']LHFND SURZDG]Ç LQG\ZLGXDOQH NRQVXOWDFMH RUD] ZDUV]WDW\ L
¸œ“™dž·£·° œš¤¡”dž¤DŽ ¸œš®—¯˜ ™Ÿ
Z\NÊDG\ GOD URG]LFµZ Z MÇ]\NX SROVNLP L DQJLHOVNLP :VSµÊSUDFXMÇ UµZQLH× ] IXQGDFMDPL
Ÿ ¡š”·° ‘¤”¯·” ×ÊRENDPL V]NRÊDPL URG]HQLD RUD] ] LQQ\PL RUJDQL]DFMDPL NWµU\FK G]LDÊDQLD QDNLHURZDQH Và QD
]ZLÇNV]DQLH NRPSHWHQFML URG]LFµZ WDN DE\ HIHNW\ZQLH ZVSLHUDOL VZRMH G]LHFNR Z SURFHVLH
=UµEP\ WR FR Z\GDMH VLÇ QLHPR×OLZH QDXF]P\ 7ZRMH G]LHFNR SLÇNQLH VSDÅ UR]ZRMX Z\FKRZDQLD L HGXNDFML :LHU]Ç ×H ND×GH G]LHFNR PR×H SLÇNQLH SU]HV\SLDÅ QRFH FR
'OD URG]LFµZ EOLÕQLÃW VSHFMDOQD RIHUWD Z PRLP GRPX WH× SRGZµMQH V]F]ÇÐFLH SU]HNÊDGD VLÇ QD OHSV]H IXQNFMRQRZDQLH FDÊHM MHJR URG]LQ\ =GURZ\ VHQ WR SRGVWDZD




·¯™™”–
0RQLND +XQWMHQV
3/$1< :63•É35$&< &HUW\ĆNRZDQD .RQVXOWDQWND GV 6QX ']LHFND
&HUWLĆHG &KLOG 6OHHS &RQVXOWDQW

'1,2:< '1,2:<

=É =É




ï $QDOL]D .ZHVWLRQDULXV]D GOD 5RG]LFµZ ï $QDOL]D .ZHVWLRQDULXV]D GOD 5RG]LFµZ
ï PLQXWRZD NRQVXOWDFMD ï PLQXWRZD NRQVXOWDFMD
SU]H]WHOHIRQ 6N\SH =RRP QD SRF]ÃWNX SU]H]WHOHIRQ 6N\SH =RRP QD SRF]ÃWNX
QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\ QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\
ï 2SUDFRZDQH LQG\ZLGXDOQLH QD :DV]H ï 2SUDFRZDQH LQG\ZLGXDOQLH QD :DV]H
SRWU]HE\ ì3ODQX 'REUHJR 6QXë SRWU]HE\ ì3ODQX 'REUHJR 6QXë

ï %LH×ÃFH ZVSDUFLH SU]H] RNUHV GZµFK W\JRGQL %LH×ÃFH ZVSDUFLH SU]H] RNUHV GZµFK W\JRGQL ï %LH×ÃFH ZVSDUFLH SU]H] RNUHV GZµFK W\JRGQL ï %LH×ÃFH ZVSDUFLH SU]H] RNUHV GZµFK W\JRGQL
ï
MHGQD NRQVXOWDFMD WHOHIRQLF]QD G]LHQQLH SU]H] MHGQD NRQVXOWDFMD WHOHIRQLF]QD G]LHQQLH SU]H]
GQL PDNV PLQXW GQL GR Z\NRU]\VWDQLD GQL PDNV PLQXW GQL GR Z\NRU]\VWDQLD
QD NRQVXOWDFMH WHOHIRQLF]QH PRJÃ QDVWÇSRZDÅ QD NRQVXOWDFMH WHOHIRQLF]QH PRJÃ QDVWÇSRZDÅ
MHGHQ SR GUXJLP OXE UR]ÊR]\Å VLÇ GRZROQLH QD MHGHQ SR GUXJLP OXE UR]ÊR]\Å VLÇ GRZROQLH QD
RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\ RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\
ï 1LHOLPLWRZDQH VPV\ ZLDGRPRÐFL WHNVWRZH ï 1LHOLPLWRZDQH VPV\ ZLDGRPRÐFL WHNVWRZH
L
L HPDLOH SU]H] FDÊ\ RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊS HPDLOH SU]H] FDÊ\ RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\
L L HPDLOH SU]H] FDÊ\ RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊS HPDLOH SU]H] FDÊ\ RNUHV QDV]HM ZVSµÊSUDF\



