MP Atabe

/SWQMG^RI -RWTMVEGNI XS SJMGNEPRE WXVSRE M WOPIT MRXIVRIXS[] JMVQ] %8%&) &IEXE '^EO
*MVQE ^ENQYNI WMʚ WTV^IHE˵ʈ EVX]OYɹ[ XIOWX]PR]GL M TS˒GMIPS[]GL SVE^ HSHEXOɹ[ []TSWE˵IRME [RʚXV^

1EV^IRMIQ [E˒GMGMIPOM SH ^E[W^I F]S ^ENQS[ERMI WMʚ []TSWE˵IRMIQ [RʚXV^ (YKS W^YOEE W[SNIN ^E[SHS[IN HVSKM 4SXVEJME
KSH^MREQM TV^IKPʈHEʊ QEKE^]R] M EPFYQ] [RʚXV^EVWOMI ˒PIH^Mʊ FPSKM M WXVSR] TS˒[MʚGSRI XIN XIQEX]GI 2MI WʈH^ME ˵I OMIH]OSP[MIO
SH[E˵] WMʚ RE XEOM OVSO M SXS NIWX
/SWQMG^RI -RWTMVEGNI SJIVYNʈ 4EʿWX[Y TVSHYOX] X]POS REN[]˵W^IN NEOS˒GM FI^TMIG^RI [ Y˵]XOS[ERMY TSWMEHENʈGI WXSWS[RI GIVX]JMOEX]
E E MGL HSHEXOS[]Q EXYXIQ Wʈ OSROYVIRG]NRI GIR]
7OPIT MRXIVRIXS[] /SWQMG^RI -RWTMVEGNI TS[WXE ^ Q]˒Pʈ S /PMIRXEGL OXɹV^] GIRMʈ WSFMI []KSHʚ M OSQJSVX NEOM HENʈ ^EOYT] SRPMRI

>ETVEW^EQ] 4EʿWX[E HS ˒PIH^IRME /SWQMG^R]GL -RWTMVEGNM M WOSV^]WXERME ^ FSKEXIN SJIVX] TVSHYOXɹ[ ^RER]GL TSPWOMGL TVSHYGIRXɹ[
E XEO˵I HSʈG^IRME HS KVSRE ^EHS[SPSR]GL /PMIRXɹ[





%8%&) &IEXE '^EO
(0% (>-)'- ;EVW^E[E YP ,S˵E
(PE REW^]GL RENQSHW^]GL SJIVYNIQ] TVSHYOX] S RMIFEREPR]Q [^SVRMGX[MI /SPSVS[I TSWMEHENʈGI ˵][ʈ M FEV[Rʈ KVEJMOʚ G^ʚWXS 8IPIJSR OSRXEOXS[]
TV^IHWXE[MENʈGI FSLEXIVɹ[ OVIWOɹ[IO M FENIO PYF YPYFMSR]GL ^[MIV^EOɹ[ 4VSHYOX] ^ [M^IVYROMIQ TSTYPEVR]GL OWMʚ˵RMG^IO M OYG]Oɹ[ HPE
H^MI[G^]RIO HPE GLSTGɹ[ QSHIPI YPYFMSR]GL []˒GMKɹ[IO M H^MIPR]GL WYTIVFSLEXIVɹ[ >EMRWTMVYN WMʚ REW^]QM TVSTS^]GNEQM M []FMIV^ [[[ EXEFI IY
TVSHYOX] [ TIRM LEVQSRM^YNʈGI ^ YTSHSFERMEQM 8[SNIKS H^MIGOE QMʚH^] MRR]QM OSH] H^MIGMʚGI TSHYW^OM TS˒GMIPI H^MIGMʚGI TSW^I[OM EXEFI$EXEFI IY
TV^I˒GMIVEHE VʚG^RMOM SVE^ HSHEXOM 3JIVYNIQ] GEOS[MGMI FI^TMIG^RI TVSHYOX] []OSRERI ^ REXYVEPR]GL XOERMR 4S^[ɹP 1EPYGLS[M []FVEʊ
W[[ɹN []QEV^SR] [^ɹV EF] GLʚXRMIN OEH WMʚ HS WRY [˒VɹH W[SMGL YPYFMSR]GL FSLEXIVɹ[
W

/SWQMG^RI -RWTMVEGNI XS SJMGNEPRE WXVSRE M WOPIT MRXIVRIXS[] JMVQ] %8%&) &IEXE '^EO
*MVQE ^ENQYNI WMʚ WTV^IHE˵ʈ EVX]OYɹ[ XIOWX]PR]GL M TS˒GMIPS[]GL SVE^ HSHEXOɹ[ []TSWE˵IRME [RʚXV^

1EV^IRMIQ [E˒GMGMIPOM SH ^E[W^I F]S ^ENQS[ERMI WMʚ []TSWE˵IRMIQ [RʚXV^ (YKS W^YOEE W[SNIN ^E[SHS[IN HVSKM 4SXVEJME
KSH^MREQM TV^IKPʈHEʊ QEKE^]R] M EPFYQ] [RʚXV^EVWOMI ˒PIH^Mʊ FPSKM M WXVSR] TS˒[MʚGSRI XIN XIQEX]GI 2MI WʈH^ME ˵I OMIH]OSP[MIO
SH[E˵] WMʚ RE XEOM OVSO M SXS NIWX
/SWQMG^RI -RWTMVEGNI SJIVYNʈ 4EʿWX[Y TVSHYOX] X]POS REN[]˵W^IN NEOS˒GM FI^TMIG^RI [ Y˵]XOS[ERMY TSWMEHENʈGI WXSWS[RI GIVX]JMOEX]
E E MGL HSHEXOS[]Q EXYXIQ Wʈ OSROYVIRG]NRI GIR]
7OPIT MRXIVRIXS[] /SWQMG^RI -RWTMVEGNI TS[WXE ^ Q]˒Pʈ S /PMIRXEGL OXɹV^] GIRMʈ WSFMI []KSHʚ M OSQJSVX NEOM HENʈ ^EOYT] SRPMRI

>ETVEW^EQ] 4EʿWX[E HS ˒PIH^IRME /SWQMG^R]GL -RWTMVEGNM M WOSV^]WXERME ^ FSKEXIN SJIVX] TVSHYOXɹ[ ^RER]GL TSPWOMGL TVSHYGIRXɹ[
E XEO˵I HSʈG^IRME HS KVSRE ^EHS[SPSR]GL /PMIRXɹ[





