MP FotoKsiazka

ZZZ SROWH[W SO



VHNUHWDULDW#SROWH[W SO




']LHFNR F]\ PXV]H &L WR
MHV]F]H UD] SRZWDU]DÅ" PLQXW XZD×QRÐFL

3U]HÊRPRZ\ SURJUDP G]LÇNL NWµUHPX WZRMH G]LHFL EÇGÃ FLÇ VÊXFKDÊ\ EH]
QDSRPLQDQLD SU]\SRPLQDQLD OXE NU]\F]HQLD -DN SRPµF G]LHFLRP UDG]LÅ VRELH ]H VWUHVHP L VWUDFKHP



3URVLV] G]LHFNR E\ Z\ÊÃF]\ÊR WHOHZL]MÇ RGURELÊR OHNFMH VSDNRZDÊR VLÇ GR V]NRÊ\ OXE :LHOROHWQLH ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLH SUDNW\NRZDQLHP ÐZLDGRPHM WURVNL RUD] ]DDQJD×RZDQLH QD
SRV]ÊR VSDÅ :LHV] ×H VÊ\V]\ FR PµZLV] OHF] LJQRUXMH WR 3URVLV] SRQRZQLH Lð QDGDO U]HF] GREURVWDQX G]LHFL VNÊRQLÊR *ROGLH +DZQ GR ]DÊR×HQLD +DZQ )RXQGDWLRQ NWµUD ZVSLHUD
EUDN UHDNFML 3UµERZDÊHÐ MX× ZV]\VWNLHJR OHF] ×DGQD ] W\FK PHWRG QLH G]LDÊD =QDV] WR EDGDQLD QDXNRZH VÊX×ÃFH UR]ZLMDQLX VSRVREµZ SRPDJDQLD G]LHFLRP Z RGQDMG\ZDQLX
SUDZGD" V]F]ÇÐFLD L SRSUDZLDQLX Z\QLNµZ Z QDXFH RUD] Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQLX ZÊDVQHJR SRWHQFMDÊX
2SUDFRZDQ\ SU]H] IXQGDFMÇ SURJUDP 0LQG83 UHDOL]RZDQ\ SU]H] QDXF]\FLHOL ] FDÊHJR ÐZLDWD
(
(NVSHUWND GV ZNVSHUWND GV Z\FKRZDQLD $P\ 0F&UHDG\ RUJDQL]DWRUND NXUVµZ 3RVLWLYH 3DUHQWLQJ VÊX×\ SU]HND]\ZDQLX G]LHFLRP ZLHG]\ QD WHPDW IXQNFMRQRZDQLD Pµ]JX RUD] WHJR MDN P\ÐOL
6ROXWLRQV 3R]\W\ZQH PHWRG\ Z\FKRZ\ZDQLD G]LHFL SU]HGVWDZLD PHWRGÇ NWµUD L XF]XFLD ZSÊ\ZDMÃ QD ]DFKRZDQLH 3URJUDP WHQ GDMH G]LHFLRP QDU]ÇG]LD VSRÊHF]QH
HOLPLQXMH ZLHORNURWQH SRZWDU]DQLH WHJR VDPHJR OXE NU]\F]HQLH QD G]LHFL 3URSRQXMH L
L HPRFMRQDOQH XÊDWZLDMÃFH HPRFMRQDOQH XÊDWZLDMÃFH UDG]HQLH VRELH ]H VWUHVHP L QHJDW\ZQ\PL XF]XFLDPL
UR]ZLÃ]DQLD SHÊQH PLÊRÐFL L MHGQRF]HÐQLH QLH]Z\NOH VNXWHF]QH MH×HOL FKRG]L R XPR×OLZLDMÃFH Z\FLV]HQLH XP\VÊX XWU]\PDQLH VNXSLHQLD RUD] UR]ZLMDQLH ZVSµÊF]XFLD
VNÊDQLDQLH G]LHFL GR SR×ÃGDQ\FK ]DFKRZDÌ L HPSDWLL å D Z RVWDWHF]Q\P UR]UDFKXQNX RVLÃJQLÇFLH V]F]ÇÐFLD


VWURQ VWURQ
,6%1 ,6%1


IRUPDW [ PP ]Ê IRUPDW [ PP ]Ê
RSUDZD PLÇNND ]H VNU]\GHÊNDPL RSUDZD PLÇNND
$P\ 0F&UHDG\ *ROGLH +DZQ :HQG\ +ROGHQ

2 RGSRUQRÐFL 6]F]HSLÅ F]\
QLH V]F]HSLÅ G]LHFL" , FDQ VLQJ LQ (QJOLVK

6]F]HSLÅ QLH V]F]HSLÅ" 2WR MHVW S\WDQLH
)DNW\ SORWNL L G\OHPDW\ GRW\F]ÃFH V]F]HSLHQLD G]LHFL ÏSLHZDM L SR]QDM NOXF]RZH VÊRZD SR DQJLHOVNX .VLÃ×ND ] SÊ\Wà &'

ì1LH PD ZLÇNV]HJR U\]\ND QL× SRVLDGDQLH G]LHFLë å WD VWDUD SUDZGD ZH ZVSµÊF]HVQ\P .VLÃ×ND ]XSHÊQLH LQQD QL× SR]RVWDÊH
ÐZLHFLH ]\VNXMH FLÃJOH QRZH REOLF]D :V]\VF\ XVLÊXMHP\ RFKURQLÅ QDV]H G]LHFL SU]HG ï QDSLVDQD ]DUµZQR SR SROVNX L DQJLHOVNX NODURZQLH Z\MDÐQLD Z MDNL VSRVµE NRU]\VWDÅ ]
]DJUR×HQLDPL ]DSHZQLÅ LP ]GURZH EH]WURVNLH G]LHFLÌVWZR L V]F]ÇÐOLZà SU]\V]ÊRÐÅ ND×GHM SLRVHQNL SRQDGWR ]DZLHUD V]F]HJµÊ\ WDNLH MDN OLF]ED VʵZ ]HVWDZ VÊRZQLFWZD VÊRZD
-HGQDN QLH VSRVµE V]F]HOQLH RGJURG]LÅ LFK RG ÐZLDWD L ZV]HONLFK Z\]ZDÌ NWµUH QLHVLH NOXF]RZH X×\WH Z GDQHM SLRVHQFH RUD] GRGDWNRZH ÅZLF]HQLD X]XSHÊQLDMÃFH
ï
]H VREà ×\FLH 7D ÐZLDGRPRÐÅ VSUDZLD ×H QLHXVWDQQLH WDUJDMà QDPL Uµ×QH ZÃWSOLZRÐFL ï NVLÃ×ND S NVLÃ×ND SUDNW\F]QD ] NWµUHM NRU]\VWDÅ PRJà ]DUµZQR G]LHFL URG]LFH D QDZHW G]LDGNRZLH QD
1LH PR×HP\ SU]HZLG]LHÅ ZV]\VWNLHJR F]DVHP QLH XPLHP\ RFHQLÅ NRQVHNZHQFML UµZQL ] QDXF]\FLHODPL L Z\FKRZDZFDPL .VLÃ×ND MHVW QD W\OH SU]\VWÇSQD GOD ZV]\VWNLFK L×
VZRLFK Z\ERUµZ L G]LDÊDÌ D QLHNLHG\ SR]ZDODP\ VREÃ PDQLSXORZDÅ 'RW\F]\ WR WDN×H PR×QD SURPRZDÅ MÃ KDVÊHP QS ì 8F] VLÇ DQJLHOVNLHJR ] G]LDGNLHPë
N ï SU]H]QDF]RQD MHVW GOD ÐFLÐOH RNUHÐORQHM JUXS\ ZLHNRZHM G]LHFL Z ZLHNX ODW .D×GD LQQD
NZHVWLL WDN SRZD×QHM MDN SRGZHVWLL WDN SRZD×QHM MDN SRGDZDQLH G]LHFLRP V]F]HSLRQHN
NVLÃ×ND R SRGREQHM WHPDW\FH ]DZLHUD QLHMDVQà FKDUDNWHU\VW\NÇ ìGOD QDMPÊRGV]\FKë