&HQ\ SR]RVWDMÃ EH] ]PLDQ
Z SU]\SDGNX EOLÕQLÃW L WURMDF]NµZ



XXX GBDFCPPL DPN TQJKNBMVT[LV





-('<1( : 32/6&( 08/7Ζ0('Ζ$/1(


12:2&=(61( =$6.$.8-Æ&(


1$-/(36=< 352'8.7 785<67<&=1<




=$35$6=$0< 2' :725.8 '2 1Ζ('=Ζ(/Ζ 2' '2

ZZZ PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO






&HOHP XWZRU]HQLD 0X]HXP 3ROVNLHM 3LRVHQNL Z 2SROX MHVW SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP
WUZDĄD RFKURQD NXOWXURZHJR G]LHG]LFWZD QDURGRZHJR L ]ZLÛNV]HQLH UROL SROVNLHM &(1< %Ζ/(7•:
SLRVHQNL Z GLDORJX PLÛG]\NXOWXURZ\P QD U]HF] SURPRFML PLDVWD L SRGQLHVLHQLD MHJR
DWUDNF\MQRĝFL WXU\VW\F]QHM 2SROH MDNR ȌVWROLFD SROVNLHM SLRVHQNLȋ ] WUDG\FMDPL SRQDG ȏ QRUPDOQ\ Ȃ ]Ą ȏ XOJRZ\ Ȃ ]Ą ȏ JUXSRZ\ Ȃ ]Ą
F]WHUG]LHVWROHWQLHM KLVWRULL .UDMRZHJR )HVWLZDOX 3ROVNLHM 3LRVHQNL MHVW QDMOHSV]\P ȏ URG]LQQ\ Ȃ ]Ą GRURVĄ\FK G]LHFL
PLHMVFHP GR SRZVWDQLD LQVW\WXFML ]DMPXMÇFHM VLÛ JURPDG]HQLHP NDWDORJRZDQLHP %LOHW\ PRJÇ 3DĆVWZR NXSLÉ
NRQVHUZRZDQLHP GLJLWDOL]RZDQLHP QDXNRZ\P RSUDFRZ\ZDQLHP L XGRVWÛSQLDQLHP
] ȏ Z NDVDFK 1&33 Z $PȴWHDWU]H
]ELRUµZ GRW\F]ÇF\FK SROVNLHM SLRVHQNL 3RWU]HED ]DMÛFLD VLÛ GRURENLHP SROVNLFK ELRUµZ GRW\F]ÇF\FK SROVNLHM SLRVHQNL 3RWU]HED ]DMÛFLD VLÛ GRURENLHP SROVNLFK
SLRVHQHN NWµUH SRVLDGDMÇ RJURPQH QLH GR NRĆFD ]EDGDQH ]DVRE\ ȏQD VWURQLH ZZZ ELOHW\ PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO
MHVW SU]HGVLÛZ]LÛFLHP ZDľQ\P SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP E\ ]DFKRZDÉ WHQ ERJDW\ FHQQ\ %LOHW\ XOJRZH VÇ ZDľQH ZUD] ] GRNXPHQWHP SRWZLHUG]DMÇF\P XSRZDľQLHQLH GR ]QLľNL
L LQWHUHVXMÇF\ PDWHULDĄ GOD SU]\V]Ą\FK SRNROHĆ








































08=(80 32/6.Ζ(- 3Ζ26(1.Ζ

_ ZZZ PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO _ PX]HXP#PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO
XO 3LDVWRZVND $ 2SROH $PȴWHDWU ZHMĝFLH RG XO %DUOLFNLHJR