%8%&) &IEXE '^EO
(0% (>-)'- ;EVW^E[E YP ,S˵E
(PE REW^]GL RENQSHW^]GL SJIVYNIQ] TVSHYOX] S RMIFEREPR]Q [^SVRMGX[MI /SPSVS[I TSWMEHENʈGI ˵][ʈ M FEV[Rʈ KVEJMOʚ G^ʚWXS 8IPIJSR OSRXEOXS[]
TV^IHWXE[MENʈGI FSLEXIVɹ[ OVIWOɹ[IO M FENIO PYF YPYFMSR]GL ^[MIV^EOɹ[ 4VSHYOX] ^ [M^IVYROMIQ TSTYPEVR]GL OWMʚ˵RMG^IO M OYG]Oɹ[ HPE
H^MI[G^]RIO HPE GLSTGɹ[ QSHIPI YPYFMSR]GL []˒GMKɹ[IO M H^MIPR]GL WYTIVFSLEXIVɹ[ >EMRWTMVYN WMʚ REW^]QM TVSTS^]GNEQM M []FMIV^ [[[ EXEFI IY
TVSHYOX] [ TIRM LEVQSRM^YNʈGI ^ YTSHSFERMEQM 8[SNIKS H^MIGOE QMʚH^] MRR]QM OSH] H^MIGMʚGI TSHYW^OM TS˒GMIPI H^MIGMʚGI TSW^I[OM EXEFI$EXEFI IY
TV^I˒GMIVEHE VʚG^RMOM SVE^ HSHEXOM 3JIVYNIQ] GEOS[MGMI FI^TMIG^RI TVSHYOX] []OSRERI ^ REXYVEPR]GL XOERMR 4S^[ɹP 1EPYGLS[M []FVEʊ
W[[ɹN []QEV^SR] [^ɹV EF] GLʚXRMIN OEH WMʚ HS WRY [˒VɹH W[SMGL YPYFMSR]GL FSLEXIVɹ[
W





1$6=<&+ .6,ÆIJ(. 1,( 02IJ( 3,26(1., 35=('6=.2/$.$ 3,26(1., 1$6=(*2


=$%5$.1ÆÈ : 7:2,0 '208 ;OBKE[JFNZ UV QJPTFOLJ [OBOF XT[ZTULJN '=,(&,þ67:$ &'
+FE[JF QPDJnjH [ EBMFLB ,SBLPXJBD[FL KFEFO D[Z
E[JFDJPN PSB[ JDI SPE[JDPN J E[JBELPN
8 LTJnjȈFD[DF [FCSBOP NFMPEJF 1JFTLJ NB’F EXB UP QJPTFOLJ [OBOF XT[ZTULJN
E[JFDJPN PSB[ JDI SPE[JDPN J E[JBELPN
QS[FLB[ZXBOF [ QPLPMFOJB OB QPLPMFOJF 8 LTJnjȈFD[DF [FCSBOP NFMPEJF QS[FLB[ZXBOF
LUØSF OB E’VHP [BKNnj VXBHǗ [BSØXOP [ QPLPMFOJB OB QPLPMFOJF LUØSF OB E’VHP [BKNnj
NB’ZDI KBL J XJǗLT[ZDI QPDJFDI VXBHǗ [BSØXOP NB’ZDI KBL J XJǗLT[ZDI QPDJFDI

&(1$ ǮǮ ǶǶ =ü &(1$ ǰǶ Ƕǭ =ü







%(=3,(&=1( '=,(&,$., /,7(5., , &<)(5., : =22

;BQFXOJFOJF CF[QJFD[FǩTUXB E[JFDJPN ,TJnjȈFD[LB [BXJFSB XFTP’F XJFST[ZLJ E[JǗLJ
UP KFEOP [ OBK XBȈOJFKT[ZDI [BEBǩ LUØSZN N’PET[F E[JFDJ QP[OBKnj MJUFSLJ J DZGFSLJ
: Q D V ] \ P V N O H S L H ] Q D M G Ç 3 D ÿ V W Z R N V L Ç ij N L SPE[JDØX OBVD[ZDJFMJ PQJFLVOØX /BT[B PSB[ QPETUBXPXF E[JB’BOJB J [OBLJ
NBUFNBUZD[OF KBL QMVT NJOVT [OBL SØXOPǴDJ
G O D G ] L H F L N V L Ç ij N L G O D Pý R G ] L H ij \ N R O R U R Z D Q N L LTJnjȈLB [BXJFSB OBKXBȈOJFKT[F [BTBEZ %PXJFE[nj TJǗ UFȈ EP D[FHP T’VȈnj X [EBOJV
CF[QJFD[FǩTUXB /BVLB SFHV’ [BDIPXBOJB
G O D G ] L H F L N V L Ç ij N L N X O L Q D U Q H R U D ] S R U D G Q L N L TJǗ X SØȈOZDI TZUVBDKBDI PECZXB TJǗ LSPQLB XZLS[ZLOJL J [OBL [BQZUBOJB /BUPNJBTU
TUBST[F QPDJFDIZ CǗEnj NPH’Z EPTLPOBMJǎ
] V H U L L 6 L R V W U D 0D U L D QS[F[ [BCBXǗ D
D[[ZUBOJF NFUPEnj TZMBCPXnj
&(1$ ǯDZ ǶǶ =ü &(1$ ǮDz ǶǶ =ü





$.$'(0,$ $.$'(0,$ 35(=(17•:
.5($7<:1(*2 '=,(&.$ "LBEFNJB QSF[FOUØX UP XTQBOJB’B LTJnjȈLB EMB

"LBEFNJB LSFBUZXOFHP E[JFDLB [BXJFSB E[JFDJ J N’PE[JFȈZ E[JǗLJ LUØSFK CǗEnj NPH’Z
XJFMF XTQBOJB’ZDI QSPKFLUØX OB P[EPCZ QS[ZHPUPXBǎ QJǗLOF QSF[FOUZ EMB OBKCMJȈT[ZDI
J QS[FENJPUZ LUØSF LBȈEF E[JFDLP NPȈF J PSZHJOBMOF P[EPCZ ǴXJnjUFD[OF 8T[ZTULJF
TBNPE[JFMOJF XZLPOBǎ B QØȇOJFK [BXBSUF X "LBEFNJJ QSPQP[ZDKF Tnj CBSE[P
QSBLUZD[OJF XZLPS[ZTUBǎ MVC LPNVǴ ’BUXF EP XZLPOBOJB B LBȈEZ PQJT PQBUS[POZ
QPEBSPXBǎ KFTU CBSXOZNJ GPUPHSBöBNJ
&(1$ ǯǶ ǶǶ =ü &(1$ ǯǶ ǶǶ =ü