VWURQ VWURQ
,6%1 ,6%1

IRUPDW [ PP ]Ê IRUPDW [ PP ]Ê
RSUDZD PLÇNND RSUDZD PLÇNND
(XOD %LVV 7HUHQFH &ODUN :DUG



3$7521, 0(',$/1,




0*3 /3 .2' 835$:1,$-Â&< '2 =1,Ö., 1$ 35(=(172:$1( : 5(./$0,( .6,ÂÖ., :$Ö1< 5
.RG UDEDWRZ\ ZSLV] Z NRV]\NX SU]\ ]DNXSLH NVLÃ×NL QD VWURQLH ZZZ ODXUXP SO L ZZZ SROWH[W SO

ZZZ SROWH[W SO



VHNUHWDULDW#SROWH[W SO




']LHFNR F]\ PXV]H &L WR
MHV]F]H UD] SRZWDU]DÅ" PLQXW XZD×QRÐFL

3U]HÊRPRZ\ SURJUDP G]LÇNL NWµUHPX WZRMH G]LHFL EÇGÃ FLÇ VÊXFKDÊ\ EH]
QDSRPLQDQLD SU]\SRPLQDQLD OXE NU]\F]HQLD -DN SRPµF G]LHFLRP UDG]LÅ VRELH ]H VWUHVHP L VWUDFKHP



3URVLV] G]LHFNR E\ Z\ÊÃF]\ÊR WHOHZL]MÇ RGURELÊR OHNFMH VSDNRZDÊR VLÇ GR V]NRÊ\ OXE :LHOROHWQLH ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLH SUDNW\NRZDQLHP ÐZLDGRPHM WURVNL RUD] ]DDQJD×RZDQLH QD
SRV]ÊR VSDÅ :LHV] ×H VÊ\V]\ FR PµZLV] OHF] LJQRUXMH WR 3URVLV] SRQRZQLH Lð QDGDO U]HF] GREURVWDQX G]LHFL VNÊRQLÊR *ROGLH +DZQ GR ]DÊR×HQLD +DZQ )RXQGDWLRQ NWµUD ZVSLHUD
EUDN UHDNFML 3UµERZDÊHÐ MX× ZV]\VWNLHJR OHF] ×DGQD ] W\FK PHWRG QLH G]LDÊD =QDV] WR EDGDQLD QDXNRZH VÊX×ÃFH UR]ZLMDQLX VSRVREµZ SRPDJDQLD G]LHFLRP Z RGQDMG\ZDQLX
SUDZGD" V]F]ÇÐFLD L SRSUDZLDQLX Z\QLNµZ Z QDXFH RUD] Z\NRU]\VW\ZDQLX ZÊDVQHJR SRWHQFMDÊX
2SUDFRZDQ\ SU]H] IXQGDFMÇ SURJUDP 0LQG83 UHDOL]RZDQ\ SU]H] QDXF]\FLHOL ] FDÊHJR ÐZLDWD
(NVSHUWND GV ZNVSHUWND GV Z\FKRZDQLD $P\ 0F&UHDG\ RUJDQL]DWRUND NXUVµZ 3RVLWLYH 3DUHQWLQJ
( VÊX×\ SU]HND]\ZDQLX G]LHFLRP ZLHG]\ QD WHPDW IXQNFMRQRZDQLD Pµ]JX RUD] WHJR MDN P\ÐOL
6ROXWLRQV 3R]\W\ZQH PHWRG\ Z\FKRZ\ZDQLD G]LHFL SU]HGVWDZLD PHWRGÇ NWµUD L XF]XFLD ZSÊ\ZDMÃ QD ]DFKRZDQLH 3URJUDP WHQ GDMH G]LHFLRP QDU]ÇG]LD VSRÊHF]QH
HOLPLQXMH ZLHORNURWQH SRZWDU]DQLH WHJR VDPHJR OXE NU]\F]HQLH QD G]LHFL 3URSRQXMH L
L HPRFMRQDOQH XÊDWZLDMÃFH HPRFMRQDOQH XÊDWZLDMÃFH UDG]HQLH VRELH ]H VWUHVHP L QHJDW\ZQ\PL XF]XFLDPL
UR]ZLÃ]DQLD SHÊQH PLÊRÐFL L MHGQRF]HÐQLH QLH]Z\NOH VNXWHF]QH MH×HOL FKRG]L R XPR×OLZLDMÃFH Z\FLV]HQLH XP\VÊX XWU]\PDQLH VNXSLHQLD RUD] UR]ZLMDQLH ZVSµÊF]XFLD
VNÊDQLDQLH G]LHFL GR SR×ÃGDQ\FK ]DFKRZDÌ L HPSDWLL å D Z RVWDWHF]Q\P UR]UDFKXQNX RVLÃJQLÇFLH V]F]ÇÐFLD


VWURQ VWURQ
,6%1 ,6%1


IRUPDW [ PP ]Ê IRUPDW [ PP ]Ê
RSUDZD PLÇNND ]H VNU]\GHÊNDPL RSUDZD PLÇNND
$P\ 0F&UHDG\ *ROGLH +DZQ :HQG\ +ROGHQ

2 RGSRUQRÐFL 6]F]HSLÅ F]\
QLH V]F]HSLÅ G]LHFL" , FDQ VLQJ LQ (QJOLVK

6]F]HSLÅ QLH V]F]HSLÅ" 2WR MHVW S\WDQLH
)DNW\ SORWNL L G\OHPDW\ GRW\F]ÃFH V]F]HSLHQLD G]LHFL ÏSLHZDM L SR]QDM NOXF]RZH VÊRZD SR DQJLHOVNX .VLÃ×ND ] SÊ\Wà &'