-('<1( : 32/6&( 08/7Ζ0('Ζ$/1(


12:2&=(61( =$6.$.8-Æ&(


1$-/(36=< 352'8.7 785<67<&=1<




=$35$6=$0< 2' :725.8 '2 1Ζ('=Ζ(/Ζ 2' '2

ZZZ PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO






&HOHP XWZRU]HQLD 0X]HXP 3ROVNLHM 3LRVHQNL Z 2SROX MHVW SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP
WUZDĄD RFKURQD NXOWXURZHJR G]LHG]LFWZD QDURGRZHJR L ]ZLÛNV]HQLH UROL SROVNLHM &(1< %Ζ/(7•:
SLRVHQNL Z GLDORJX PLÛG]\NXOWXURZ\P QD U]HF] SURPRFML PLDVWD L SRGQLHVLHQLD MHJR
DWUDNF\MQRĝFL WXU\VW\F]QHM 2SROH MDNR ȌVWROLFD SROVNLHM SLRVHQNLȋ ] WUDG\FMDPL SRQDG ȏ QRUPDOQ\ Ȃ ]Ą ȏ XOJRZ\ Ȃ ]Ą ȏ JUXSRZ\ Ȃ ]Ą
F]WHUG]LHVWROHWQLHM KLVWRULL .UDMRZHJR )HVWLZDOX 3ROVNLHM 3LRVHQNL MHVW QDMOHSV]\P ȏ URG]LQQ\ Ȃ ]Ą GRURVĄ\FK G]LHFL
PLHMVFHP GR SRZVWDQLD LQVW\WXFML ]DMPXMÇFHM VLÛ JURPDG]HQLHP NDWDORJRZDQLHP %LOHW\ PRJÇ 3DĆVWZR NXSLÉ
NRQVHUZRZDQLHP GLJLWDOL]RZDQLHP QDXNRZ\P RSUDFRZ\ZDQLHP L XGRVWÛSQLDQLHP
] ȏ Z NDVDFK 1&33 Z $PȴWHDWU]H
]ELRUµZ GRW\F]ÇF\FK SROVNLHM SLRVHQNL 3RWU]HED ]DMÛFLD VLÛ GRURENLHP SROVNLFK ELRUµZ GRW\F]ÇF\FK SROVNLHM SLRVHQNL 3RWU]HED ]DMÛFLD VLÛ GRURENLHP SROVNLFK
SLRVHQHN NWµUH SRVLDGDMÇ RJURPQH QLH GR NRĆFD ]EDGDQH ]DVRE\ ȏQD VWURQLH ZZZ ELOHW\ PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO
MHVW SU]HGVLÛZ]LÛFLHP ZDľQ\P SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP E\ ]DFKRZDÉ WHQ ERJDW\ FHQQ\ %LOHW\ XOJRZH VÇ ZDľQH ZUD] ] GRNXPHQWHP SRWZLHUG]DMÇF\P XSRZDľQLHQLH GR ]QLľNL
L LQWHUHVXMÇF\ PDWHULDĄ GOD SU]\V]Ą\FK SRNROHĆ








































08=(80 32/6.Ζ(- 3Ζ26(1.Ζ

_ ZZZ PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO _ PX]HXP#PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO
XO 3LDVWRZVND $ 2SROH $PȴWHDWU ZHMĝFLH RG XO %DUOLFNLHJR

-('<1( : 32/6&( 08/7Ζ0('Ζ$/1(


12:2&=(61( =$6.$.8-Æ&(


1$-/(36=< 352'8.7 785<67<&=1<




=$35$6=$0< 2' :725.8 '2 1Ζ('=Ζ(/Ζ 2' '2

ZZZ PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO






0DULD 6DGRZVND SRSURZDG]LĄD 0DĄÇ $NDGHPLÛ 3LRVHQNL
$QQD :\V]NRQL Z 0DĄHM $NDGHPLL 3LRVHQNL
0DULD 6DGRZVND WR SROVND SLRVHQNDUND Z\NRQXMÇFD PX]\NÛ MD]] SRS IXQN