/(*(1'< 32/6.,( /(*(1'< 32/6.,(

-FHFOEZ 1PMTLJF UP PQPXJFǴDJ -FHFOEZ 1PMTLJF UP PQPXJFǴDJ TUBOPXJnjDF
TUBOPXJnjDF XJFMLnj MJUFSBDLnj QS[ZHPEǗ XJFMLnj MJUFSBDLnj QS[ZHPEǗ [BSØXOP EMB
[BSØXOP EMB OBKN’PET[ZDI KBL UFȈ EMB OBKN’PET[ZDI KBL UFȈ EMB TUBST[ZDI
TUBST[ZDI QBTKPOBUØX OJFTBNPXJUZDI QBTKPOBUØX OJFTBNPXJUZDI IJTUPSJJ LUØS[Z
IJTUPSJJ LUØS[Z E[JǗLJ OJFK CǗEnj NPHMJ E[JǗLJ OJFK CǗEnj NPHMJ DIPǎ OB DIXJMǗ
WHO ZHZ _ VNOHS#Z\GDZQLFWZRPDUWHO SO DIPǎ OB DIXJMǗ QPXSØDJǎ EP QJǗLOZDI QPXSØDJǎ EP QJǗLOZDI D[BTØX TXPKFHP
E[JFDJǩTUXB
D[BTØX TXPKFHP E[JFDJǩTUXB
ZZZ Z\GDZQLFWZRPDUWHO SO &(1$ ǮǮ ǶǶ =ü &(1$ ǮǮ ǶǶ =ü

1$6=<&+ .6,ÆIJ(. 1,( 02IJ( 3,26(1., 35=('6=.2/$.$ 3,26(1., 1$6=(*2


=$%5$.1ÆÈ : 7:2,0 '208 ;OBKE[JFNZ UV QJPTFOLJ [OBOF XT[ZTULJN '=,(&,þ67:$ &'
+FE[JF QPDJnjH [ EBMFLB ,SBLPXJBD[FL KFEFO D[Z
E[JFDJPN PSB[ JDI SPE[JDPN J E[JBELPN
8 LTJnjȈFD[DF [FCSBOP NFMPEJF 1JFTLJ NB’F EXB UP QJPTFOLJ [OBOF XT[ZTULJN
E[JFDJPN PSB[ JDI SPE[JDPN J E[JBELPN
QS[FLB[ZXBOF [ QPLPMFOJB OB QPLPMFOJF 8 LTJnjȈFD[DF [FCSBOP NFMPEJF QS[FLB[ZXBOF
LUØSF OB E’VHP [BKNnj VXBHǗ [BSØXOP [ QPLPMFOJB OB QPLPMFOJF LUØSF OB E’VHP [BKNnj
NB’ZDI KBL J XJǗLT[ZDI QPDJFDI VXBHǗ [BSØXOP NB’ZDI KBL J XJǗLT[ZDI QPDJFDI

&(1$ ǮǮ ǶǶ =ü &(1$ ǰǶ Ƕǭ =ü







%(=3,(&=1( '=,(&,$., /,7(5., , &<)(5., : =22

;BQFXOJFOJF CF[QJFD[FǩTUXB E[JFDJPN ,TJnjȈFD[LB [BXJFSB XFTP’F XJFST[ZLJ E[JǗLJ
UP KFEOP [ OBK XBȈOJFKT[ZDI [BEBǩ LUØSZN N’PET[F E[JFDJ QP[OBKnj MJUFSLJ J DZGFSLJ
: Q D V ] \ P V N O H S L H ] Q D M G Ç 3 D ÿ V W Z R N V L Ç ij N L SPE[JDØX OBVD[ZDJFMJ PQJFLVOØX /BT[B PSB[ QPETUBXPXF E[JB’BOJB J [OBLJ
NBUFNBUZD[OF KBL QMVT NJOVT [OBL SØXOPǴDJ
G O D G ] L H F L N V L Ç ij N L G O D Pý R G ] L H ij \ N R O R U R Z D Q N L LTJnjȈLB [BXJFSB OBKXBȈOJFKT[F [BTBEZ %PXJFE[nj TJǗ UFȈ EP D[FHP T’VȈnj X [EBOJV
CF[QJFD[FǩTUXB /BVLB SFHV’ [BDIPXBOJB
G O D G ] L H F L N V L Ç ij N L N X O L Q D U Q H R U D ] S R U D G Q L N L TJǗ X SØȈOZDI TZUVBDKBDI PECZXB TJǗ LSPQLB XZLS[ZLOJL J [OBL [BQZUBOJB /BUPNJBTU
TUBST[F QPDJFDIZ CǗEnj NPH’Z EPTLPOBMJǎ
D[[ZUBOJF NFUPEnj TZMBCPXnj
] V H U L L 6 L R V W U D 0D U L D QS[F[ [BCBXǗ D
&(1$ ǯDZ ǶǶ =ü &(1$ ǮDz ǶǶ =ü





$.$'(0,$ $.$'(0,$ 35(=(17•:
.5($7<:1(*2 '=,(&.$ "LBEFNJB QSF[FOUØX UP XTQBOJB’B LTJnjȈLB EMB

"LBEFNJB LSFBUZXOFHP E[JFDLB [BXJFSB E[JFDJ J N’PE[JFȈZ E[JǗLJ LUØSFK CǗEnj NPH’Z
XJFMF XTQBOJB’ZDI QSPKFLUØX OB P[EPCZ QS[ZHPUPXBǎ QJǗLOF QSF[FOUZ EMB OBKCMJȈT[ZDI
J QS[FENJPUZ LUØSF LBȈEF E[JFDLP NPȈF J PSZHJOBMOF P[EPCZ ǴXJnjUFD[OF 8T[ZTULJF
TBNPE[JFMOJF XZLPOBǎ B QØȇOJFK [BXBSUF X "LBEFNJJ QSPQP[ZDKF Tnj CBSE[P
QSBLUZD[OJF XZLPS[ZTUBǎ MVC LPNVǴ ’BUXF EP XZLPOBOJB B LBȈEZ PQJT PQBUS[POZ
QPEBSPXBǎ KFTU CBSXOZNJ GPUPHSBöBNJ
&(1$ ǯǶ ǶǶ =ü &(1$ ǯǶ ǶǶ =ü







/(*(1'< 32/6.,( /(*(1'< 32/6.,(

-FHFOEZ 1PMTLJF UP PQPXJFǴDJ -FHFOEZ 1PMTLJF UP PQPXJFǴDJ TUBOPXJnjDF
TUBOPXJnjDF XJFMLnj MJUFSBDLnj QS[ZHPEǗ XJFMLnj MJUFSBDLnj QS[ZHPEǗ [BSØXOP EMB
[BSØXOP EMB OBKN’PET[ZDI KBL UFȈ EMB OBKN’PET[ZDI KBL UFȈ EMB TUBST[ZDI
TUBST[ZDI QBTKPOBUØX OJFTBNPXJUZDI QBTKPOBUØX OJFTBNPXJUZDI IJTUPSJJ LUØS[Z
IJTUPSJJ LUØS[Z E[JǗLJ OJFK CǗEnj NPHMJ E[JǗLJ OJFK CǗEnj NPHMJ DIPǎ OB DIXJMǗ
WHO ZHZ _ VNOHS#Z\GDZQLFWZRPDUWHO SO DIPǎ OB DIXJMǗ QPXSØDJǎ EP QJǗLOZDI QPXSØDJǎ EP QJǗLOZDI D[BTØX TXPKFHP
E[JFDJǩTUXB
D[BTØX TXPKFHP E[JFDJǩTUXB
ZZZ Z\GDZQLFWZRPDUWHO SO &(1$ ǮǮ ǶǶ =ü &(1$ ǮǮ ǶǶ =ü