ì1LH PD ZLÇNV]HJR U\]\ND QL× SRVLDGDQLH G]LHFLë å WD VWDUD SUDZGD ZH ZVSµÊF]HVQ\P .VLÃ×ND ]XSHÊQLH LQQD QL× SR]RVWDÊH
ÐZLHFLH ]\VNXMH FLÃJOH QRZH REOLF]D :V]\VF\ XVLÊXMHP\ RFKURQLÅ QDV]H G]LHFL SU]HG ï QDSLVDQD ]DUµZQR SR SROVNX L DQJLHOVNX NODURZQLH Z\MDÐQLD Z MDNL VSRVµE NRU]\VWDÅ ]
]DJUR×HQLDPL ]DSHZQLÅ LP ]GURZH EH]WURVNLH G]LHFLÌVWZR L V]F]ÇÐOLZà SU]\V]ÊRÐÅ ND×GHM SLRVHQNL SRQDGWR ]DZLHUD V]F]HJµÊ\ WDNLH MDN OLF]ED VʵZ ]HVWDZ VÊRZQLFWZD VÊRZD
-HGQDN QLH VSRVµE V]F]HOQLH RGJURG]LÅ LFK RG ÐZLDWD L ZV]HONLFK Z\]ZDÌ NWµUH QLHVLH NOXF]RZH X×\WH Z GDQHM SLRVHQFH RUD] GRGDWNRZH ÅZLF]HQLD X]XSHÊQLDMÃFH
ï
]H VREà ×\FLH 7D ÐZLDGRPRÐÅ VSUDZLD ×H QLHXVWDQQLH WDUJDMà QDPL Uµ×QH ZÃWSOLZRÐFL ï NVLÃ×ND S NVLÃ×ND SUDNW\F]QD ] NWµUHM NRU]\VWDÅ PRJà ]DUµZQR G]LHFL URG]LFH D QDZHW G]LDGNRZLH QD
1LH PR×HP\ SU]HZLG]LHÅ ZV]\VWNLHJR F]DVHP QLH XPLHP\ RFHQLÅ NRQVHNZHQFML UµZQL ] QDXF]\FLHODPL L Z\FKRZDZFDPL .VLÃ×ND MHVW QD W\OH SU]\VWÇSQD GOD ZV]\VWNLFK L×
VZRLFK Z\ERUµZ L G]LDÊDÌ D QLHNLHG\ SR]ZDODP\ VREÃ PDQLSXORZDÅ 'RW\F]\ WR WDN×H PR×QD SURPRZDÅ MÃ KDVÊHP QS ì 8F] VLÇ DQJLHOVNLHJR ] G]LDGNLHPë
N ï SU]H]QDF]RQD MHVW GOD ÐFLÐOH RNUHÐORQHM JUXS\ ZLHNRZHM G]LHFL Z ZLHNX ODW .D×GD LQQD
NZHVWLL WDN SRZD×QHM MDN SRGZHVWLL WDN SRZD×QHM MDN SRGDZDQLH G]LHFLRP V]F]HSLRQHN
NVLÃ×ND R SRGREQHM WHPDW\FH ]DZLHUD QLHMDVQà FKDUDNWHU\VW\NÇ ìGOD QDMPÊRGV]\FKë

VWURQ VWURQ
,6%1 ,6%1

IRUPDW [ PP ]Ê IRUPDW [ PP ]Ê
RSUDZD PLÇNND RSUDZD PLÇNND
(XOD %LVV 7HUHQFH &ODUN :DUG



3$7521, 0(',$/1,




0*3 /3 .2' 835$:1,$-Â&< '2 =1,Ö., 1$ 35(=(172:$1( : 5(./$0,( .6,ÂÖ., :$Ö1< 5
.RG UDEDWRZ\ ZSLV] Z NRV]\NX SU]\ ]DNXSLH NVLÃ×NL QD VWURQLH ZZZ ODXUXP SO L ZZZ SROWH[W SO

















7SPM OPSGO¾[ RMI WTSW¾F TV^IGIRMÔ /Yŏ SH RENQēSHW^]GL PEX VS^[MNENÒ SRI
H^MIGMéGÒ []SFVEōRMé OVIEX][RSĮÔ X[¾VG^I M PSKMG^RI Q]ĮPIRMI YG^Ò
XV¾N[]QMEVS[IKS WTSNV^IRME RE Į[MEX E GS REN[EŏRMINW^I VS^[MNENÒ
^HSPRSĮGM QERYEPRI XEO RMIHSGIRMERI SFIGRMI [ Į[MIGMI
[W^IGLSFIGR]GL OSQTYXIV¾[ M WQEVXJSR¾[ ;WT¾PRE ^EFE[E
^ V¾[MIĮRMOEQM G^] XIŏ ^ VSH^MGEQM XS TMéORI M W^G^éĮPM[I GL[MPI [ G^EWMI
OX¾V]GL [ REXYVEPR] WTSW¾F VS^[MNEQ] ^HSPRSĮGM OSQYRMOEG]NRI SVE^
ŏ]GMI WTSēIG^RI M VSH^MRRI [Mé^] )S XIKS WTV^IHE[ERI TV^I^ REW OPSGOM
ŏ
GIGLYNI REN[]ŏW^E IYVSTINWOE NEOSĮÔ SVE^ RSVQ] ^ETI[RMENÒGI
FI^TMIG^IĕWX[S H^MIGM 3E [W^]WXOMI T]XERMI ^ QMēÒ GLéGMÒ SHTS[MIQ]
QEMPS[S ^ETVEW^EQ]



>EQ¾[ SRPMRI PYF OYT SWSFMĮGMI [ WEPSRMI

0438&08
,EPIVME 9VW]R¾[ WXEGNE QIXVE 3EXSPMR
&P 0*3 PSO 9 TMéXVS



8IP OSQ XIP
I QEMP WOPIT%[]FMIV^ OPSGOM TP

[[[ []FMIV^ OPSGOM TP










































;]FMIV^ OPSGOMƾ



FS OPSGOM OSPIKS WÒ HPE OEŏHIKS

,ē¾[RÒ ^EPIXÒ G]TV]NWOMGL OPSGO¾[ )b:Fbjŷ NIWX YQSŏPM[MIRMI H^MIGMSQ W^]FOMIKS M ēEX[IKS FYHS[ERME
TVSWX]GL PYF ^ēSŏSR]GL QSHIPM TV^] Yŏ]GMY FEVH^S QEēIN PMG^F] V¾ŏR]GL OSQTSRIRX¾[ ]WXIQ ^SWXEē
[]REPI^MSR] TV^I^ F]ēIKS REYG^]GMIPE M MRŏ]RMIVE OX¾V] GLGMEē [W^G^ITMÔ YG^RMSQ TEWNI HS XIGLRMOM +MVQE
VS^[MNE W[SNI TVSHYOX] RE FE^MI ^EXV^EWOS[]GL OSQTSRIRX¾[ VS^[MNENÒG NI S TV^IOēEHRMI OSēE TEWS[I
WMPRMG^OM G^] TERIPI WēSRIG^RI .RWXVYOGNI FYHS[] HSWXéTRI WÒ [ MRXIVEOX][RIN ETPMOEGNM RE WXVSRMI
TVSHYGIRXE TSQEKENÒG H^MIGMSQ [INĮÔ [ MRXIVEOGNI ^ XIGLRSPSKMÒ M YG^]Ô TSTV^I^ ^EFE[é 5VSHYOX]
WOMIVS[ERI HPE H^MIGM SH PEX


ƒˆ)`LjƀƉz~ ›jƉb)›ˆjb Ɖ )«›_ %bj… ØƉz4%

)^MéOM ^IWXE[S[M ). (4:*7.3, 8*2 5VE[E 3I[XSRE Ƴ FI^[ēEHRSĮÔ
TéH IRIVKME OMRIX]G^RE M TSXIRGNEPRE H^MIGM QENÒ QSŏPM[SĮÔ TS^RERME
TSHWXE[ QIGLERMOM OPEW]G^RIN ^[ERIN RI[XSRS[WOÒ OX¾VE STMWYNI
[MéOW^SĮÔ ^RER]GL REQ ^NE[MWO WTSX]OER]GL [ GSH^MIRR]Q ŏ]GMY
IOWTIV]QIRX¾[ ^ IRIVKMÒ OMRIX]G^RÒ M TSXIRGNEPRÒ SVE^ MGL [ēEĮGM[SĮGM
NEO IRIVKME TSXIRGNEPRE ^QMIRME WMé [ OMRIX]G^RÒ M RE SH[V¾X