: SRQLHG]LDĄHN NZLHWQLD JRĝFLHP 0DĄHM $NDGHPLL 3LRVHQNL EÛG]LH $QQD L HOHNWURQLF]QÇ D WDNľH VFHQDU]\VWND L UHľ\VHU ȴOPRZ\ 0D QD NRQFLH G]LHZLÛÉ VRORZ\FK
:\V]NRQL ZRNDOLVWND L NRPSR]\WRUND QLHJG\ĝ ]ZLÇ]DQD ] ]HVSRĄHP Ȍă]\ȋ SĄ\W P LQ 7ULEXWH WR .RPHGD ]ĄRWD SĄ\WD L Z SHĄQL DXWRUVNÇ Ȍ6SLV WUHĝFLȋ -HM HWLXGD

$UW\VWFH EÛG]LH WRZDU]\V]\Ą JRVSRGDU] PX]\F]Q\ ΖJRU 3U]HELQGRZVNL : SURJUDPLH IDEXODUQD SW Ȍ6NU]\GĄDȋ SRND]\ZDQD E\ĄD QD PLÛG]\QDURGRZ\FK IHVWLZDODFK
ȴOPRZ\FK P LQ Z 0RVNZLH 7DMSHM %RORQLL %DUFHORQLH 6WDPEXOH L 3DU\ľX
PX]\F]QH ]DMÛFLD GOD G]LHFL Z ZLHNX SU]HGV]NROQ\P L ZF]HVQRV]NROQ\P D WDNľH
PLQLNRQFHUW GOD QDMPĄRGV]\FK 2SRODQ 0 0DULD 6DGRZVND E\ĄD JRĝFLHP 0DĄHM $NDGHPLL 3LRVHQNL PDUFD $UW\VWND ZUD]
] JRVSRGDU]HP PX]\F]Q\P ΖJRUHP 3U]HELQGRZVNLP ]DSURVLOL G]LHFL QD QLH]Z\NĄH ZDUV]WDW\
PX]\F]QH SRGF]DV NWµU\FK ZVSµOQLH ĝSLHZDOL DOH SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP GREU]H VLÛ EDZLOL










































08=(80 32/6.Ζ(- 3Ζ26(1.Ζ

_ ZZZ PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO _ PX]HXP#PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO
XO 3LDVWRZVND $ 2SROH $PȴWHDWU ZHMĝFLH RG XO %DUOLFNLHJR

-('<1( : 32/6&( 08/7Ζ0('Ζ$/1(


12:2&=(61( =$6.$.8-Æ&(


1$-/(36=< 352'8.7 785<67<&=1<




=$35$6=$0< 2' :725.8 '2 1Ζ('=Ζ(/Ζ 2' '2

ZZZ PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO






0DULD 6DGRZVND SRSURZDG]LĄD 0DĄÇ $NDGHPLÛ 3LRVHQNL
$QQD :\V]NRQL Z 0DĄHM $NDGHPLL 3LRVHQNL
0DULD 6DGRZVND WR SROVND SLRVHQNDUND Z\NRQXMÇFD PX]\NÛ MD]] SRS IXQN

: SRQLHG]LDĄHN NZLHWQLD JRĝFLHP 0DĄHM $NDGHPLL 3LRVHQNL EÛG]LH $QQD L HOHNWURQLF]QÇ D WDNľH VFHQDU]\VWND L UHľ\VHU ȴOPRZ\ 0D QD NRQFLH G]LHZLÛÉ VRORZ\FK
:\V]NRQL ZRNDOLVWND L NRPSR]\WRUND QLHJG\ĝ ]ZLÇ]DQD ] ]HVSRĄHP Ȍă]\ȋ SĄ\W P LQ 7ULEXWH WR .RPHGD ]ĄRWD SĄ\WD L Z SHĄQL DXWRUVNÇ Ȍ6SLV WUHĝFLȋ -HM HWLXGD