ĻõËà’ĻÝU















ÙŇîËõĩ










'URG]\ 5RG]LFH
'EDFLH R EH]SLHF]HĆVWZR VZRLFK G]LHFL" &KURQLFLH MH SU]HG FKRUREDPL" =DUD]NDPL" %DNWHULDPL"


$OH F]\ WDNľH Z WRDOHFLH"

: GRPX SXFXMHFLH ĄD]LHQNL GR VHGHVµZ Xľ\ZDFLH EDNWHULREµMF]\FK SĄ\QµZ NRVWHN ľHOLȐ 0DFLH VSHFMDOQH QDNĄDGNL
QD GHVNÛ VHGHVRZÇ ľHE\ PDOXFK Z\JRGQLH XVLDGĄ

$ SRWHP LG]LHFLH ] G]LHFNLHP GR ZHVRĄHJR PLDVWHF]ND NLQD VNOHSX LȐ Ȍ0DPRRR 6LNX ȋ %\ZD ľH SRWU]HED MHVW
SRZDľQLHMV]D L MXľ ]D NU]DF]HN QLH SµMG]LHP\ -HV]F]H JRU]HM JG\ G]LHFNR MHVW Z SU]HGV]NROX DOER Z V]NROH L PXVL
SRUDG]LÉ VRELH VDPR


2WR UR]ZLÇ]DQLH WHJR SUREOHPX ĻõËà’ĻÝU ĹÙŇîËõĩ


ȏ 5R]NĄDGDFLH MÇ QD GHVFH L EH]SLHF]QLH Z\JRGQLH VDG]DFLH G]LHFNR

ȏ -HVW V]HURND 0DOXFK GOD XWU]\PDQLD UµZQRZDJL ĄDSLH EU]HJ VHGHVX SU]H] SDSLHU ] ]DFKRZDQLHP KLJLHQ\ L VSRNRMQLH VRELH
VLHG]L
ȏ : FKZLOL VSXV]F]DQLD ZRG\ 72Ζ/(7.$ MHVW VDPRF]\QQLH VSĄXNLZDQD

ȏ 8OHJD ELRGHJUDGDFML
ȏ
ȏ .RORURZH SRWZRUNL L GUXN QD SDSLHU]H WR RND]MD GR HGXNDF\MQHM ]DEDZ\ QS WZRU]HQLD KLVWRU\MHN G]LÛNL NWµU\P ]EXGXMHFLH .RORURZH SRWZRUNL L GUXN QD SDSLHU]H WR RND]MD GR HGXNDF\MQHM ]DEDZ\ QS WZRU]HQLD KLVWRU\MHN G]LÛNL NWµU\P ]EXGXMHFLH
G]LHFLÛFH WRDOHWRZH U\WXDĄ\ L Z\URELFLH SUDZLGĄRZH QDZ\NL KLJLHQLF]QH NWµUH ]RVWDQÇ G]LHFNX QD FDĄH ľ\FLH





3URGXFHQW 3257Ζ&$ ŕŕŕęĒõĩĻËvUęĒá

WHO hËŇĩöfĒõĩĻËvUęĒá

ĻõËà’ĻÝU















ÙŇîËõĩ










'URG]\ 5RG]LFH
'EDFLH R EH]SLHF]HĆVWZR VZRLFK G]LHFL" &KURQLFLH MH SU]HG FKRUREDPL" =DUD]NDPL" %DNWHULDPL"


$OH F]\ WDNľH Z WRDOHFLH"

: GRPX SXFXMHFLH ĄD]LHQNL GR VHGHVµZ Xľ\ZDFLH EDNWHULREµMF]\FK SĄ\QµZ NRVWHN ľHOLȐ 0DFLH VSHFMDOQH QDNĄDGNL
QD GHVNÛ VHGHVRZÇ ľHE\ PDOXFK Z\JRGQLH XVLDGĄ

$ SRWHP LG]LHFLH ] G]LHFNLHP GR ZHVRĄHJR PLDVWHF]ND NLQD VNOHSX LȐ Ȍ0DPRRR 6LNX ȋ %\ZD ľH SRWU]HED MHVW
SRZDľQLHMV]D L MXľ ]D NU]DF]HN QLH SµMG]LHP\ -HV]F]H JRU]HM JG\ G]LHFNR MHVW Z SU]HGV]NROX DOER Z V]NROH L PXVL
SRUDG]LÉ VRELH VDPR


2WR UR]ZLÇ]DQLH WHJR SUREOHPX ĻõËà’ĻÝU ĹÙŇîËõĩ


ȏ 5R]NĄDGDFLH MÇ QD GHVFH L EH]SLHF]QLH Z\JRGQLH VDG]DFLH G]LHFNR

ȏ -HVW V]HURND 0DOXFK GOD XWU]\PDQLD UµZQRZDJL ĄDSLH EU]HJ VHGHVX SU]H] SDSLHU ] ]DFKRZDQLHP KLJLHQ\ L VSRNRMQLH VRELH
VLHG]L
ȏ : FKZLOL VSXV]F]DQLD ZRG\ 72Ζ/(7.$ MHVW VDPRF]\QQLH VSĄXNLZDQD

ȏ 8OHJD ELRGHJUDGDFML
ȏ
ȏ .RORURZH SRWZRUNL L GUXN QD SDSLHU]H WR RND]MD GR HGXNDF\MQHM ]DEDZ\ QS WZRU]HQLD KLVWRU\MHN G]LÛNL NWµU\P ]EXGXMHFLH .RORURZH SRWZRUNL L GUXN QD SDSLHU]H WR RND]MD GR HGXNDF\MQHM ]DEDZ\ QS WZRU]HQLD KLVWRU\MHN G]LÛNL NWµU\P ]EXGXMHFLH
G]LHFLÛFH WRDOHWRZH U\WXDĄ\ L Z\URELFLH SUDZLGĄRZH QDZ\NL KLJLHQLF]QH NWµUH ]RVWDQÇ G]LHFNX QD FDĄH ľ\FLH