ŎƖĿ ƉzXb
ĿĿ



ĂLjƐLjƉFb™)bˆj~ƉĂLjƉ`j%)XƒƉ`jˆj~F«)%Ɖƒ)ˆ

>EE[ERWS[ERE PMRME .3:*3847 24847.>*) XS ^IWXE[] OPSGO¾[
[]TSWEŏSRI [ WMPRMG^IO IPIOXV]G^R] HS RETéHY MGL IPIQIRX¾[
VYGLSQ]GL 5S[]ŏW^] ^IWXE[ YQSŏPM[ME ^FYHS[ERMI V¾ŏR]GL
QSHIPM .3:*3847 XS OPSGOM []WSOMIN NEOSĮGM ^ OEXIKSVMM IHYOEG]NR]GL
OSRWXVYOG]NRS MRŏ]RMIV]NR]GL OX¾VI ēÒG^Ò WMé [ OEŏHIN TēEW^G^]ōRMI
) GS WTVE[ME ŏI WÒ YRMOEXS[I


ƖƖĿ ƉzXb
ĿĿ


ŎƅƐŎƉFb™)bˆj~ƉŎƅƉ`j%)XƒƉ ~ƒ


.3:*3847 QSHIPM WEQSGLSH¾[ XS ^IWXE[ OPSGO¾[ []WSOMIN NEOSĮGM
^ OEXIKSVMM IHYOEG]NR]GL OSRWXVYOG]NRS MRŏ]RMIV]NR]GL YQSŏPM[MENÒG]
^FYHS[ERMI QSHIPM TSNE^H¾[ M ēÒG^IRME IPIQIRX¾[ [ OEŏHIN TēEW^G^]ōRMI
) TV^I^ GS OPSGOM WÒ YRMOEXS[I 5SHWXE[S[E PMRME .3:*3847 XS ^IWXE[]
H^MéOM OX¾V]Q MWXRMINI QSŏPM[SĮÔ ^FYHS[ERME SH HS QSHIPM ^IWXE[]
XIQEX]G^RI WEQSGLSH] WEQSPSX] QSXSG]OPI TSNE^H] WTIGNEPRI

ŎƐĿ ƉzXb
ĿĿ



LjíƐĉƉFb™)bˆj~ƉíƉ`j%)XƒƉFb%ƒˆ~F X


.3:*3847 QSHIPM TSNE^H¾[ WTIGNEPR]GL XS ^IWXE[
OPSGO¾[ []WSOMIN NEOSĮGM ^ OEXIKSVMM IHYOEG]NR]GL
OSRWXVYOG]NRS MRŏ]RMIV]NR]GL YQSŏPM[MENÒG] ^FYHS[ERMI
QSHIPM TSNE^H¾[ M ēÒG^IRME IPIQIRX¾[ [ OEŏHIN TēEW^G^]ōRMI
) TV^I^ GS OPSGOM WÒ YRMOEXS[I



ƅĉ ƉzXb
ĿĿ

:)j` :ƕ XS W^[ENGEVWOM TVSHYGIRX OPSGO¾[ QEKRIX]G^R]GL 8E RMI^[]OPI TVSWXE ^EFE[OE WOēEHE WMé Kē¾[RMI ^
RMOPS[ER]GL OYPIO SVE^ TPEWXMOS[]GL TVéGMO¾[ [ [I[RÒXV^ OX¾V]GL ^RENHYNÒ WMé H[E QEKRIW] ĒÒG^ÒG ^I WSFÒ XI H[E
IPIQIRX] QSŏRE ^FYHS[EÔ FEVH^S HYŏS V¾ŏR]GL KISQIXV]G^R]GL ǻKYV SVE^ MRR]GL WXVYOXYV ) M ) )SHEXOS[]Q
IPIQIRXIQ ^EFE[OM WÒ TERIPI WēYŏÒGI HS YW^X][RMIRME OSRWXVYOGNM )^MéOM QSŏPM[SĮGM ēEX[IKS ^FYHS[ERME M
VS^IFVERME FYHS[PM W]WXIQ VS^[MNE []SFVEōRMé M NIWX TSQSGR] HS REYOM ^EKEHRMIĕ QEXIQEX]G^R]GL ǻ^]G^R]GL
GLIQMG^R]GL SVE^ VS^[MNE OVIEX][RSĮÔ H^MIGOE 5VSHYOX] HIH]OS[ERI H^MIGMSQ TS[]ŏIN VSOY ŏ]GME


:)jěƖĂĂƉ jXj~ƉŎƖLjƉ)Xţ

,ISQEK XS [WTERMEēE ^EFE[OE IHYOEG]NRE STEVXE RE TSēÒG^IRMY
ǻ^]G^R]GL [ēEĮGM[SĮGM QEKRIWY M W^[ENGEVWOMIN MRRS[EG]NRSĮGM ĒÒG^ÒG
QEKRIX]G^RI TEēIG^OM ^ RMOPS[ER]QM OYPOEQM QSŏIQ] [ FEVH^S TVSWX]
WTSW¾F FYHS[EÔ XV¾N[]QMEVS[I SFMIOX] M TV^IHQMSX]


ŎĿĿ ƉzXb
ĿĿ




:)jěƀƖƖƉ`) B bF ƒƉŎĉƅƉ)Xţ

,ISQEK XS [WTERMEēE ^EFE[OE IHYOEG]NRE STEVXE RE TSēÒG^IRMY ǻ^]G^R]GL
[ēEĮGM[SĮGM QEKRIWY M W^[ENGEVWOMIN MRRS[EG]NRSĮGM ĒÒG^ÒG QEKRIX]G^RI
TEēIG^OM ^ RMOPS[ER]QM OYPOEQM SVE^ TERIPEQM QSŏIQ] [ FEVH^S TVSWX]
WTSW¾F FYHS[EÔ XV¾N[]QMEVS[I SFMIOX] M TV^IHQMSX] /IH]R]Q
SKVERMG^IRMIQ NIWX XY REW^E [ēEWRE JERXE^NE M MPSĮÔ IPIQIRX¾[


ŎíĿ ƉzXb
ĿĿ

5VSHYOX¾[ HYĕWOMIN ǻVQ] X):jŷ TV^IHWXE[MEÔ GL]FE RMOSQY RMI XV^IFE ;EVXS NIH]RMI ^E^REG^]Ô Mŏ TVSHYGIRX TSWMEHE
H[E RMI^EPIŏRI W]WXIQ] OPSGO¾[ )9514 HPE H^MIGM [ [MIOY PEX SVE^ 1*,4 ]WXIQ HPE H^MIGM SH VSOY ŏ]GME (S
GMIOE[I H[E TSHWXE[S[I OPSGOM 1*,4 ¡ QSŏRE TSēÒG^]Ô [ V¾ŏRI OSQFMREGNI > XV^IGL OPSGO¾[ MPSĮÔ OSQFMREGNM
[]RSWM NYŏ ^EĮ ^ W^IĮÔ IPIQIRX¾[ HENI QSŏPM[SĮÔ TSēÒG^IRME RE WTSWSF¾[ 4 OVIEX][RSĮÔ H^MIGM
QSŏIQ] [MéG F]Ô WTSOSNRM NIŏIPM HS XIKS HSHEQ] OMPOEREĮGMI V¾ŏR]GL WIVMM XIQEX]G^R]GL HSFVE ^EFE[E QYVS[ERE
ŎLjíƐƐƉ%zXjƉz~«)%ƒ«UjX)