$UW\VWFH EÛG]LH WRZDU]\V]\Ą JRVSRGDU] PX]\F]Q\ ΖJRU 3U]HELQGRZVNL : SURJUDPLH IDEXODUQD SW Ȍ6NU]\GĄDȋ SRND]\ZDQD E\ĄD QD PLÛG]\QDURGRZ\FK IHVWLZDODFK
ȴOPRZ\FK P LQ Z 0RVNZLH 7DMSHM %RORQLL %DUFHORQLH 6WDPEXOH L 3DU\ľX
PX]\F]QH ]DMÛFLD GOD G]LHFL Z ZLHNX SU]HGV]NROQ\P L ZF]HVQRV]NROQ\P D WDNľH
PLQLNRQFHUW GOD QDMPĄRGV]\FK 2SRODQ 0 0DULD 6DGRZVND E\ĄD JRĝFLHP 0DĄHM $NDGHPLL 3LRVHQNL PDUFD $UW\VWND ZUD]
] JRVSRGDU]HP PX]\F]Q\P ΖJRUHP 3U]HELQGRZVNLP ]DSURVLOL G]LHFL QD QLH]Z\NĄH ZDUV]WDW\
PX]\F]QH SRGF]DV NWµU\FK ZVSµOQLH ĝSLHZDOL DOH SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP GREU]H VLÛ EDZLOL










































08=(80 32/6.Ζ(- 3Ζ26(1.Ζ

_ ZZZ PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO _ PX]HXP#PX]HXPSLRVHQNL SO
XO 3LDVWRZVND $ 2SROH $PȴWHDWU ZHMĝFLH RG XO %DUOLFNLHJR





















1$6=( 35(0,(5<



,JQDÐ .LWHN DUFKLWHNW

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV

3U]H]DEDZQD L QLHSRNRUQD NVLÃ×ND

9Ü«ˆĂ¹« ôØãÊύ«Êô— ¼«ã—؁¹Ê R UHDOL]RZDQLX VZRLFK SDVML ZEUHZ
SU]HFLZQRÐFLRP



« Õ« ¹Ã«— «¼èÜãØÊôÃ— =É




5µ]LD 5HZHOND LQ×\QLHUND

1DV]H Z\GDZQLFWZR VSHFMDOL]XMH VLÇ Z VWDUDQQ\P GRERU]H RIHUW\ L SURSRQXMH $QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV
URG]LFRP L G]LHFLRP Z\VRNLHM MDNRÐFL NVLÃ×NL ]DUµZQR ZDUWRÐFLRZH OLWHUDFNR =DEDZQD L PÃGUD RSRZLHÐÅ R

MDN L SLÇNQLH LOXVWURZDQH 7R ìSLFWXUHERRNVë å NVLÃ×NL Z NWµU\FK WHNVW L REUD] UHDOL]RZDQLX SDVML L QLH]UD×DQLX
ZVSµÊJUDMà ]H VREà WZRU]ÃF XQLNDOQà MDNRÐÅ NWµUHM QLH GDÊRE\ VLÇ RVLÃJQÃÅ EH] VLÇ QLHSRZRG]HQLDPL
KDUPRQLL PLÇG]\ QLPL 6Ã WR SXEOLNDFMH GOD Z\PDJDMÃF\FK å SRXF]DMÃFD
L MHGQRF]HÐQLH HNVF\WXMÃFD OLWHUDWXUD G]LHFLÇFD =É








7HN 1RZRF]HVQ\ MDVNLQLRZLHF

3DWULFN 0F'RQQHOO


=DEDZQ\ VSRVµE PµZLHQLD R ]QDF]HQLX Z\ÊÃF]HQLD
RWDF]DMÃF\FK QDV XU]ÃG]HÌ L FLHV]HQLD VLÇ XURNDPL

SLÇNQHJR ÐZLDWD GRRNRÊD


=É


$GD %DPELQL 1DXNRZF]\QL

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV


=$32:,('Ô





#.LQGHUNXOND




:6=<67.,( .6,ÂÖ., '267Æ31( 1$ ::: .,1'(5.8/.$ 3/

1$6=( 35(0,(5<



,JQDÐ .LWHN DUFKLWHNW

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV

3U]H]DEDZQD L QLHSRNRUQD NVLÃ×ND

9Ü«ˆĂ¹« ôØãÊύ«Êô— ¼«ã—؁¹Ê R UHDOL]RZDQLX VZRLFK SDVML ZEUHZ
SU]HFLZQRÐFLRP



« Õ« ¹Ã«— «¼èÜãØÊôÃ— =É




5µ]LD 5HZHOND LQ×\QLHUND

1DV]H Z\GDZQLFWZR VSHFMDOL]XMH VLÇ Z VWDUDQQ\P GRERU]H RIHUW\ L SURSRQXMH $QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV
URG]LFRP L G]LHFLRP Z\VRNLHM MDNRÐFL NVLÃ×NL ]DUµZQR ZDUWRÐFLRZH OLWHUDFNR =DEDZQD L PÃGUD RSRZLHÐÅ R