3URGXFHQW 3257Ζ&$ ŕŕŕęĒõĩĻËvUęĒá

WHO hËŇĩöfĒõĩĻËvUęĒá





68&+( %$6(1< = 3,É(&=.$0,


2G QLHGDZQD ]DMÇOLÐP\ VLÇ SURGXNFMD VXFK\FK EDVHQµZ GOD
G]LHFL 0RW\ZDFMÃ GR G]LDÊDQLD E\Ê QDV] SHÊHQ HQHUJLL V\QHN

NWµU\ ZWHG\ PLDÊ ]DOHGZLH PLHVLÇF\ -X× ZWHG\ PRFQR
SRND]\ZDÊ QDP VZµM Z\EXMDÊ\ WHPSHUDPHQW %DVHQLN NWµU\
VDPL GOD QLHJR ]URELOLÐP\ GDÊ QDP FKZLOH Z\WFKQLHQLD RUD]
PRW\ZDFMÇ GR G]LDÊDQLD 1DV]H EDVHQLNL SR]ZDODMÃ QD FKZLOH
Z\WFKQLHQLD GOD PDP\ L WDW\ RUD] QLHVDPRZLWÃ IUDMGÇ GOD
P
PDDOXFKµZ 1LH XNU\ZDMP\ ×H P\ GRURÐOL WH× OXELP\ SREDZLÅ VLÇ
Z EDVHQLNX ] SLÊHF]NDPL GODWHJR WR WH× LGHDOQD PRW\ZDFMD GR
]DEDZ\ GOD FDÊHM URG]LQ\



















































ZZZ DMDEDE\ SO

ELXUR#DMDEDE\ FRP

68&+( %$6(1< = 3,É(&=.$0,


2G QLHGDZQD ]DMÇOLÐP\ VLÇ SURGXNFMD VXFK\FK EDVHQµZ GOD
G]LHFL 0RW\ZDFMÃ GR G]LDÊDQLD E\Ê QDV] SHÊHQ HQHUJLL V\QHN

NWµU\ ZWHG\ PLDÊ ]DOHGZLH PLHVLÇF\ -X× ZWHG\ PRFQR
SRND]\ZDÊ QDP VZµM Z\EXMDÊ\ WHPSHUDPHQW %DVHQLN NWµU\
VDPL GOD QLHJR ]URELOLÐP\ GDÊ QDP FKZLOH Z\WFKQLHQLD RUD]
PRW\ZDFMÇ GR G]LDÊDQLD 1DV]H EDVHQLNL SR]ZDODMÃ QD FKZLOH
Z\WFKQLHQLD GOD PDP\ L WDW\ RUD] QLHVDPRZLWÃ IUDMGÇ GOD
P
PDDOXFKµZ 1LH XNU\ZDMP\ ×H P\ GRURÐOL WH× OXELP\ SREDZLÅ VLÇ
Z EDVHQLNX ] SLÊHF]NDPL GODWHJR WR WH× LGHDOQD PRW\ZDFMD GR
]DEDZ\ GOD FDÊHM URG]LQ\



















































ZZZ DMDEDE\ SO

ELXUR#DMDEDE\ FRP

2MI EQ WMʙ (S EQERME QEW^ EQMKɸ[OM


03+- EQMKɸ[OM








03+- []HE[GE QMIWMʚG^RMOɹ[ HPE QMS˒RMOɹ[ SFVE^Oɹ[ PSKMG^R]GL M MRR]GL EQMKɹ[IO

7YHSOY OV^]˵ɹ[OM PMG^FS[I RSRSKVEQ] QEPS[ERMI PMG^FEQM [MIPSOVSTOM ^EHERME PSKMG^RI



/MPOE Wɸ[ S EQMKɸ[OEGL 0SKM

/E˴HE EQMKɸ[OE QE X]POS NIHRS VS^[Mʇ^ERMI ŽEQMKɹ[OM Wʈ XIWXS[ERI TVSKVEQIQ OSQTYXIVS[]Q ^ETVSNIOXS[ER]Q TV^I^
REW /E˴Hʇ EQMKɸ[Oʙ HE WMʙ VS^[Mʇ^Eʉ X]POS ^E TSQSGʇ PSKMOM RMI TSXV^IFE ^KEH][ERME 4VSKVEQ NIWX XEO ^ETVSNIOXS[ER]
˵I XIWXYNI EQMKɹ[OM VS^[Mʈ^YNʈG NI NEO G^S[MIO E RMI NEO QEW^]RE (PEXIKS EQMKɹ[OM 0SKM Wʈ XEOMI TV^]NIQRI [ VS^[Mʈ^][ERMY
3
3FFVE^OM Wʇ V]WS[ERI TV^I^ TVSJIWNSREPR]GL KVEJMOɸ[ 1EQ] FEVH^S []WSOMI WXERHEVH] HPE SFVE^Oɹ[ 2MI TV^]NQYNIQ]
[W^]WXOMGL SFVE^Oɹ[ [MIPI ^ RMGL SHV^YGEQ] FS RMI WTIRMENʈ REW^]GL []QSKɹ[ RT QENʈ TYWXI V^ʚH] Wʈ RMIG^]XIPRI EPFS
WQYXRI 4VSKVEQ YWXEPE TMʚʊ WXSTRM XVYHRS˒GM 8EO [MʚG WXSTRMI Wʈ ^YTIRMI SFMIOX][RI M RMI^QMIRRI ŽEQMKɹ[OM RMI TS[XEV^ENʈ
WMʚ 2MI ^SFEG^]W^ [ 0SKM H[ɹGL XEOMGL WEQ]GL EQMKɹ[IO 7XEVI EQMKɹ[OM HENIQ] NIH]RMI [ OWMʈ˵OEGL OXɹVI
TYFPMOYNIQ] TS ERKMIPWOY RE %QE^SR GSQ

/V^]˴ɸ[OM PMG^FS[I

.EO VS^[Mʈ^][Eʊ OV^]˵ɹ[OM PMG^FS[I#
ŵ [ TYWXI TSPE [TMW^ G]JV] SH HS
ŵ PMG^F] SOVI˒PENʈ NEOE QE F]ʊ WYQE [TMWER]GL G]JV RE TV^]OEH !
ŵ [ SFVʚFMI NIHRIN WYQ] G]JV] RMI QSKʈ WMʚ TS[XEV^Eʊ
ŵ OE˵HE EQMKɹ[OE QE HSOEHRMI NIHRS VS^[Mʈ^ERMI




