>IWXE[] ^ WIVMM 2SNI QMEWXS 1*,4q )9514q TS^[EPE ^FYHS[EÔ
HSWOSREPI ^RERI SXSG^IRMI M SHKV][EÔ [ RMQ VIEPMWX]G^RI WGIROM
^ YH^MEēIQ RS[SG^IWR]GL ǻKYVIO )9514 8IR FEV[R] ^IWXE[ )9514
^EGLéGM QEPYGL] HS SHKV][ERME V¾ŏR]GL WGIRIO ^ MGL HRME ƴ SH ^EFE[]
RE QEGMI TV^I^ TSWMēOM M GSH^MIRRÒ XSEPIXé Eŏ TS WTV^ÒXERMI >EGLéÔ
H^MIGOS HS [GMIPERME WMé [ V¾ŏRI VSPI M WTVE[ F] W^]FGMIN TS^RE[EēS Į[MEX


ƀŎ ƉzXb
ĿĿ


ŎLjíĉíƉ%zXjƉ`jI)ƉzF)~›ƒ«)ƉUXj UF

8IR [WTERMEē] ^IWXE[ ^ []FSVIQ TSHWXE[S[]GL OPSGO¾[
1*,4q )9514q VS^TEPM []SFVEōRMé OEŏHIKS QEPYGLE M HE QY
[MIPI KSH^MR Į[MIXRIN ^EFE[] >E[EVXI [ X]Q ^IWXE[MI OPSGOM
SVE^ OEVX] ^ MRWXVYOGNEQM TS^[EPENÒ ^FYHS[EÔ [W^]WXOS GS X]POS
TSHWYRMI []SFVEōRME


ƀŎ ƉzXb
ĿĿ

{`¥‰UF ƐŎ ƉzXb
ĉĿ
Ukc„‰ŽU ¥Ic)

„¥„‰)aŽƉ
%zXjƉ47&>

X):jƉ

ĂƐ ƉzXb
ĿĿ

X ƒƒF Ɖ«)ƒˆ ›ƉU~) ˆ¤›b):jƉUjbƒˆ~Uˆj~

MéKRMN TS ^IWXE[ OVIEX][RIKS OSRWXVYOXSVE 1*,4q (PEWWMG
M [OVSG^ HS Į[MEXE RMG^]Q RMIWOVéTS[ERIN []SFVEōRM M TEWNM
X[SV^IRME /EWRI OSPSVS[I M YRM[IVWEPRI OPSGOM 1*,4
TSFYH^ENÒ []SFVEōRMé HS FYHS[ERME M ^EFE[]

íĿ ƉzXb
ĿĿ


~) ˆj~Ɖ~j jˆěj%U~¤›
8IR RMIWEQS[MX] QSHIP ^VSFM [VEŏIRMI RE 8[SMGL ^RENSQ]GL
7SFSXE SHOV][G] RMI WTSW¾F ^ RMOMQ TSQ]PMÔ /IWX FēéOMXRS G^EVRS W^EV]
QE NEWRS^MIPSRI SG^] H^MEēENÒGI KÒWMIRMGI SFVEGENÒGÒ WMé KēS[é M OSVTYW
E XEOŏI VYGLSQI VEQMSRE ^I W^TIVEG^IQ M H^MEēENÒG]Q GL[]XEOMIQ

ƀŎ ƉzXb
ĿĿ


IbFj~ƒƉ~j« Fm~U

,H^MI WMé ^ETSH^MEē XIR OEWO$ (^EW FVEÔ WMé HS VSFSX] RE TPEGY FYHS[]
1*,4q (MX] >IWXE[ ^E[MIVE ēEX[I HS ^FYHS[ERME TSNE^H] XEOMI NEO
[][VSXOE OSTEVOE ^ SFVSXS[]Q VEQMIRMIQ ^ X]ēY Hō[MK ^ OYPÒ
[]FYV^IRMS[Ò E HS XIKS FYH]RIO [ XVEOGMI FYHS[]

ŎƖĂ ƉzXb
ĿĿ


8~F)b%ƒƉ%jƒˆ › Ɖzj`FbUm›Ɖ›ƉB) ~ˆX U)

MéKRMN TS ^IWXE[ )SWXE[GE YTSQMRO¾[ [ -IEVXPEOI 1*,4q
+VMIRHW M TSQ¾ŏ XITLERMI HSWXEVG^]Ô TVI^IRX] ; TYHIēOY
^RENH^MIW^ WEQSGL¾H HSWXE[G^] M JVSRX WOPITY ^ QMINWGIQ RE
TVI^IRX] WOV^]ROÒ TSG^XS[Ò M OEWÒ

íLj ƉzXb
ĿĿ


Fˆ¤Ɖƒˆ~ ¯ UFƉ›m«Ɖˆ) BbF «b¤

&RXIRE WEXIPMXEVRE [ RMIFI^TMIG^IĕWX[MI 3E W^G^éĮGMI RE QMINWGI
TéH^M NYŏ WXVEŏEGOM [¾^ XIGLRMG^R] /IWX SR []TSWEŏSR] [ YRSW^SR]
M STYW^G^ER] []WMéKRMO RE TV^]G^ITMI WTIGNEPR] [Òŏ ^ []V^YXRMÒ
OPSGO¾[ [SH] KEĮRMGé WTV^éX SGLVSRR] M [MIPI MRR]GL EOGIWSVM¾[

ŎƐĉ ƉzXb
ĿĿ

.VLčJDUQLD LQWHUQHWRZD ]QDN FRP SO WR GREUH NVLĈİNL Z\ELWQL DXWRU]\
DWUDNF\MQH SURPRFMH V]\END GRVWDZD SU]HGVSU]HGDİH 1DV]Ĉ VLãĈ VĈ
QDVL NOLHQFL NWyU]\ GRFHQLDMĈ SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP DWUDNF\MQH FHQ\ RUD]

V]\ENĈ UHDOL]DFMč ]DPyZLHQLD
&2 2)(58-(0<"


‡ KLW\ Z\GDZQLF]H GRVWčSQH W\G]LHę ZF]HĤQLHM QLİ Z LQQ\FK NVLčJDUQLDFK
‡
‡ DWUDNF\MQH NRG\ UDEDWRZH DWUDNF\MQH NRG\ UDEDWRZH
‡ SURPRFMH FHQRZH



















































5DEDW RG FHQ\ RNãDGNRZHM ] NRGHP PDJD]\QSU]HGV]NROD












ZZZ ]QDN FRP SO

VNOHS#]QDN FRP SO

)DQQ\ -RO\
3UDOLQND


3UDOLQND L MHM URG]LQND 3R]QDMFLH $OLQNč 3UDOLQNč 1D FR G]LHę
MHVW VãRGND DOH NLHG\ WU]HED SRWUDIL WXSQĈþ QRJĈ 3ãDF]H QD HVW VãRGND DOH NLHG\ WU]HED SRWUDIL WXSQĈþ QRJĈ 3ãDF]H QD
M
]DZRãDQLH ĤSLHZD QD FDã\ JãRV L ]DNRFKXMH VLč QD ]DEyM«
=ãRĤOLZL VWDUVL EUDFLD" .ãRSRW\ Z V]NROH" :L]\WD %DUG]R :DİQ\FK
*RĤFL" = SRPRFĈ SU]\MDFLyãNL &HOLQ\ SOXV]RZHJR OZD *U\]DND
RUD] QDMIDMQLHMV]HJR FKãRSFD Z FDãHM V]NROH .U]\VLD 7UXIOL ²
3UDOLQND SRUDG]L VRELH ]H ZV]\VWNLP