MDN L SLÇNQLH LOXVWURZDQH 7R ìSLFWXUHERRNVë å NVLÃ×NL Z NWµU\FK WHNVW L REUD] UHDOL]RZDQLX SDVML L QLH]UD×DQLX
ZVSµÊJUDMà ]H VREà WZRU]ÃF XQLNDOQà MDNRÐÅ NWµUHM QLH GDÊRE\ VLÇ RVLÃJQÃÅ EH] VLÇ QLHSRZRG]HQLDPL
KDUPRQLL PLÇG]\ QLPL 6Ã WR SXEOLNDFMH GOD Z\PDJDMÃF\FK å SRXF]DMÃFD
L MHGQRF]HÐQLH HNVF\WXMÃFD OLWHUDWXUD G]LHFLÇFD =É








7HN 1RZRF]HVQ\ MDVNLQLRZLHF

3DWULFN 0F'RQQHOO


=DEDZQ\ VSRVµE PµZLHQLD R ]QDF]HQLX Z\ÊÃF]HQLD
RWDF]DMÃF\FK QDV XU]ÃG]HÌ L FLHV]HQLD VLÇ XURNDPL

SLÇNQHJR ÐZLDWD GRRNRÊD


=É


$GD %DPELQL 1DXNRZF]\QL

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV


=$32:,('Ô





#.LQGHUNXOND




:6=<67.,( .6,ÂÖ., '267Æ31( 1$ ::: .,1'(5.8/.$ 3/







=GURZH VWRS\ 'R SURGXNFML REXZLD 0HPR VWRVR

ZDQH VĈ QDMZ\İV]HM MDNRĤFL PDWHULDã\ :LHU
G]LHFND ]FKQLD L ZHZQčWU]QD F]čĤþ EXWD Z\NRQDQD
MHVW ] QDWXUDOQ\FK PLčNNLFK VNyU NR]LFK
LGHDOQ\FK GOD VWRS\ G]LHFND 6NyU\ WH Z
VSRVyE QDWXUDOQ\ GRVWRVRZXMĈ VLč GR
0HPR WR QDMZ\İV]HM MDNRĤFL REXZLH GOD
G]LHFL Z\NRQDQH Z NODV\F]Q\P VW\OX ] VWRS\ W\P VDP\P ]ZLčNV]DMĈ NRPIRUW Xİ\W
QDWXUDOQ\FK PDWHULDãyZ SU]\MD]Q\FK VWRSLH NRZDQLD 1LHNWyUH PRGHOH Z\SRVDİRQH
G]LHFND 8QLNDWRZĈ IXQNFMč GLDJQRVW\F]QĈ ]RVWDã\ Z VSHFMDOLVW\F]QĈ SRGV]HZNč
]DSHZQLD V\VWHP PRQLWRULQJX Z SRGHV]ZLH EH]FKURPRZĈ 1DWXUDOQH PDWHULDã\ R
0HPR :\SUDFRZDQD SU]H] ODWD NRQVWUXN ZãDĤFLZRĤFLDFK KLJURVNRSLMQ\FK VSUDZLDMĈ
FMD L WHFKQRORJLD PRQWDİX EXWyZ 0HPR İH EXW RGG\FKD D VWRSD QLH XOHJD
] ]DSRFHQLX
]\VNDãD\VNDãD X]QDQLH VSHFMDOLVWyZ MDNR
VNXWHF]QD PHWRGD SURILODNW\NL L OHF]HQLD
QDMF]čVWV]\FK ZDG SRVWDZ\