>ETVEW^EQ] RE REW^ʇ WXVSRʙ TS [MʙGIN EQMKɸ[IO




[[[ []HE[RMGX[SPSKM TP
&MYVS YP /M[IVWOE ;EVW^E[E
8IPIJSR VIHEOGNE$[]HE[RMGX[SPSKM TP

2MI EQ WMʙ (S EQERME QEW^ EQMKɸ[OM


03+- EQMKɸ[OM








03+- []HE[GE QMIWMʚG^RMOɹ[ HPE QMS˒RMOɹ[ SFVE^Oɹ[ PSKMG^R]GL M MRR]GL EQMKɹ[IO

7YHSOY OV^]˵ɹ[OM PMG^FS[I RSRSKVEQ] QEPS[ERMI PMG^FEQM [MIPSOVSTOM ^EHERME PSKMG^RI



/MPOE Wɸ[ S EQMKɸ[OEGL 0SKM

/E˴HE EQMKɸ[OE QE X]POS NIHRS VS^[Mʇ^ERMI ŽEQMKɹ[OM Wʈ XIWXS[ERI TVSKVEQIQ OSQTYXIVS[]Q ^ETVSNIOXS[ER]Q TV^I^
REW /E˴Hʇ EQMKɸ[Oʙ HE WMʙ VS^[Mʇ^Eʉ X]POS ^E TSQSGʇ PSKMOM RMI TSXV^IFE ^KEH][ERME 4VSKVEQ NIWX XEO ^ETVSNIOXS[ER]
˵I XIWXYNI EQMKɹ[OM VS^[Mʈ^YNʈG NI NEO G^S[MIO E RMI NEO QEW^]RE (PEXIKS EQMKɹ[OM 0SKM Wʈ XEOMI TV^]NIQRI [ VS^[Mʈ^][ERMY
3
3FFVE^OM Wʇ V]WS[ERI TV^I^ TVSJIWNSREPR]GL KVEJMOɸ[ 1EQ] FEVH^S []WSOMI WXERHEVH] HPE SFVE^Oɹ[ 2MI TV^]NQYNIQ]
[W^]WXOMGL SFVE^Oɹ[ [MIPI ^ RMGL SHV^YGEQ] FS RMI WTIRMENʈ REW^]GL []QSKɹ[ RT QENʈ TYWXI V^ʚH] Wʈ RMIG^]XIPRI EPFS
WQYXRI 4VSKVEQ YWXEPE TMʚʊ WXSTRM XVYHRS˒GM 8EO [MʚG WXSTRMI Wʈ ^YTIRMI SFMIOX][RI M RMI^QMIRRI ŽEQMKɹ[OM RMI TS[XEV^ENʈ
WMʚ 2MI ^SFEG^]W^ [ 0SKM H[ɹGL XEOMGL WEQ]GL EQMKɹ[IO 7XEVI EQMKɹ[OM HENIQ] NIH]RMI [ OWMʈ˵OEGL OXɹVI
TYFPMOYNIQ] TS ERKMIPWOY RE %QE^SR GSQ

/V^]˴ɸ[OM PMG^FS[I

.EO VS^[Mʈ^][Eʊ OV^]˵ɹ[OM PMG^FS[I#
ŵ [ TYWXI TSPE [TMW^ G]JV] SH HS
ŵ PMG^F] SOVI˒PENʈ NEOE QE F]ʊ WYQE [TMWER]GL G]JV RE TV^]OEH !
ŵ [ SFVʚFMI NIHRIN WYQ] G]JV] RMI QSKʈ WMʚ TS[XEV^Eʊ
ŵ OE˵HE EQMKɹ[OE QE HSOEHRMI NIHRS VS^[Mʈ^ERMI




























>ETVEW^EQ] RE REW^ʇ WXVSRʙ TS [MʙGIN EQMKɸ[IO




[[[ []HE[RMGX[SPSKM TP
&MYVS YP /M[IVWOE ;EVW^E[E
8IPIJSR VIHEOGNE$[]HE[RMGX[SPSKM TP

/PSGOS[RME ĂÈG^] [ WSFMI ^EPIX] TPEGY ^EFE[ M GIRXVYQ IHYOEGNM W^G^IK¶PRMI
[ ^EOVIWMI VS^[MNERME OSQTIXIRGNM WTSĂIG^R]GL M [WT¶ĂH^MEĂERME X[¶VG^IKS Q]ęPIRME
TV^IWXV^IRRIKS PSKMOM []SFVEĸRM OSRGIRXVEGNM SVE^ QEĂIN M HYĺIN QSXSV]OM ; ^EFE[MI

OPSGOEQM H^MIGOS HSę[MEHG^E W[SMGL TMIV[W^]GL [ĂEWR]GL WYOGIW¶[ M SWMÈKRMÜÊ
IOWTIV]QIRXYNI TSTIĂRME FĂÜH] TV^] X]Q RMIę[MEHSQMI M RMIYWXERRMI WMÜ YG^ÈG
; /PSGOS[RM HENIQ] H^MIGMSQ HS H]WTS^]GNM OPSGOM YRMOEPR]GL OW^XEĂX¶[ V¶ĺRIN [MIPOSęGM

[MIPSVEOMIN WXVYOXYV] >SWXEĂ] SRI HSFVERI [ XEOM WTSW¶F EF] FE[MÊ WMÜ RMQM TV^I^ HĂYĺW^]
G^EW FI^ ^RYH^IRME [ĂEęGM[MI RMKH] RMI FYHYNÈG XIN WEQIN FYHS[PM H[E VE^]
3JIVXE HPE W^O·ă M TV^IHW^OSPM

7^YOEW^ TSQ]WĂY RE TV^ITVS[EH^IRMI OVIEX][R]GL ^ENÜÊ# 4V^]NHĸ ^ X[SNÈ KVYTÈ OPEWÈ
HS /PSGOS[RM M []OSV^]WXEN REW^I OPSGOM HS WX[SV^IRMI RMITS[XEV^EPR]GL ^ENÜÊ PIOGNM
Ê[MG^IRME QEĂIN QSXSV]OM OSRGIRXVEGNM TSHWXE[ QEXIQEX]OM Ŷ^]OM FMSPSKMM M GLIQMM PSKMOM
OVIEX][R]GL XIGLRMO XIEXVEPR]GL MXT (YĺS ^EPIĺ] SH 'MIFMI G^] H^MIGM TSOSGLENÈ XS G^IKS
YG^]W^ M NEO HEPIN FÜHE WMÜ VS^[MNEÊ 2MI ^QEVRYN XIN W^ERW] 2EW^ TIVWSRIP HSVEH^M 'M OX¶VÈ

WXVIJÜ []FVEÊ M NEO QSĺIW^ STX]QEPRMI ^SVKERM^S[EÊ ^ENÜGME

;EVW^E[E +EPIVME 6IRSZE TMÝXVS 4MSXVO·[ 8V]FYREPWOM +EPIVME *SGYW 1EPP
ZMW E ZMW ,ERIWYWLM TMÜXVS SFSO /MRE ,IPMSW
YP 6IQFMIPMĄWOE YP 7ĂS[EGOMIKS
;EVW^E[E 4MSXVO¶[ 8V]F

XIPIJSR XIPIJSR
I QEMP VIRSZE$OPSGOS[RME GSQ I QEMP TMSXVOS[$OPSGOS[RME GSQ










8IP
[[[ OPSGOS[RME GSQ





FMYVS$OPSGOS[RME GSQ

/PSGOS[RME ĂÈG^] [ WSFMI ^EPIX] TPEGY ^EFE[ M GIRXVYQ IHYOEGNM W^G^IK¶PRMI
[ ^EOVIWMI VS^[MNERME OSQTIXIRGNM WTSĂIG^R]GL M [WT¶ĂH^MEĂERME X[¶VG^IKS Q]ęPIRME
TV^IWXV^IRRIKS PSKMOM []SFVEĸRM OSRGIRXVEGNM SVE^ QEĂIN M HYĺIN QSXSV]OM ; ^EFE[MI