3/1






)DQQ\ -RO\
3UDOLQND QLH GDMH ]D Z\JUDQĈ



7R ]QRZX MD $OLQND 7\ONR QLH QD]\ZDMFLH PQLH 3UD« 1LH ]QRV]č
WHJR : PRLP İ\FLX MDN ]Z\NOH GXİR VLč G]LHMH :\Sã\ZDP
] QLH]QRĤQ\PL EUDþPL Z QLHEH]SLHF]Q\ UHMV QD Z\ĤFLJL ]ELHUDP
QDNUčWNL RGNU\ZDP PLãRĤþ GR VZLQJD D QDZHW ]RVWDMč SUDZG]LZĈ
PX]Ĉ .U]\VLD 7UXIOL QDMIDMQLHMV]HJR FKãRSFD ] FDãHM V]NRã\ (FK OHFč
PXV]č WR GOD :DV V]\ENR VSLVDþ ER ]DUD] ]DSRPQč D MHV]F]H
F]HND QD PQLH WDEOLF]ND PQRİHQLD SU]H] VLHGHP« 'R ]REDF]HQLD




3/1






-LOO %DUNOHP
: -Hİ\QRZ\P *URG]LH


: -Hİ\QRZ\P *URG]LH UR]EU]PLHZDMĈ UDGRVQH SRSLVNLZDQLD
L WXSRW ãDSHN 0DãH P\V]NL XZLMDMĈ VLč E\ SU]\JRWRZDþ SU]\MčFLH
QLHVSRG]LDQNč GOD )UHG]LD SLNQLN QDG EU]HJLHP VWUXPLHQLD
1D WUDZLH S\V]QLĈ VLč MXİ NDQG\]RZDQH ILRãNL MDJRGRZD
OHJXPLQD FLDVWHF]ND SLHUZLRVQNRZH L KHUEDWD ] OLĤFL MHİ\Q
7\ONR JG]LH SRG]LDã VLč WRUW XURG]LQRZ\"«



3/1










_ ZZZ ]QDN FRP SO _ VNOHS#]QDN FRP SO

0LFKDHO %RQG
1RZH SU]\JRG\ 3DGGLQJWRQD


'OD PDãHJR QLHGĮZLDGND İ\FLH Z W\SRZ\P DQJLHOVNLP GRPX VWDQRZL
ĮUyGãR QLHXVWDQQ\FK SHU\SHWLL &]\ SRUDG]L VRELH ] NRV]HQLHP
WUDZQLND" -DN ]DFKRZD VLč QD ĤZLĈWHF]Q\FK ]DNXSDFK" &]\ XGD PX
VLč SU]HSčG]Lþ ZãDP\ZDF]D"




3/1




0LFKDHO %RQG
0LĤ ]ZDQ\ 3DGGLQJWRQ


1D VWDFML NROHMRZHM 3DGGLQJWRQ Z /RQG\QLH SRMDZLD VLč PDã\
] DJXELRQ\ PLĤ 1D V]\L PD NDUWHF]Nč Å3URV]č ]DRSLHNRZDþ VLč
W\P QLHGĮZLDGNLHP ']LčNXMčµ &]\ PLĤ ]QDMG]LH GRP" &]\ SDęVWZR
%URZQ ]HFKFĈ SU]\MĈþ JR QD ]DZV]H"



3/1





1RUPDQ %ULGZHOO

&OLIIRUG :LHOND NVLčJD SU]\JyG


3R UD] SLHUZV]\ ]DPHUGDã RJRQHP Z NVLĈİFH 1RUPDQD %ULGZHOOD
Z URNX : URNX ZV]HGã ] ãDSDPL GR WHOHZL]ML 7HQ Z\MĈWNRZR
GXİ\ SVLDN PD WDOHQW GR ZSDGDQLD Z WDUDSDW\




3/1






1RUPDQ %ULGZHOO
&OLIIRUG :LHONL F]HUZRQ\ SLHV


:V]\VWNLH G]LHFL NRFKDMĈ &OLIIRUGD ² ZLHONLHJR F]HUZRQHJR SVD
3LHUZV]D NODV\F]QD KLVWRULD R ZDV]\P RJURPQ\P F]ZRURQRİQ\P
SU]\MDFLHOX NWyU\ ]DZV]H MHVW JRWyZ GR ]DEDZ\



3/1








_ ZZZ ]QDN FRP SO _ VNOHS#]QDN FRP SO

0LFKDHO %RQG
3DGGLQJWRQ ]D JUDQLFĈ



1RZH Z\GDQLH SU]\JyG QLHGĮZLDGND ] GDOHNLHJR 3HUX

0Dã\ ]DJXELRQ\ PLĤ WUDILã GR SDęVWZD %URZQ L QD GREUH VLč
]DGRPRZLã $ WHUD] UD]HP ] QLPL Z\MHİGİD QD ZDNDFMH GR
)UDQFML &]\ VSRGRED PX VLč SRGUyİ VDPRORWHP"
&]\ EčG]LH FKFLDã VSUyERZDþ ĤOLPDNyZ" -DN ]DNRęF]\ VLč
MHJR ZL]\WD X ZUyİNL"




3/1







6HDQ &RYH\
QDZ\NyZ V]F]čĤOLZHJR G]LHFND


3R]QDMFLH SU]\MDFLyã ] NUDLQ\ 6LHGPLX 'čEyZ NWyU]\ ZDP Z W\P
SRPRJĈ :LWHN QDXF]\ RUJDQL]DFML F]DVX .XGãDWHN SU]HNRQD
İH ZDUWR RNUHĤOLþ VRELH FHO G]LDãDQLD /LOND ]ZUyFL XZDJč QD
ZVSyãSUDFč ] LQQ\PL D :DQG]LD SU]\SRPQL GODF]HJR ZDUWR
]DGEDþ R VLHELH

2ERZLĈ]NRZ\ W\WXã GOD ZV]\VWNLFK URG]LFyZ L G]LHFL ² MXİ Z 3ROVFH




3/1







-LP 6PLWK
1LH ]H PQĈ WDNLH WHUH IHUH



0RMH İ\FLH ]DZV]H E\ãR VXSHU ² PLDãHP QDMOHSV]HJR NXPSOD
%ĈF]ND L QDOHİDãHP GR IDMQ\FK G]LHFLDNyZ
$OH« RGNĈG Z V]NROH SRMDZLã VLč 'DUHN 'DUHQRZVNL ]H VZRMĈ
SDVNXGQĈ NURNRG\OĈ JčEĈ QLH GDMH PL İ\þ




3/1











_ ZZZ ]QDN FRP SO _ VNOHS#]QDN FRP SO









/7<'7/ *+5614;%<0' /+#56# -4#-19#

DQ NGMELG JKUVQTKK PKG OWU\Ȱ D[Ȳ PWFPGų

/W\GWO *KUVQT[E\PG /KCUVC -TCMQYC VQ OKGLUEG FNC %KGDKGК 6Q 0QYQE\GUPG /W\GWO OKGLUMKG ::+
YKGMW MVȡTG Y MKNMWPCUVW QFF\KCCEJ QRQYKCFC JKUVQTKɂ -TCMQYC \ TȡʝP[EJ RGTURGMV[Y QF
ɺTGFPKQYKGE\C FQ E\CUȡY YURȡE\GUP[EJ 6W QFD[YCLȰ UKɂ PCLNGRU\G PCLEKGMCYU\G K CMV[YPG NGMELG
JKUVQTKKК 2Q\PCL PCU\Ȱ DQICVC QHGTVɂ GFWMCE[LPȰ CFTGUQYCPȰ FQ F\KGEK Y TȡʝP[O YKGMW