8QLNDWRZ\ V\VWHP G\QDPLF]QHM NRQWUROL
VWyS G]LHFND GDMĈF\ PRİOLZRĤþ ELHİĈFHJR
PRQLWRURZDQLD VWDQX VWyS RUD] QDW\FKPLD
VWRZHM UHDNFML 6SHFMDOQ\ RGVWDZLRQ\ NV]
WDãW SRGHV]Z\ GRGDWNRZR VWDELOL]XMH VWRSč
L ]DSHZQLD SUDZLGãRZH MHM XãRİHQLH SRG 6SHFMDOQD WHFKQRORJLD PRQWDİX
F]DV FKRGX 'LDJQRVW\F]QD SRGHV]ZD 9 WHFK SROHJDMĈFD QD SUDZLGãRZ\P XVW
0HPR 2EV]DUHP GLDJQRVW\F]Q\P REXZLD DZLHQLX FKROHZNL SRGF]DV SURFHVX PRQ
0HPR MHVW MHJR SRGHV]ZD 1D MHM SRZLHU WRZDQLD EXWD 7HFKQRORJLD WD JZDUDQWXMH
]FKQL RUD] QD REFDVLH ]RVWDãR Z\RGUčEQL ]DFKRZDQLH RVL V\PHWULL Z Z\SURGXNRZ
RQ\FK V]HĤþ SRQXPHURZDQ\FK VWUHI ] Z\ DQ\P EXFLH D W\P VDP\P ZUD] ] FKDUDNW
SXNã\PL SDVNDPL ELHİQLND VWUHID QRUP\ HU\VW\F]Q\P V]W\ZQ\P ]DSLčWNLHP L Z\VRNĈ
VWUHID U\]\ND RUD] F]WHU\ VWUHI\ GXİHM G\V FKROHZNĈ ZVSRPDJD SUDZLGãRZ\ UR]ZyM
IXQNFML 3RGF]DV Xİ\WNRZDQLD SDVNL XOHJDMĈ VWyS 2EXZLH 0HPR SR]EDZLRQH MHVW FHFK
ĤFLHUDQLX G]LčNL F]HPX VWDUWH IUDJPHQW\ NRQVWUXNF\MQ\FK PRJĈF\FK ]DNãyFLþ
XPRİOLZLDMĈ V]\ENĈ L SUHF\]\MQĈ GLDJQR]č REUD] U]HF]\ZLVWHM IL]MRORJLL L SRWU]HE VWyS Z
ZDG VWyS RUD] HZHQWXDOQH GREUDQLH RNUHVLH Z]UDVWDQLD ']LčNL WHPX REXZLH
ZNãDGHN : SU]\SDGNX EUDNX NRQLHF]QRĤFL 0HPR XMDZQLD LFK SUDZLGãRZRĤþ PRUIR
VWRVRZDQLD ZNãDGHN NRU\JXMĈF\FK EXW\ ORJLF]QRF]\QQRĤFLRZĈ OXE LVWQLHMĈFH
0HPR VSHãQLDMĈ IXQNFMč SURILODNW\F]QĈ ZDG\ EĈGĮ LFK V\PSWRP\
=HVWDZ ZNãDGHN ZFKRG]ĈF\FK Z VNãDG
V\VWHPX\VWHPX 0HPR ZUD] ] ZEXGRZDQ\P Z
V 3URGXNW X]\VNDã SR]\W\ZQĈ RSLQLč
SRGHV]ZLH REFDVHP 7KRPDV·D QDGDMH Å&HQWUXP =GURZLD ']LHFNDµ
EXWRP 0HPR FKDUDNWHU REXZLD NRUHNF\M
QHJR 2GSRZLHGQLD GOD G]LHFND ZNãDGND
PRİH E\þ GREUDQD EH]SRĤUHGQLR SU]H]
URG]LFD QD SRGVWDZLH ]DãĈF]RQHM LQVWUXNFML
Xİ\WNRZDQLD 6\VWHPX 0HPR OXE ZJ ZVND
]Dę VSHFMDOLVW\




ZZZ ]GURZHEXFLNL SO