OPSGOEQM H^MIGOS HSę[MEHG^E W[SMGL TMIV[W^]GL [ĂEWR]GL WYOGIW¶[ M SWMÈKRMÜÊ
IOWTIV]QIRXYNI TSTIĂRME FĂÜH] TV^] X]Q RMIę[MEHSQMI M RMIYWXERRMI WMÜ YG^ÈG
; /PSGOS[RM HENIQ] H^MIGMSQ HS H]WTS^]GNM OPSGOM YRMOEPR]GL OW^XEĂX¶[ V¶ĺRIN [MIPOSęGM

[MIPSVEOMIN WXVYOXYV] >SWXEĂ] SRI HSFVERI [ XEOM WTSW¶F EF] FE[MÊ WMÜ RMQM TV^I^ HĂYĺW^]
G^EW FI^ ^RYH^IRME [ĂEęGM[MI RMKH] RMI FYHYNÈG XIN WEQIN FYHS[PM H[E VE^]
3JIVXE HPE W^O·ă M TV^IHW^OSPM

7^YOEW^ TSQ]WĂY RE TV^ITVS[EH^IRMI OVIEX][R]GL ^ENÜÊ# 4V^]NHĸ ^ X[SNÈ KVYTÈ OPEWÈ
HS /PSGOS[RM M []OSV^]WXEN REW^I OPSGOM HS WX[SV^IRMI RMITS[XEV^EPR]GL ^ENÜÊ PIOGNM
Ê[MG^IRME QEĂIN QSXSV]OM OSRGIRXVEGNM TSHWXE[ QEXIQEX]OM Ŷ^]OM FMSPSKMM M GLIQMM PSKMOM
OVIEX][R]GL XIGLRMO XIEXVEPR]GL MXT (YĺS ^EPIĺ] SH 'MIFMI G^] H^MIGM TSOSGLENÈ XS G^IKS
YG^]W^ M NEO HEPIN FÜHE WMÜ VS^[MNEÊ 2MI ^QEVRYN XIN W^ERW] 2EW^ TIVWSRIP HSVEH^M 'M OX¶VÈ

WXVIJÜ []FVEÊ M NEO QSĺIW^ STX]QEPRMI ^SVKERM^S[EÊ ^ENÜGME

;EVW^E[E +EPIVME 6IRSZE TMÝXVS 4MSXVO·[ 8V]FYREPWOM +EPIVME *SGYW 1EPP
ZMW E ZMW ,ERIWYWLM TMÜXVS SFSO /MRE ,IPMSW
YP 6IQFMIPMĄWOE YP 7ĂS[EGOMIKS
;EVW^E[E 4MSXVO¶[ 8V]F

XIPIJSR XIPIJSR
I QEMP VIRSZE$OPSGOS[RME GSQ I QEMP TMSXVOS[$OPSGOS[RME GSQ










8IP
[[[ OPSGOS[RME GSQ





FMYVS$OPSGOS[RME GSQ





















1$6=( 35(0,(5<



,JQDÐ .LWHN DUFKLWHNW

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV

3U]H]DEDZQD L QLHSRNRUQD NVLÃ×ND

9Ü«ˆĂ¹« ôØãÊύ«Êô— ¼«ã—؁¹Ê R UHDOL]RZDQLX VZRLFK SDVML ZEUHZ
SU]HFLZQRÐFLRP



« Õ« ¹Ã«— «¼èÜãØÊôÃ— =É




5µ]LD 5HZHOND LQ×\QLHUND

1DV]H Z\GDZQLFWZR VSHFMDOL]XMH VLÇ Z VWDUDQQ\P GRERU]H RIHUW\ L SURSRQXMH $QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV
URG]LFRP L G]LHFLRP Z\VRNLHM MDNRÐFL NVLÃ×NL ]DUµZQR ZDUWRÐFLRZH OLWHUDFNR =DEDZQD L PÃGUD RSRZLHÐÅ R

MDN L SLÇNQLH LOXVWURZDQH 7R ìSLFWXUHERRNVë å NVLÃ×NL Z NWµU\FK WHNVW L REUD] UHDOL]RZDQLX SDVML L QLH]UD×DQLX
ZVSµÊJUDMà ]H VREà WZRU]ÃF XQLNDOQà MDNRÐÅ NWµUHM QLH GDÊRE\ VLÇ RVLÃJQÃÅ EH] VLÇ QLHSRZRG]HQLDPL
KDUPRQLL PLÇG]\ QLPL 6Ã WR SXEOLNDFMH GOD Z\PDJDMÃF\FK å SRXF]DMÃFD
L MHGQRF]HÐQLH HNVF\WXMÃFD OLWHUDWXUD G]LHFLÇFD =É








7HN 1RZRF]HVQ\ MDVNLQLRZLHF

3DWULFN 0F'RQQHOO


=DEDZQ\ VSRVµE PµZLHQLD R ]QDF]HQLX Z\ÊÃF]HQLD
RWDF]DMÃF\FK QDV XU]ÃG]HÌ L FLHV]HQLD VLÇ XURNDPL

SLÇNQHJR ÐZLDWD GRRNRÊD


=É


$GD %DPELQL 1DXNRZF]\QL

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV


=$32:,('Ô





#.LQGHUNXOND




:6=<67.,( .6,ÂÖ., '267Æ31( 1$ ::: .,1'(5.8/.$ 3/

1$6=( 35(0,(5<



,JQDÐ .LWHN DUFKLWHNW

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV

3U]H]DEDZQD L QLHSRNRUQD NVLÃ×ND

9Ü«ˆĂ¹« ôØãÊύ«Êô— ¼«ã—؁¹Ê R UHDOL]RZDQLX VZRLFK SDVML ZEUHZ
SU]HFLZQRÐFLRP



« Õ« ¹Ã«— «¼èÜãØÊôÃ— =É




5µ]LD 5HZHOND LQ×\QLHUND

1DV]H Z\GDZQLFWZR VSHFMDOL]XMH VLÇ Z VWDUDQQ\P GRERU]H RIHUW\ L SURSRQXMH $QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV
URG]LFRP L G]LHFLRP Z\VRNLHM MDNRÐFL NVLÃ×NL ]DUµZQR ZDUWRÐFLRZH OLWHUDFNR =DEDZQD L PÃGUD RSRZLHÐÅ R

MDN L SLÇNQLH LOXVWURZDQH 7R ìSLFWXUHERRNVë å NVLÃ×NL Z NWµU\FK WHNVW L REUD] UHDOL]RZDQLX SDVML L QLH]UD×DQLX
ZVSµÊJUDMà ]H VREà WZRU]ÃF XQLNDOQà MDNRÐÅ NWµUHM QLH GDÊRE\ VLÇ RVLÃJQÃÅ EH] VLÇ QLHSRZRG]HQLDPL
KDUPRQLL PLÇG]\ QLPL 6Ã WR SXEOLNDFMH GOD Z\PDJDMÃF\FK å SRXF]DMÃFD
L MHGQRF]HÐQLH HNVF\WXMÃFD OLWHUDWXUD G]LHFLÇFD =É