/W\GWO *KUVQT[E\PG /KCUVC -TCMQYC 2CCE -T\[U\VQHQT[
4[PGM )ȡYP[ -TCMȡY
%GPVTWO 1DUWIK <YKGF\CLȰE[EJ VGN


YYY OJM RN ^ KPHQ"OJM RN

24<'&5<-1.# + 5<-1Œ;



/W\GWO *KUVQT[E\PG /KCUVC -TCMQYC RTQRQPWLG U\GTQMK Y[DȡT NGMELK K YCTU\VCVȡY CFTGUQYCP[EJ FQ F\KGEK
PC MCʝF[O U\E\GDNW GFWMCELK \CE\[PCLȰE QF RT\GFU\MQNK MQɧE\ȰE PC WE\PKCEJ U\Mȡ RQPCFIKOPC\LCNP[EJ
#MV[YPC Y[OKCPC O[ɺNK RTCEC Y \CD[VMQY[EJ YPɂVT\CEJ RT\[ Y[MQT\[UVCPKW OW\GCNP[EJ TGMYK\[VȡY
URT\[LC TQ\YKLCPKW MTGCV[YPQɺEK RQDWF\C EKGMCYQɺȲ C RT\GFG YU\[UVMKO WYTCʝNKYKC OQF[EJ
WE\GUVPKMȡY \CLɂȲ PC RQ\PCYCPKG RKɂMPC VTCF[ELK MWNVWT[ K YKGNQYKGMQYGL JKUVQTKK -TCMQYC


9 EGNW FQMQPCPKC TG\GTYCELK NGMELK
YCTU\VCVȡY NWD URCEGTW PCNGʝ[
UMQPVCMVQYCȲ UKɂ \ YCɺEKY[O
QFF\KCGO /W\GWO *KUVQT[E\PGIQ
/KCUVC -TCMQYC Y MVȡT[O FQEGNQYQ
QFDɂFȰ UKɂ \CLɂEKC
0WWOGT[ MQPVCMVQYG QTC\ CFTGU[ G OCKN
0
\PCLF\KGEKG 2CɧUVYQ Y \CMCFEG
1&&<+#Œ;






%'00+-


NGMELG OW\GCNPG \ ITWRC
YCTU\VCV[ \ ITWRC
NGMELG Y VGTGPKG \ ITWRC
NGMELG Y U\MQNG \ ITWRC
QRTQYCF\CPKG RQ Y[UVCYCEJ UVC[EJ
\ ITWRC DKNGV YUVɂRW
QR QRTQYCF\CPKG RQ Y[UVCYCEJ

E\CUQY[EJ Y QFF\KCCEJ 2CCE RQF
-T\[U\VQHQT[ &\KGLG 0QYGL *WV[ K &QO
<YKGT\[PKGEMK \ ITWRC DKNGV
YUVɂRW
QRTQYCF\CPKG RQ Y[UVCYKG UVCGL
Y QFF\KCNG QFF\KCNG (CDT[MC 'OCNKC 1UMCTC
Y
5EJKPFNGTC ť WUWIC Y EGPKG DKNGVW
WUWIC RT\GYQFPKMC Y QFF\KCNG
2QF\KGOKC 4[PMW \ ITWRC DKNGV
YUVɂRW
\CLɂEKC \ -T\[U\ \CLɂEKC \ -T\[U\VQHQTMKGO NWD

&QTQVMȰ MQU\V YCTU\VCVȡY \ \C
WF\KC CMVQTC QF ITWR[
















YYY OJM RN

41&<+%' < &<+'ȱ/+



<CDCYC MVȡTC WE\[ VQ JCUQ RT\GYQFPKG E[MNW URQVMCɧ FNC F\KGEK 9 KEJ VTCMEKG OCNK QFMT[YE[ RQ\PCLȰ
RQRT\G\ IT[ \CDCY[ URCEGT[ K URQVMCPKC YCTU\VCVQYG VCLGOPKEG K UGMTGV[ OCIKE\PGIQ -TCMQYC 0C
PCLOQFU\[EJ QFYKGF\CLȰE[EJ /W\GWO E\GMCLȰ Y EKȰIW TQMW TȡYPKGʝ KPPG EKGMCYG RTQRQ\[ELG VCMKG
EJQEKCʝD[ LCM HGTKG E\[ NCVQ Y OW\GWO

/7<'1/#0+# 9 MCʝF[O TQMW U\MQNP[O \CRTCU\CO[ PC E[MN \CLɂȲ FNC F\KGEK K OQF\KGʝ[ Y TCOCEJ
/W\GQOCPKK #MCFGOKC /CGIQ 1FMT[YE[ QTC\ #MCFGOKC /CGIQ 1FMT[YE[ ':64#К /C[ YKGNMK
-TCMȡY 6CLGOPKE\[ MWHGT 5Ȱ VQ MTGCV[YPG URQVMCPKC YCTU\VCVQYG QTC\ URCEGT[ OKGLUMKG %Q TQM
PQY[ RTQITCOК 9KɂEGL PC YYY OJM RN OW\GQOCPKC


#MCFGOKC /CGIQ 1FMT[YE[


2TQITCO FGF[MQYCP[ YU\[UVMKO IQFP[O YKGF\[ K YTCʝGɧ OC[O
QFMT[YEQO Y YKGMW NCV QTC\ KEJ TQF\KEQO MVȡT\[ Y CMV[YP[ K VYȡTE\[
URQUȡD RTCIPȰ RQ\PCYCȲ -TCMȡY Y[TCUVCLȰE V[O UCO[O PC RTCYF\KY[EJ
\PCYEȡY C \CTC\GO OKQɺPKMȡY LGIQ F\KGLȡY K MWNVWTQYGIQ F\KGF\KEVYC
2QFQDPKG LCM -T\[U\VQHQTGM K &QTQVMC ť DQJCVGTQYKG OW\GCNPGIQ E\CUQRKUOC
Ů-T\[U\VQHQTGMŭ ť MVȡT\[ YURȡNPKG \ F\KGȲOK WE\GUVPKE\Ȱ Y Y[DTCP[EJ \CLɂEKCEJ





/C[ YKGNMK -TCMȡY


%[MN OKGLUMKEJ URCEGTȡY FNC F\KGEK Y YKGMW ť NCV QTC\ KEJ TQF\KEȡY
6TCU[ K VGOCV[MC URCEGTȡY UȰ VCM RT\GO[ɺNCPG CD[ Y OQFU\[EJ WE\GUVPKMCEJ
Y\DWF\KȲ EKGMCYQɺȲ ɺYKCVC K \COKQYCPKG FQ QFMT[YCPKC VCLGOPKE -TCMQYC
9[EKGE\MK VTYCLȰ PKGEQ RQPCF IQF\KPɂ




6CLGOPKE\[ MWHGT

2TQITCO UMKGTQYCP[ FQ MTGCV[YP[EJ K EKGMCY[EJ ɺYKCVC OCNWEJȡY Y YKGMW
NCV QTC\ KEJ TQF\KEȡY MVȡT\[ RTCIPȰ YURKGTCȲ YU\GEJUVTQPP[ TQ\YȡL UYQKEJ
RQEKGEJ LWʝ QF PCLOQFU\[EJ NCV -CʝFG URQVMCPKG MQPEGPVTWLG UKɂ PC Y[DTCP[O
RT\GFOKQEKG ť ɺYKCFMW OKPKQP[EJ YKGMȡY K RQ\YCNC F\KGEKQO PC UVCYKCPKG
RKGTYU\[EJ MTQMȡY Y ɺYKGEKG RT\GU\QɺEK <CEJɂEC KEJ V[O UCO[O FQ
KPVGTCMV[YPGIQ RQ\PCYCPKC JKUVQTKK K MWNVWT[ -TCMQYC



#MCFGOKC /CGIQ 1FMT[YE[ ':64#К

2TQITCO FGF[MQYCP[ YU\[UVMKO IQFP[O YKGF\[
K YTCʝGɧ OC[O QFMT[YEQO QTC\ KEJ TQF\KEQO MVȡT\[
Y CMV[YP[ K VYȡTE\[ URQUȡD RTCIPȰ RQ\PCYCȲ -TCMȡY
Y[TCUVCLȰE V[O UCO[O PC RTCYF\KY[EJ \PCYEȡY
C \CTC\GO OKQɺPKMȡY LGIQ F\KGLȡY K MWNVWTQYGIQ
F\KGF\KEVYC 2QFQDPKG LCM -T\[U\VQHQTGM K &QTQVMC ť
DQJCVGTQYKG OW\GCNPGIQ E\CUQRKUOC Ů-T\[U\VQHQTGMŭ ť
M
MVVȡT\[ YURȡNPKG \ F\KGȲOK WE\GUVPKE\Ȱ Y Y[DTCP[EJ
\CLɂEKCEJ
YYY OJM RN

-4<;5<61(14'-



%\[VCLК $CY UKɂК <YKGF\CL -TCMȡYК %\CUQRKUOQ FNC /C[EJ 1FMT[YEȡY MVȡT\[ YTC\ \ LGIQ DQJCVGTCOK
ť -T\[U\VQHQTMKGO K &QTQVMȰ QFMT[YCLȰ RT\GU\QɺȲ FCYPGL UVQNKE[ RCɧUVYC -T\[U\VQHQTGM VQ
DQICEVYQ VTGɺEK IT[ K \CDCY[ QTC\ YURCPKCC U\CVC ITCƓE\PC








































52'-6#-.' &.# &<+'%+ 9 9+'-7 .#6


9 EKȰIW TQMW QFD[YC UKɂ MKNMCPCɺEKG URGMVCMNK Q TȡʝPGL VGOCV[EG \ -T\[U\VQHQTMKGO K &QTQVMȰ Y TQNK
IȡYPGL 9 DCTYP[ K F[PCOKE\P[ URQUȡD RT\GFUVCYKCLȰ TȡʝPG JKUVQTKG \CD[VMQYGIQ -TCMQYC
2T\Gʝ[L \ PCOK YURCPKCȰ RT\[IQFɂК






















YYY OJM RN ^ KPHQ"OJM RN


/W\GWO *KUVQT[E\PG /KCUVC -TCMQYC 2CCE -T\[U\VQHQT[
4[PGM )ȡYP[ -TCMȡY
%GPVTWO 1DUWIK <YKGF\CLȰE[EJ VGN

















HWPMELQPCNPQɮȦ GUVGV[MC 6YQLG \CFQYQNGPKG







9KVCO[ PC UVTQPKG ƒTO[ /'6.+0' ,GUVGɮO[ FQUVCYEȤ Y[UQMKGL
LCMQɮEK OGDNK Wʑ[VMQY[EJ MVȕTG QF\PCE\CLȤ UKȶ RQPCFRT\GEKȶVPȤ
GUVGV[MȤ QTC\ Y[LȤVMQYȤ HWPMELQPCNPQɮEKȤ 9[TQD[ RQYUVCLȤ PC
DC\KG FQDT[EJ ICVWPMQYQ OCVGTKCȕY Y[MQɛE\QP[EJ Y Y[UQMKO
UVCPFCTF\KG F\KȶMK E\GOW QF\PCE\CLȤ UKȶ QFRQTPQɮEKȤ PC F\KCCPKG
E\[PPKMȕY \GYPȶVT\P[EJ QTC\ WU\MQF\GPKC OGEJCPKE\PG




U\CHMK WDTCPKQYG $*2
U\CHMK ɮPKCFCPKQYG

U\CHMK FGRQ\[VQYG

U\CHMK PC QF\KGʑ E\[UVȤ DTWFPȤ

U\CH[ CMVQYG

U\CH[ MCTVQVGMQYG

ICDNQV[ QIQU ICDNQV[ QIQU\GPKQYG






5\CHMK FQ U\Mȕ




K RT\GFU\MQNK









$T\G\KPMC WN 5QPGE\PC
#PFT[EJȕY
KPHQNKPKC
HCZ
VGN
G OCKN DKWTQ"OGVNKPG EQO RN

YYY UMNGR OGVNKPG EQO RN

HWPMELQPCNPQɮȦ GUVGV[MC 6YQLG \CFQYQNGPKG







9KVCO[ PC UVTQPKG ƒTO[ /'6.+0' ,GUVGɮO[ FQUVCYEȤ Y[UQMKGL
LCMQɮEK OGDNK Wʑ[VMQY[EJ MVȕTG QF\PCE\CLȤ UKȶ RQPCFRT\GEKȶVPȤ
GUVGV[MȤ QTC\ Y[LȤVMQYȤ HWPMELQPCNPQɮEKȤ 9[TQD[ RQYUVCLȤ PC
DC\KG FQDT[EJ ICVWPMQYQ OCVGTKCȕY Y[MQɛE\QP[EJ Y Y[UQMKO
UVCPFCTF\KG F\KȶMK E\GOW QF\PCE\CLȤ UKȶ QFRQTPQɮEKȤ PC F\KCCPKG
E\[PPKMȕY \GYPȶVT\P[EJ QTC\ WU\MQF\GPKC OGEJCPKE\PG




U\CHMK WDTCPKQYG $*2
U\CHMK ɮPKCFCPKQYG

U\CHMK FGRQ\[VQYG

U\CHMK PC QF\KGʑ E\[UVȤ DTWFPȤ

U\CH[ CMVQYG

U\CH[ MCTVQVGMQYG

ICDNQV[ QIQU ICDNQV[ QIQU\GPKQYG






5\CHMK FQ U\Mȕ




K RT\GFU\MQNK









$T\G\KPMC WN 5QPGE\PC
#PFT[EJȕY
KPHQNKPKC
HCZ
VGN
G OCKN DKWTQ"OGVNKPG EQO RN

YYY UMNGR OGVNKPG EQO RN

HWPMELQPCNPQɮȦ GUVGV[MC 6YQLG \CFQYQNGPKG











QQȦ
0Yɮ
W U
P C F T M P C \ C H CJ
ME














































$T\G\KPMC WN 5QPGE\PC
#PFT[EJȕY
KPHQNKPKC
HCZ
VGN
G OCKN DKWTQ"OGVNKPG EQO RN

YYY UMNGR OGVNKPG EQO RN

HWPMELQPCNPQɮȦ GUVGV[MC 6YQLG \CFQYQNGPKG











QQȦ
0Yɮ
W U
P C F T M P C \ C H CJ
ME














































$T\G\KPMC WN 5QPGE\PC
#PFT[EJȕY
KPHQNKPKC
HCZ
VGN
G OCKN DKWTQ"OGVNKPG EQO RN

YYY UMNGR OGVNKPG EQO RN