7HN 1RZRF]HVQ\ MDVNLQLRZLHF

3DWULFN 0F'RQQHOO


=DEDZQ\ VSRVµE PµZLHQLD R ]QDF]HQLX Z\ÊÃF]HQLD
RWDF]DMÃF\FK QDV XU]ÃG]HÌ L FLHV]HQLD VLÇ XURNDPL

SLÇNQHJR ÐZLDWD GRRNRÊD


=É


$GD %DPELQL 1DXNRZF]\QL

$QGUHD %HDW\ LOXVWUDWRU 'DYLG 5REHUWV


=$32:,('Ô





#.LQGHUNXOND




:6=<67.,( .6,ÂÖ., '267Æ31( 1$ ::: .,1'(5.8/.$ 3/







=GURZH VWRS\ 'R SURGXNFML REXZLD 0HPR VWRVR

ZDQH VĈ QDMZ\İV]HM MDNRĤFL PDWHULDã\ :LHU
G]LHFND ]FKQLD L ZHZQčWU]QD F]čĤþ EXWD Z\NRQDQD
MHVW ] QDWXUDOQ\FK PLčNNLFK VNyU NR]LFK
LGHDOQ\FK GOD VWRS\ G]LHFND 6NyU\ WH Z
VSRVyE QDWXUDOQ\ GRVWRVRZXMĈ VLč GR
0HPR WR QDMZ\İV]HM MDNRĤFL REXZLH GOD
G]LHFL Z\NRQDQH Z NODV\F]Q\P VW\OX ] VWRS\ W\P VDP\P ]ZLčNV]DMĈ NRPIRUW Xİ\W
QDWXUDOQ\FK PDWHULDãyZ SU]\MD]Q\FK VWRSLH NRZDQLD 1LHNWyUH PRGHOH Z\SRVDİRQH
G]LHFND 8QLNDWRZĈ IXQNFMč GLDJQRVW\F]QĈ ]RVWDã\ Z VSHFMDOLVW\F]QĈ SRGV]HZNč
]DSHZQLD V\VWHP PRQLWRULQJX Z SRGHV]ZLH EH]FKURPRZĈ 1DWXUDOQH PDWHULDã\ R
0HPR :\SUDFRZDQD SU]H] ODWD NRQVWUXN ZãDĤFLZRĤFLDFK KLJURVNRSLMQ\FK VSUDZLDMĈ
FMD L WHFKQRORJLD PRQWDİX EXWyZ 0HPR İH EXW RGG\FKD D VWRSD QLH XOHJD
] ]DSRFHQLX
]\VNDãD\VNDãD X]QDQLH VSHFMDOLVWyZ MDNR
VNXWHF]QD PHWRGD SURILODNW\NL L OHF]HQLD
QDMF]čVWV]\FK ZDG SRVWDZ\









8QLNDWRZ\ V\VWHP G\QDPLF]QHM NRQWUROL
VWyS G]LHFND GDMĈF\ PRİOLZRĤþ ELHİĈFHJR
PRQLWRURZDQLD VWDQX VWyS RUD] QDW\FKPLD
VWRZHM UHDNFML 6SHFMDOQ\ RGVWDZLRQ\ NV]
WDãW SRGHV]Z\ GRGDWNRZR VWDELOL]XMH VWRSč
L ]DSHZQLD SUDZLGãRZH MHM XãRİHQLH SRG 6SHFMDOQD WHFKQRORJLD PRQWDİX
F]DV FKRGX 'LDJQRVW\F]QD SRGHV]ZD 9 WHFK SROHJDMĈFD QD SUDZLGãRZ\P XVW
0HPR 2EV]DUHP GLDJQRVW\F]Q\P REXZLD DZLHQLX FKROHZNL SRGF]DV SURFHVX PRQ
0HPR MHVW MHJR SRGHV]ZD 1D MHM SRZLHU WRZDQLD EXWD 7HFKQRORJLD WD JZDUDQWXMH
]FKQL RUD] QD REFDVLH ]RVWDãR Z\RGUčEQL ]DFKRZDQLH RVL V\PHWULL Z Z\SURGXNRZ
RQ\FK V]HĤþ SRQXPHURZDQ\FK VWUHI ] Z\ DQ\P EXFLH D W\P VDP\P ZUD] ] FKDUDNW
SXNã\PL SDVNDPL ELHİQLND VWUHID QRUP\ HU\VW\F]Q\P V]W\ZQ\P ]DSLčWNLHP L Z\VRNĈ
VWUHID U\]\ND RUD] F]WHU\ VWUHI\ GXİHM G\V FKROHZNĈ ZVSRPDJD SUDZLGãRZ\ UR]ZyM
IXQNFML 3RGF]DV Xİ\WNRZDQLD SDVNL XOHJDMĈ VWyS 2EXZLH 0HPR SR]EDZLRQH MHVW FHFK
ĤFLHUDQLX G]LčNL F]HPX VWDUWH IUDJPHQW\ NRQVWUXNF\MQ\FK PRJĈF\FK ]DNãyFLþ
XPRİOLZLDMĈ V]\ENĈ L SUHF\]\MQĈ GLDJQR]č REUD] U]HF]\ZLVWHM IL]MRORJLL L SRWU]HE VWyS Z
ZDG VWyS RUD] HZHQWXDOQH GREUDQLH RNUHVLH Z]UDVWDQLD ']LčNL WHPX REXZLH
ZNãDGHN : SU]\SDGNX EUDNX NRQLHF]QRĤFL 0HPR XMDZQLD LFK SUDZLGãRZRĤþ PRUIR
VWRVRZDQLD ZNãDGHN NRU\JXMĈF\FK EXW\ ORJLF]QRF]\QQRĤFLRZĈ OXE LVWQLHMĈFH
0HPR VSHãQLDMĈ IXQNFMč SURILODNW\F]QĈ ZDG\ EĈGĮ LFK V\PSWRP\
=HVWDZ ZNãDGHN ZFKRG]ĈF\FK Z VNãDG
V\VWHPX\VWHPX 0HPR ZUD] ] ZEXGRZDQ\P Z
V 3URGXNW X]\VNDã SR]\W\ZQĈ RSLQLč
SRGHV]ZLH REFDVHP 7KRPDV·D QDGDMH Å&HQWUXP =GURZLD ']LHFNDµ
EXWRP 0HPR FKDUDNWHU REXZLD NRUHNF\M
QHJR 2GSRZLHGQLD GOD G]LHFND ZNãDGND
PRİH E\þ GREUDQD EH]SRĤUHGQLR SU]H]
URG]LFD QD SRGVWDZLH ]DãĈF]RQHM LQVWUXNFML
Xİ\WNRZDQLD 6\VWHPX 0HPR OXE ZJ ZVND
]Dę VSHFMDOLVW\




ZZZ ]GURZHEXFLNL SO